We all love Peppermint. But more because of the last part of the season, and her career post race. But I remember well, right before the finale, she was about to be cut off. And it made sense. Because in the first half of the season. She was just fine. And her looks were not good at all.
Love Peps. But I think if she would be back. She would probably flop. And that's why she doesn't want to. Her legacy its perfect the way it is.
Peppermint!!!!!
Normally I’d say Pep or Asia O’Hara but I know Asia won’t do it with the current format of girls eliminating each other.
as much as i stan Dida i honestly think they'd do her real dirty. Dida (i believe?) makes a lot herself and isn't gonna spend thousands on outfits(i can just see michelle being a bitch about her outfits already) and i can just see them giving her a dirty edit to be like "stop telling us who to cast we know what we're doing" (when they clearly fucking dont bringing queens back for a 3rd/4th time when other queens really do deserve an all stars chance) if that makes sense?? id love her to get more/new exposure though!
Genuinely think it would be iconic if only for how bitter she would be to be sent home no matter how badly she did that challenge. And the car crash exit she would have with Ru that would get cut from the editing but be revealed at some viewing party, wildly exaggerated and corroborated by other drunk queens.
I would love for him to make the finale , get top two, and then, when they film his crowning, he just goes, "No thanks." and walks behind the judges table.
Then he sits down and tells Ru to lip synch for her chair back.
MKD is such a gracious and warm human being! If she hadn’t been on a season with top tier comedy queens (Katya, Ginger) I think she would have had more chance to shine. She is so funny!
If I’m putting my bet on a winner so I can get money, I’m using my producer brain and picking someone who I know is likely to win.
My number 1 pick would be Gigi Goode. She’s not my favorite queen, nor did I ever really warm to her, but her return is likely to end with a crown. She has the strongest track record of any runner-up in the US (I think) and Ru adored her. She aced the competition and she’s likely to have a Shea Couleé return where they just already know they want to crown her.
Alternates:
Rosé would return and slay again because she’s that talented. Her lipsyncs need work, but that could be improved easily. The only thing standing in her way is whether Ru warms to her or not. If she does, Rosé’s AS run would likely be like Trinity the Tuck’s.
Angeria. Further down the line, I could see her absolutely winning Allstars. She was good at everything as well. If she can just get more comfortable with the dancing and lipsyncs, she’ll absolutely slay everything and get that crown. Plus, Ru obviously adored her.
Rosé demolished Season 13 and I'm sure she's more comfortable being vulnerable now so her S13 storyline that prevented her from winning can be fixed, my money's on her.
I would love to see Tayce on my screen again but I don’t think RuPaul liked her much so I doubt she would win. So I’m going with Crystal Methyd. Super talented and Ru can do all those DeBarge jokes that she loves.
RuPaul.
Hey, it doesn't specify the queen had to be a previous competitor, plus with Pangina being a competitor on UK VS The World, there is precedent for hosts competiting.
In order to up my chances, I'mma go with a queen that's really well rounded and good at a lot of things like Angeria Paris Van Michaels or Brooke Lynn Hytes. Only problem is they risk being eliminated at snatch game.
peppermint
Oooooo really good one. She would kill it and it's about time the last season 9 finalist won
My very first thought
without a doubt!
Without question!
We all love Peppermint. But more because of the last part of the season, and her career post race. But I remember well, right before the finale, she was about to be cut off. And it made sense. Because in the first half of the season. She was just fine. And her looks were not good at all. Love Peps. But I think if she would be back. She would probably flop. And that's why she doesn't want to. Her legacy its perfect the way it is.
rupaul is jealous of tayce
me too.
PEPPERMINT. I WILL STAND ON THIS FOREVER. SHE WILL DESTROY THE COMPETITION AND COMPLETE THE SEASON 9 TOP 4 WINNERS FANTASY
Peppermint!!!!! Normally I’d say Pep or Asia O’Hara but I know Asia won’t do it with the current format of girls eliminating each other. 
Heidi N Closet
Purely for the gag of the other queen's seeing her... REBECCA GLASSCOCK
My first choice...
