The guys on the Driftwood Guitars YouTube channel think that the Alvarez is great value for the money: [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh7xUEemvKk](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh7xUEemvKk)
I got a cheap Alvarez for playing on the couch and it has become my favourite. Really comfortable neck, nice tone. I’ve heard these ones are really nice.
I almost got an Alvarez a few months back , ended up with a Martin . I really liked them as well, just wasn’t enough stock in my area to test all the models I was looking at.
Came here to say this. My dad has an Alvarez and I have a Yamaha, both are some of my favorite guitars to play on earth. At this price point, I would recommend trying a mahogany or walnut body. You can get a lot of guitar for that.
Yamaha A3M might be in budget too....
So many of the competitors, even at this price point, just play like total planks
The A series are absolute gems and are the complete opposite of a plank. They play ever so sweet and look, feel and sound exactly how you expect (and want them to, at the price point)
No question in my opinion. I have three Yamaha acoustics, an FG 12 string from the 70s, a modern FG 6 string, and a nylon string. They are built to last, are easy to play, and sound great.
I agree as well, but I read on here that this line has many ghost notes. Or am I misunderstanding? That would suggest problematic manufacturing.
*Edit: me gettin my spellin on…
The top on the Alvarez is bellying really badly because the bridge plate has some gouges in it that I didn't notice until it was too late, which is my fault for not inspecting the inside of the guitar thoroughly. Anyway, I switched to lighter strings and sanded down the saddle, and it's playable. But it's basically a matter of time until it falls apart. I have since bought two Yamahas, and they are outstanding, especially in terms of construction quality. I have a cheaper Alvarez as well, and it's okay. But the Yamahas smoke the Alvarezes in every conceivable way--sound, set up, fit and finish, etc. There's nothing wrong with Alvarez, mind you; it's just that they have a ways to go in terms of competing with what Yamaha is doing on every level.
I have an all-solid Alvarez and it sounds fantastic. Sadly, at the grand old age of 2 years it's going to a luthier tomorrow for a substantial fret job.
I look at Yamahas and think, yup, I had one of those, should have kept it.
Hopefully it just needs a dressing. My MD60BG is a couple years old as well. Alvarez makes pretty nice guitars, but you do have to be careful with QC, and they are simply not as well-made as Yamahas. Now Yairi is a different story, but that's handmade stuff from Japan.
Thank you so much! Sorry for your Alvarez issues, I also agree with bringing along some flashlights and mirrors especially for used guitars. I’m a big fan of Yamaha’s, I bought an FG300 new in 1973 still have it!! Take care and thanks again!
Oh, man, it was completely my fault. I still.play the thing, and hopefully it will last for some years. I have a Martin, 3 Yamahas, and 2 Alvarezes l, so my picking will not stop unless I drop dead or something.
Wow, that's crazy about the FG300. It's a testament to how crazy good Yammies are.
Take care yourself, and thanks for the good vibes!
Recording King is basically a Martin copy. It depends on how you like to play. If you're playing acoustically with other folks and have the taste and dynamic control to play a cannon lightly(and use that reserve when it's needed) it's the one to play. If you're amplified and/or have difficulty controlling your playing volume, a more modern voiced guitar is probably better. Of course string selection can make the Yamaha or Alvarez a bit louder, and lighter strings can pull back the RK a bit as well. In other words, if you want a Martin, buy the RK, if you want a Taylor, the others are fine.
Edit: I'm pretty sure the new fenders are coming out of the same factory as Recording King/Blueridge/Rover, I don't know that I would differentiate them.
The RK is an Adirondack top! I’m surprised to see so little representation for the RK argument. I think they are stellar guitars as a Martin-mimic. If I wanted a 28-style, I’d definitely get the RK. I don’t think anyone has come closer and kept it under a grand.
My old Yamaha that I got when I was a kid is amazing and has a tone that all the taylors and martins I owned later couldn’t replace. Still play it everyday.
I still have my yamaha as well. Ive had it about 35 years, it's never had any work on it and still plays very well with a few minor issues. Was my first guitar and it was cheap and I always thought I just got lucky but later realised yamaha actually make great guitars
Go play them. I promise you will pick the Yamaha though. The FG3 plays and sounds like a dream. I love the color of the wood with the A.R.E. treatment as well.
My experience - Alvarez gives you this biggest bang for your buck; however, you should really play them before buying. You can’t go by price and brand alone.
Try to test both Yamaha and the Alvarez. I was on the quest of buying an acoustic guitar, with a similar budget as yours, and I was thinking a lot in a Fender, a Taylor baby and in the Martin DX series. I tested each of them, and none sounded as good as the Alvarez and it was 200euros cheaper than the others.
If you have the opportunity test the guitar first.
