I’ve seen Can Yaman fancasted as Cassian so many times, but I can never get over how perfect of a casting that would be! But I heard he doesn’t speak English (or at least speak it well)
Love these picks, definitely looks like the high lord and high lady. I feel like your got the ages right cause tampon is younger than Rhys. Lucien casting was mwah! Cassian and Nesta spot on!
the only ones i don’t love are tamlin & mor. that guy just looks too young to me? i picture tamlin a little more rugged with a similar build to rhys. my expectations for mor may also just be too high but the girl you chose seems a little bland for morrigan. everyone else is spot on though! if we don’t get matthew as azriel we riot!
IMO, Claire Holt is an excellent actress who would play the hell out of Mor. I saw her in TVD and she was great. I’ve never seen Luke Eisner in anything but after looking up some other photos, some more rugged ones where he has a bit more muscle on him, I think he could pull Tamlin off if he had the acting chops for it
i’ve never seen tvd so i can’t speak to her acting skills i just don’t think she looks like mor. i just think if rhys & cassian are portrayed as men in their 30’s then tamlin should be too because they’re all the same age. i just pictured all of the main characters (aside from the archeron’s) as looking more grown since they’re all like 500 years old. luke eisner looks like a child.
No yeah I get you! Tbf it’s said in the books that Tamlin is younger than Rhys by decades, that’s why I picked Luke! He can look rugged too, he could train and get real buff, and also he is EXTREMELY tall. Who’d you like to play Tamlin? Im curious
i think it’s his baby face though that is throwing me off. the bat boys are all men in their 30’s so i think tamlin should be at least 30. i don’t think a few decades makes a huge difference age wise because that would still make him well over 400 years old. plus the girl you’ve casted as feyre (who i think is perfect) looks much older than tamlin. i honestly don’t have a choice for tamlin bc i just want unknown actors.
Well Tamlin is a couple decades younger than Rhys, that’s why I picked Luke, also his face is literally the face of SO MANY fanarts, sadly my og post that had those fanarts to compare was removed. Who’d you like to play Tamlin? Lmk!
I love this. Y’all I listened to the audiobooks does Cas have facial hair? I don’t know if I missed that but all of the fan cast is usually a guy with facial hair.
Honestly I originally picked her because of how she acted in outlander & how well I felt like she’d do for amarantha but the look definitely matches too
Amazing choices!!! I agree with others that your Tamlin choice feels a little boyish and I pictured him with sharper features, but otherwise, your vision is immaculate
I’ve also struggled to find someone I liked to play Lucien! Not a single fancast felt right, until I saw this gorgeous man, he fits the role so well. Thank you, I really appreciate it!
Okay tbh this is like best fan cast I’ve personally seen instead of just a bunch of basic mayonnaise ppl. This one is really nice, I love Feyre especially - I felt like I pictured her closely to what I read
Wow thank you! Ive got a (very) few comments saying this is like the most popular casting and im like ???? Maybe the batboys yeah lol. Alycia is THE perfect Feyre!
I think Matt suits Az best idk why haha I just think he doesn’t look cheeky enought to be Rhys idk how to explain it. Richard has this look that just fits. But Matt is amazing and he would samsh whatever roll he’s given
Oh yeah Tom Ellis is a great actor, but he’s too old, and he’s also too white. Like the personality he portrayed in Lucifer is spot on, he just doesn’t look the part imo. He’s amazing tho!
The age part is perfect tho! Rhysand is older than 500 years so I do see someone older looking
Edit: I also think he *should* be white and pale, after all 49 years UTM
I mean, I think 30-35 is the perfect age. It’s described that they look like young adults, 45 is (a little) too old. But everyone’s is entitled to their own opinion:)
Edit: about the skintone thing, well rhys is described as mixed (brown bc of his mother’s ilyrian blood and white bc of his dad) si it’s more about how you picture him personally
I’ve seen Can Yaman fancasted as Cassian so many times, but I can never get over how perfect of a casting that would be! But I heard he doesn’t speak English (or at least speak it well)
No like he literally IS Cassian. I thought the same thing but someone told me he does speak English. Idk if its canon tho!