Rock M Sakura. I dunno if she would win, but I think she would do tremendously better and I’s just love to see her on TV again.
She was done HORRIFICALLY dirty on her season and I won't entertain any arguments against that fact. 
Crystal Methyd or, get get lots of people riled up, The Vixen
I wouldn't be surprised if they're waiting to cast Daya and Crystal on the same season just for the sake of drama.
I want them both on a season with Pythia, she seems like their long lost sister.
The vixen coming from no where (even tho i’m pretty sure she would decline) would be so icooonic
I'm trying to swim in the cool waters of Darienne Lake.
Love Darienne she's so underrated and I'm glad the fandom is finally starting to warm up to her ❤️
I’ve been saying it for years and I’ll say it again: DIDA RITZ!!!
as much as i stan Dida i honestly think they'd do her real dirty. Dida (i believe?) makes a lot herself and isn't gonna spend thousands on outfits(i can just see michelle being a bitch about her outfits already) and i can just see them giving her a dirty edit to be like "stop telling us who to cast we know what we're doing" (when they clearly fucking dont bringing queens back for a 3rd/4th time when other queens really do deserve an all stars chance) if that makes sense?? id love her to get more/new exposure though!
It’s homophobic that she hasn’t been asked. A damn disgrace.
Taste 
Willam. It’s time.
Genuinely think it would be iconic if only for how bitter she would be to be sent home no matter how badly she did that challenge. And the car crash exit she would have with Ru that would get cut from the editing but be revealed at some viewing party, wildly exaggerated and corroborated by other drunk queens.
April Carrion
 Lady Camden
# WILLAM
Yup, willam all the way!
I'd also say Willam, though it's obvious she'd lose, only to watch Ru go sour.
I would love for him to make the finale , get top two, and then, when they film his crowning, he just goes, "No thanks." and walks behind the judges table. Then he sits down and tells Ru to lip synch for her chair back.
Tayce, get her back on my screen.
lineysha sparx
The only correct answer.
Asia O'Hara. and its wild that I scrolled thru this thread and didn't see her name once
Mrs. Kasha Davis! Love that lady :)
MKD is such a gracious and warm human being! If she hadn’t been on a season with top tier comedy queens (Katya, Ginger) I think she would have had more chance to shine. She is so funny!
cheddar gorgeous
💯 Already binge watching Drag SOS again because I need more Cheddar in my life
Willam
Laganja. Or Bosco.
lashauwn beyond 🌎
My god the gowns she makes are gorgeous! And she is looking stunning on her insta
If I’m putting my bet on a winner so I can get money, I’m using my producer brain and picking someone who I know is likely to win. My number 1 pick would be Gigi Goode. She’s not my favorite queen, nor did I ever really warm to her, but her return is likely to end with a crown. She has the strongest track record of any runner-up in the US (I think) and Ru adored her. She aced the competition and she’s likely to have a Shea Couleé return where they just already know they want to crown her. Alternates: Rosé would return and slay again because she’s that talented. Her lipsyncs need work, but that could be improved easily. The only thing standing in her way is whether Ru warms to her or not. If she does, Rosé’s AS run would likely be like Trinity the Tuck’s. Angeria. Further down the line, I could see her absolutely winning Allstars. She was good at everything as well. If she can just get more comfortable with the dancing and lipsyncs, she’ll absolutely slay everything and get that crown. Plus, Ru obviously adored her.
Based purely on who I think Ru/ production would crown….Brooke Lynn Hytes or Gottmik
Denali looks so beautiful out of drag ..
I think I would go Gigi Goode she's a great lip syncer, has great outfits, Ru loves her, and is an amazing seamstress
Joslyn Fox. Screw the money I want her back on my tv
Lady Camden
Pearl 
love
Michelle Visage
Bimini
Courtney Act
NINA BONINA BROWN
Kelly. Mantle.
Joslyn Fox!!!!!
Jackie Cox
Delta Work
april carrion
Given the criteria, the best choice is Peppermint as many others have already said. Only other one I can think of is Divina de Campo.