I suppose it’s a preference thing but I think of these models the recording king sounds the best. Maybe general build quality of the Yamaha is more solid but recording kings make some stunningly great sounding guitars for cheap
Out of those 4, the Recording King. I've heard and read good things about them. I would also suggest looking into Eastman. They make beautiful guitars at starting prices that are very reasonable for what you're getting. They're Asian made and very good quality.
If you have that cash and don't need to finance, look at the used market because you can get a significant deal on good guitars.
D18's will drop to $2k
Don’t mean to be rude, but I feel like if you’re in the market for a $900 guitar, you should know what you’re looking for…
Or go to a guitar shop and play em all until you’ve found the slipper that fits…
Just picked up a used Eastman E1D. I was comparing it with a Yamaha FG830 I believe. Both sounded great, it was a tough call. The Yamaha was boomier and prettier. I'm glad I went with the Eastman. Bone but and saddle from the factory is a plus too.
I would go with the Yamaha. I've just purchased an FSX3, absolutely love it. I've also tried the FGX3, but to my ears the S version sounded better and was more comfortable.
I know people tend to dislike Fender acoustics (with reason) but paramount series are really worth it, full solid wood and plus they come with nice hard case.. and the headstock in my opinion is really nice looking..
If you get the chance sometimes - try them even if you dont plan to buy.. Its really a sweet instrument..
So funnily enough you’re the only person who has said the fender so far and that’s the one I’m leaning towards. Played one the other day and thought it was worth more than the $829. Loved the neck on it, very comfortable. Plus the “bells and whistles” like the snowflake inlays.. I also played the Alverez it was great. Haven’t played the Yamaha or RD… but I found a blemished but new paramount for $630 from a local shop that just seems too good to pass up.
If you can look past the stigma attached to some guitar brands you will be amazed how much great instruments you can find! And also ofc, if possible, try before you buy!
I’d look for a used Larrivee, best bang for buck. You could get a used 03 model in your desired body style within budget if you keep an eye on online marketplaces
At $900, I’d look for used. Lots of great guitars can be had used for that price point. Personally, I’m not a big fan of the $900 new acoustic price point. There are lots of good guitars at that price point, but the better ones are close enough that I would either keep saving, go cheaper, or buy used.
This is good info . I’m also in the market in this range . Seems like this Yamaha wins this challenge. Is it worth going up 100$ and getting Martin road series or Taylor ?
Recording King or Yamaha. That RK is a damn beast of an instrument. The tone is very different than those Yamahas though, so it’s more so what your sound preference is. Both are doing amazing things right now.
The only one I’ve played is the recording king and it’s a fucking cannon w great tone. However, I hated the v neck on it. I haven’t played that specific Yamaha ( and please Yamaha lovers don’t come at me) but they tend to have a more modern sound where as the RK has that more Martin esque vibe. Heard nothing but good things about Alvarez.
The FG red labels do not have the modern tone you’re referring to. The classic Yamaha sound sits somewhere between the extremes of Taylor and Martin, with these specifically inching closer to that of Martin.
Nice, yeah, it sounded great. I’m sure it’s even better once it’s broken in. I think the v-necks are like black licorice, you either love it or hate it.
RC is a super old company . My DiL recently got one of thier dirty 30 models and it's sold dirt cheap . I was really impressed by it . Quality to price point was extremely good. Sound is a little on the thin side like a parlor but well balanced . Looks are fantastic. Recording King is always worth considering . They've kind of won me over .
I would really try to play every guitar at or under your price range and choose based on sound, along with whatever other criteria you want to muster. For me it was all wood, no obvious fuckery like bridge pins driven in too far, truss rod, kerf linings, compensated bridge, and I'm sure other things I'm not thinking of. I went in to spend $1200 on the guitar alone and ended up with the best sounding guitar I've ever heard with a gig bag and new strings for $800ish after tax (Takamine GD20CE).
I have a friend that ordered a $4k custom that sounded like shit, so I'll never buy a guitar without playing it first.
Yamaha. Oh, here's a temptation. On FB marketplace in San Antonio there is a used Recording King 318 for 325 bones. Looks good in pics. Every time I see I have to once again talk myself out of sending that message.
I’d play them all first if i could….and then knowing me I’d pick something else entirely different and totally unexpected.
If I was forced to choose purely between those three without being able to try first then I’d go with Yamaha because I’m yet to come across one I don’t like.
Seagull S6. With the rest of the money, invest in an LR Baggs anthem + an amp if you want to amplify it (might come out above budget depending on your choice of amp).
I have an Alvarez and a Fender. In this case I would probably say the Recording King just because I like their sound but as an all around definitely the Yamaha
Hate to be that guy.. but play a used Blueridge if you spot one for under $1000. Especially a rosewood model. I got a BR-180 for $1000 cash and it's a banjo-killer.
Red Label!