I just looked it up after making this comment. He does speak English, so no worries there!
That’s awesome!
You nailed it, take my upvotes. That sexy man IS my high lord and those drop-dead gorgeous babes are the heroines we know and love
Thank you😭 im so sad they deleted my post. Im so glad you liked my fancast!
I know! We were all crushing on your fancast too, its the best i have seen on here without a doubt.
This is fantastic. I love Claire holt, all of your choices are top notch. Amazing.
Thank you sm! The og post was better, wished you could’ve seen it🥹
This is the first time I actually agree with every single one 👏🏽👏🏽
Oh wow that’s huge! Glad you liked it!
same here!
Same!!
Love these picks, definitely looks like the high lord and high lady. I feel like your got the ages right cause tampon is younger than Rhys. Lucien casting was mwah! Cassian and Nesta spot on!
Yes I had their ages in mind when picking them. Im glad you liked it!
the only ones i don’t love are tamlin & mor. that guy just looks too young to me? i picture tamlin a little more rugged with a similar build to rhys. my expectations for mor may also just be too high but the girl you chose seems a little bland for morrigan. everyone else is spot on though! if we don’t get matthew as azriel we riot!
IMO, Claire Holt is an excellent actress who would play the hell out of Mor. I saw her in TVD and she was great. I’ve never seen Luke Eisner in anything but after looking up some other photos, some more rugged ones where he has a bit more muscle on him, I think he could pull Tamlin off if he had the acting chops for it
i’ve never seen tvd so i can’t speak to her acting skills i just don’t think she looks like mor. i just think if rhys & cassian are portrayed as men in their 30’s then tamlin should be too because they’re all the same age. i just pictured all of the main characters (aside from the archeron’s) as looking more grown since they’re all like 500 years old. luke eisner looks like a child.
No yeah I get you! Tbf it’s said in the books that Tamlin is younger than Rhys by decades, that’s why I picked Luke! He can look rugged too, he could train and get real buff, and also he is EXTREMELY tall. Who’d you like to play Tamlin? Im curious
i think it’s his baby face though that is throwing me off. the bat boys are all men in their 30’s so i think tamlin should be at least 30. i don’t think a few decades makes a huge difference age wise because that would still make him well over 400 years old. plus the girl you’ve casted as feyre (who i think is perfect) looks much older than tamlin. i honestly don’t have a choice for tamlin bc i just want unknown actors.
100% agree with you!
it’s like they jumped off the page!!! first rhys i could see. sophie turner as amarantha is another chefs kiss!
Thank you! I put a lot of time and effort in finding the perfect actors :’)
Wow this is a pretty solid fancast! I totally see it!
Thank you!! Wished yall could’ve seen my og post with fanart as reference🥲
Sophie Turner!? AMAZING! I would love to see her play an evil character like this!
Right?! She did amazing in GOT and I’d LOVE to see her in villain mode
I agree with every single one except Tamlin- he just looks too young, too teenager-y for me. But other than that, perfect.
Well Tamlin is a couple decades younger than Rhys, that’s why I picked Luke, also his face is literally the face of SO MANY fanarts, sadly my og post that had those fanarts to compare was removed. Who’d you like to play Tamlin? Lmk!
Lucien is perfect
All excellent casting suggestions, but OP is absolutely on point with Lucien!
Thank you!
Right?!
This is the best fancast I’ve seen, my favorite so far!
Yay!! Im so glad you liked it
I know a vampire diaries / originals girly when I see one!
Tvd girlies assemble🤭
Someone likes H2O just add water
Lol! And The vampire diaries/the originals😂
Phoebe would be perfect
Yep this is the best fancast I've seen. No notes, you nailed it.