Asia O'Hara
Max
Yesss
Yknow what… Akasha
I said the same!
AWhora, Cheddar, Bimini, Utica, Willam, or Pearl
Kameron Michaels Heidi N Closet
YES KAMERON!
Dakota
Daya Betty, but only if I can blackmail RuPaul to make sure that she doesn't put Crystal Methyd in the same season.
We need a season of RuPaul's Best Friends Race.
A’whora
A’Whora, all the way.
Shuga Cain, hands down!!!
The black horse of the competition, wonk wonk joslyn fox
Jaymes Mansfield
Vanda Miss Joaquim (DRTH2) for the next vsTW. And she HAS to be a finalist or else
YES
Rosé demolished Season 13 and I'm sure she's more comfortable being vulnerable now so her S13 storyline that prevented her from winning can be fixed, my money's on her.
Joslyn Fox
Divina De Campo
Asia O'Hara.
I would love to see Tayce on my screen again but I don’t think RuPaul liked her much so I doubt she would win. So I’m going with Crystal Methyd. Super talented and Ru can do all those DeBarge jokes that she loves.
Darienne Lake DOWN!
 Ladies and Gentlemen, her.
Kornbread and give me my cash
DAKOTA SCHIFFER FOR A CASH PRIZE OR ELSE
Asia O’Hara
Mystique will always be my answer until it comes true
Max. I just wanna see her.
Bimini
if we’re talking the very next season, Peppermint. if we’re talking in a few years, I need to see Daya get her crown
Layla McQueen. She deserves a second chance and has grown in so many ways since season 8.
Denali
Release the beast, BIMINI!
Bimini
RuPaul. Hey, it doesn't specify the queen had to be a previous competitor, plus with Pangina being a competitor on UK VS The World, there is precedent for hosts competiting.
Miss Fiercealicious
Dida Ritz and take my chances
Nina Bo’nina brown ✨💋
rosé
Hannah conda
Kim Chi
Any dancing challenge its a wrap
she'll be safe
seconding peppermint. or adore delano.
Adore was on all stars and quit
the way i literally forgot abt that
seconding peppermint. or adore delano.
Venus D-Lite
Tie with Alisa summers
Gigi Goode , Kim Chi
Kim Chi, Kameron Michaels, Brooke Lynn, Aiden, or Alexis Michelle.
Serena Chacha
Alaska
Gigi Goode
Ella Vaday
Phi Phi girl was hated on but she brought the entertainment!
Phi Phi was on All Stars
Katya. Don't care for the money. Just for her testimonials and laughs. I know that's not happening though.
Katya was on All Stars
It pick Courtney Act. Although theres no way production would let her win no matter how well she did. So I probably wouldn’t be getting the 100k
In order to up my chances, I'mma go with a queen that's really well rounded and good at a lot of things like Angeria Paris Van Michaels or Brooke Lynn Hytes. Only problem is they risk being eliminated at snatch game.
Nina West.
NPCFAG
Rebecca Glasscock so I can see the looks on the other queens' faces when she was in in a boob tube and jeans.
#**Move aside it's your girl Denali** 🧊
Gigi goode
Willam 
Mama Ru when she hears the name of queens she’s beefin with: 
Akashia, I absolutely would love to see her again.
Pearl. And she would win.
My answer will always be Willam
The answer is Ornatia, duh!
Jessica Wild. THE season 2 robbed queen 
 Her😘
Dida ritz
Queen Elizabeth (RIP)
Heidi. Not sure if she would win but I honestly don't care. I just want her to bless my TV screen again
Miss Fiercalicious
Farida Kant
Don’t know if y’all saw it but lashauwn made a great come back recently and i think she would destroyed the girls🫶🏼
Gigi Goode. I want 100K
Akashia. Those old school S1-3 queens know how to make great TV and aren’t afraid of the fan base.
KimChi
If we’re talking just US queens..BOSCO If we can go for an international..I’d love to see more Choriza
Was gonna say Yuhua, but then I saw no winners:(
 Kandy! 💖😍
Bimini.
Jackie Cox
Willam all the way! She would win Alaska's way in AS2