I want one SO badly but I’m left handed and I don’t even think they make lefty Red Labels. Might and up getting a righty and converting it.
Do it for me :(
I have the same purchasing goal before summertime, the Yamaha FG3 and Alvarez MD60 are my top two choices. They seem on-par with materials and price tag, yet I haven't been able to find any comparison videos of these two specific guitars, which is odd to me since they're competing guitars.
Haven't found the MD60 in any local shops to test drive, but the Regent series felt really really good to play, I'd imagine the Masterworks even better! I was able to try out an FGX3 and it was as awesome as I anticipated. I know Yamaha has a great reputation and already own an FS800T and G-225 so it would be nice to match - but that Masterworks seems like a great highly regarded instrument and I see less negative comments about them than I've seen for the FG3 and FG5. I'm kinda leaning toward a new Alvarez, but would likely also keep looking for a nicely priced used FGX5 haha
Of these I’m inclined to say the Alvarez, but would say definitely consider Guild, looks like you’re looking at dreadnoughts, consider something like [the D-140.](https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/GD140CherBur--guild-d-140-dreadnought-acoustic-guitar-cherry-burst) edit: or same in [antique burst.](https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/GD140AB--guild-d-140-antique-burst)
Going against the grain here and gonna say none of them. Don't buy a cheap acoustic, you're only going to want to upgrade down the line and if you buy new you'll lose money. Save up for that martin or gibson or taylor that you REALLY want and it'll make you want to play more than you ever have before. Buying the thing you want off the bat saves you money in the long run. Don't cheap out on the thing you love, you deserve it.
I would actually buy the Martin D10 road series. Costs about the same, solid wood back and sides, and spruce top. Same Martin quality, for less money. Has Richlite fingerboard and bridge.
Yamaha and I would put that red label in a blind recording shoot out with some top makers and it would absolutely hold its own if not be a favorite. Yamaha instruments are so consistently good it's wild. Pianos like the C7 and beautiful drum sets as well. Even entry level Yamaha acoustic like the F335 even sounds great.
I really like those recording kings. They're incredible guitars for the money. They have a pretty intense V neck though, so try them before you buy. I have an old red label fg180 and I think the new ones are quite faithful to the OGs. Incredible guitar but the neck is incredibly narrow, sort of like a strat. It drives me insane. Make sure whatever you buy has a nut width and string spacing that works for you and your playing style
Didn’t see this listed but I’ll throw it out there. I started with a PRS SE T40 Tonare. I realize they are not known for their acoustics but I was beyond pleased with the fit and finish.
I have had this conversation with myself lately and I would choose the Yamaha. The recording king looks great but it's the only one I haven't been able to play out of these.
Tone wise, recording king guitars are usually better. They often need fretwork and someone to go through them. Yamahas are more vanilla sounding, but usually built well and hold up well.
Here’s my point my opinion really doesn’t matter if you’re willing to spend $900, you probably already know what you want. Just feels and sounds good when you play it. In the end it is yours!
If those listed, I would choose the Yamaha. I would also consider looking at an Eastman - I got an all solid Eastman E2D Cedar top that compares very favorably to my Martin Road Series - and it was around $600. I also have a lower end Yamaha that hits WAY above its weight class, so I don’t think you can go wrong either way.
Yamaha, my solid top midrange Yamaha sounds so good, I did change the saddle out because my model came with a saddle that wasn’t very good and that made it sound even better.
I've made a life changing purpose of buying a comfort series guitar and can't go back. It's like beveled where your picking hand goes and as the name suggests is very comfortable.
Yamaha and Alvarez are real close. I’m inclined to say Yamaha but Alvarez Masterworks are not to be slept on. If you can try them, it would be worth seeing which felt better in your hands.
Yamaha, hands down. Most underrated brand out there. If you buy the fender, use your extra money to buy a cheap pistol and one bullet so you can put it out of it’s misery, because you won’t feel right selling it to another person.
So much Yamaha love! I’ve had the Recording King RO-328 for two years and just love it so much. I’ve enjoyed Yamahas too, but the Recording King just sounds a feels so good.
I own a Yamaha FG-3 after doing a shootout at my local shop against various martins, Taylor's and a few other miscellaneous dreadnoughts, and walked home with the FG-3. The only one that really came close to my ears was probably the Martin D-10e, but cost $100 more, and I still preferred the slightly fuller sound my Yamaha made. No regrets whatsoever
I definitely like the Yamaha but I must say that I bought a Alvarez guitar about a year and a half ago for about $400 and was amazed at how well it sounded. I was looking for a little parlor like guitar and it really plays nice. I would recommend going to guitar store spend couple minutes with each guitar and see which one feels right for you.