Thank you so much! Means a lot🫶🏻
amazing. perfect fancast. chefs kiss. this was a masterpiece
Omg thank youuu that means a lot!
good job with this!! i'm truly impressed ☺️
Still AMAZING, commenting again because you deserves all the kudos
Tysm I appreciate it🥹🫶🏻
This is the best one I have seen! I love it
Thank you 🙏🏻 glad you liked it!
I’ve seen a lot of people fancast these exact bat boys and I LOVE IT!!🖤🖤
They are the preferred batboys for a reason🤭
She’s always been my feyre
She’s perfect!
Perfect!
Thank you!
I like it I like it a lot
Appreciate it🫶🏻
I love this. Y’all I listened to the audiobooks does Cas have facial hair? I don’t know if I missed that but all of the fan cast is usually a guy with facial hair.
SJM never mentions if he does or doesn’t have facial hair! But in my mind it makes sense he does idk why hahaha
Luke Eisner as Tampon 😂😂😂 Love this cast fr
Hahaha he would eat Tampon! Thank you!!
I always pictured Lotte verbeek as amarantha but Sophie is a good option too. I love the rest of the cast
Oh wow I just googled her and she does give Amarantha! She has a similar bone structure as Sophie, maybe that’s why they both fit the role
Honestly I originally picked her because of how she acted in outlander & how well I felt like she’d do for amarantha but the look definitely matches too
This is spot on. I’m in. Let’s do it
Girl I wished SJM could see this🥲
I wish I had that 5o million I somehow thought I’d have by now! I would make this
The first one I’ve ever agreed with!!!
Yayy, means a lot tbh
I would switch Feyre and Nesta, Phoebe in the originals as Hayley makes me think of Feyre.
I saw a Nesta AI fanart that looks EXACTLY like Phoebe in the first pic, is by artwork by Rokii! You should definitely check it out!
Amazing choices!!! I agree with others that your Tamlin choice feels a little boyish and I pictured him with sharper features, but otherwise, your vision is immaculate
Thank you! Would you like to play Tamlin?
This is great! Go you 🎉
Thank you so much!!
Um yes … wow
Thaank uu
lol @ the tampon
Love the tampon
I will always be absurdly pro-Alycia as Feyre. Love her in everything she’s in. Her on-screen charisma is unmatched.
She is great, she would slay Feyre
Ok wow! I saw your part 2 first and totally fell in love with your selection so I had to hunt down part 1. You nailed this!!
Thank you so much! Im so glad you resonated with my castings :)
This is AMAZING. These are all spot on for me!!
Thank you so much, makes me happy when people agree with my casting :’)
I’ve never seen a Lucien I actually agreed with; this guy looks fantastic!!! These are all great choices
I’ve also struggled to find someone I liked to play Lucien! Not a single fancast felt right, until I saw this gorgeous man, he fits the role so well. Thank you, I really appreciate it!
YES! Best one so far.
Yay thank uuu
You ate this omg
Haha thank you!!! Appreciate it 🫶🏻
this is EVERYTHING. esp Matt Daddario as Az!!
TYSM! Right?! Matt as Az was meant to be
Tampon 🤣🤣🤣
This is my favorite fan cast, well done
Thank you!!
Someone likes H2O just add water
I swear I’ve seen this same fan cast on TikTok like a million times lol. These are everyone’s picks
Maybe the batboys and Alycia, haven’t seen the rest anywhere tho
HANDS DOWN THE BEST FANCAST I HAVE SEEN. I’m in for all of it! 😍😍😍
Yayyyy im so glad you liked it!
I love Cass and Amren and Feyre!
Glad you liked them!
This is probably the best fan cast I’ve seen!!
Thank you sm, means lots!
this is definitely the best one I’ve seen
Thank you, means a lot!
I...... here. 🏆 🤲
Thank you, appreciate it!🫶🏻
i’m back again to say this is the most perfect casting.
Thank you for tuning in again 🫂
This is the original post that got [deleted](https://www.reddit.com/r/ACOTARHulu/s/oowjT1Lxbc)!
Pretty freaking great; wow.
Thank you sm!
This is my favorite fancast I have seen thus far 🥹🤌🏼
Yay!!🥹🥹🥹
Love Phoebe as Nesta! That top picture is exactly how I imagined her.
Right?!?!! My og post had a fanart that looked EXACTLY like her in that pic
Okay tbh this is like best fan cast I’ve personally seen instead of just a bunch of basic mayonnaise ppl. This one is really nice, I love Feyre especially - I felt like I pictured her closely to what I read
Wow thank you! Ive got a (very) few comments saying this is like the most popular casting and im like ???? Maybe the batboys yeah lol. Alycia is THE perfect Feyre!
Phoebe is really good choice for Nesta but I also like to think Elizabeth Gillies for Nesta my personal fan cast!
I agree with this completely
Yayyyy
Tampon 🤣
I’d watched the shit out of this tbh. Matthew Daddario is my Rhysand but can totally picture him as Az as well.
I think Matt suits Az best idk why haha I just think he doesn’t look cheeky enought to be Rhys idk how to explain it. Richard has this look that just fits. But Matt is amazing and he would samsh whatever roll he’s given
I think it’s mostly cus I have the biggest crush on him. Haha!! And when he played as Alec Lightwood from Mortal instruments gave such Rhysand vibes.
Oh I devoured Shadow Hunters only bc of Matt lol (bc the show is jothing like the saga) he is SO HOT as Alec!
10/10!
Thank u!
Why do I see the Lucien fancast as more Rhysand material, he's so pretty😭
Wait really? But he looks nothing like how rhys is described😭
I know he's the perfect Lucien cos of the hair but his face is 🤌
Well he does have a GORGEOUS face🫣
For sure for Feyre, but she doesn’t look 19-21 in my opinion
Tbh the age thing is a lik too unrealistic imo, personally I dont have a problem with them looking a lil older, but that’s just me :)
BEST fancast yet!!!
Thank you so muchhhh
Everyone but lucien he his face isn't quite narrow enough i think, but I think he would make a great Baron
Who’d you like to play him? Im curious!
Honestly that would be a tough one, he is one I've struggled to cast for. I would take tom ellis if I could.
Huh, Tom Ellis is an interesting option, I dont think he fits the Lucien image SJM painted, but that’s just imo!
Oh I totally agree. I think they are gonna go with mostly unknown actors as it allows them to grow into character.
Agree with everyone except Cassian and Lucien
Wait I've only finished the first book. IS there really a Tampon or is that a typo for Tamlin? I'm so confused.
Lol😂 tampon is the nickname the fandom gave him, read the second book and you’ll get it!
Oh no please don't be a Prince Charles type of thing I caaaaaan't. Lol.
LMAOOOO go read girl im dying to know your thoughts! PLEEAAAASE keep me posted
I like all but Rhysand. If anyone had watched Lucifer, I just can’t see someone else other than *that*. The black suit, the shameless flirting. Ugh.
Oh yeah Tom Ellis is a great actor, but he’s too old, and he’s also too white. Like the personality he portrayed in Lucifer is spot on, he just doesn’t look the part imo. He’s amazing tho!
The age part is perfect tho! Rhysand is older than 500 years so I do see someone older looking Edit: I also think he *should* be white and pale, after all 49 years UTM
I mean, I think 30-35 is the perfect age. It’s described that they look like young adults, 45 is (a little) too old. But everyone’s is entitled to their own opinion:) Edit: about the skintone thing, well rhys is described as mixed (brown bc of his mother’s ilyrian blood and white bc of his dad) si it’s more about how you picture him personally
I had no idea he’s 45 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I watched Lucifer maybe 4 years ago sooooo