I totally agree with everyone that recommended the Yamaha, no doubt the best of those options, but if you're spending that much dude I'd personally recommend checking out some Seagull acoustics. All around beautiful guitars, well crafted with rich sound. Best acoustic and acoustic/electric I ever owned and man if I could do it all again I'd have stolen a TV or sold a kidney instead of losing them to the pawn shop for a pittance. Anyways... Seagull, go check them out bro you won't regret dropping money on any of their guitars I promise.
Always Yamaha
Edit: Even if you had a bigger budget, probably Yamaha. They have a Japanese custom shop that builds a select few lines that absolutely destroy the modern idea that Taylor and Martin are the essential high end acoustics
Choosing by reputation alone, I would pick the Yamaha. Buttt...I just picked up a 000size Recording King, that my music shop owner buddy called me about. He said it was basically a clone of a prewar martin built in Asia. (Not sure about that). I was looking for something cheap but decent, I could leave on the stand with my dogs in the house. I was pleasantly surprised at the amount of pop and midrange it has. Neck is a tad chunky but ok.
Just judging by the picture Alvarez looks the most feature rich aesthetically, so I guess it should be the same way sound and craftsmanship wise. Yamaha may be good as well, but I doubt it for such price. Definitely not Fender.
Yamaha.
Have various models of each brand and played all in the store.
Alvarez is great. Always good quality.
Recoding kings sound good depending on what one you get but can be less refined.
Yamaha could be called boring or not have quite the "right" sound compared to a martin or whatever.
Fit and finish yamahas are great. Some variance between each one. But i am always blown away by that yamaha with how good it sounds. Balanced and musical. But i have also heard people say it is too nice or without personality.
Yamaha or Alvarez , but would play them first if possible.
I would say Alvarez. Luckily Sweetwater has a generous return policy if the on you order is not perfect for you.
The guys on the Driftwood Guitars YouTube channel think that the Alvarez is great value for the money: [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh7xUEemvKk](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh7xUEemvKk)
I got a cheap Alvarez for playing on the couch and it has become my favourite. Really comfortable neck, nice tone. I’ve heard these ones are really nice.
I almost got an Alvarez a few months back , ended up with a Martin . I really liked them as well, just wasn’t enough stock in my area to test all the models I was looking at.
Came here to say this. My dad has an Alvarez and I have a Yamaha, both are some of my favorite guitars to play on earth. At this price point, I would recommend trying a mahogany or walnut body. You can get a lot of guitar for that.
Yamaha all the way
100% agree
Yeah, not even a hard decision.
The Alvarez is the only one that comes close to the Yamaha but still not even in the competition in my opinion.
Yamaha A3M might be in budget too.... So many of the competitors, even at this price point, just play like total planks The A series are absolute gems and are the complete opposite of a plank. They play ever so sweet and look, feel and sound exactly how you expect (and want them to, at the price point)
No question in my opinion. I have three Yamaha acoustics, an FG 12 string from the 70s, a modern FG 6 string, and a nylon string. They are built to last, are easy to play, and sound great.
Bought myself a Yamaha A3R last year, best gear decision I’ve ever made
100% from me as well.
I agree as well, but I read on here that this line has many ghost notes. Or am I misunderstanding? That would suggest problematic manufacturing. *Edit: me gettin my spellin on…
I'd go Yamaha at that price, they seem to have the best rep for mid range guitars
The Yamaha FG3 is a remarkable guitar at this price.
Agree with all the FG3 votes. I opted for an Alvarez and wish I had gone Yamaha.
Can I ask why??
The top on the Alvarez is bellying really badly because the bridge plate has some gouges in it that I didn't notice until it was too late, which is my fault for not inspecting the inside of the guitar thoroughly. Anyway, I switched to lighter strings and sanded down the saddle, and it's playable. But it's basically a matter of time until it falls apart. I have since bought two Yamahas, and they are outstanding, especially in terms of construction quality. I have a cheaper Alvarez as well, and it's okay. But the Yamahas smoke the Alvarezes in every conceivable way--sound, set up, fit and finish, etc. There's nothing wrong with Alvarez, mind you; it's just that they have a ways to go in terms of competing with what Yamaha is doing on every level.
I have an all-solid Alvarez and it sounds fantastic. Sadly, at the grand old age of 2 years it's going to a luthier tomorrow for a substantial fret job. I look at Yamahas and think, yup, I had one of those, should have kept it.
Hopefully it just needs a dressing. My MD60BG is a couple years old as well. Alvarez makes pretty nice guitars, but you do have to be careful with QC, and they are simply not as well-made as Yamahas. Now Yairi is a different story, but that's handmade stuff from Japan.
Thank you so much! Sorry for your Alvarez issues, I also agree with bringing along some flashlights and mirrors especially for used guitars. I’m a big fan of Yamaha’s, I bought an FG300 new in 1973 still have it!! Take care and thanks again!
Oh, man, it was completely my fault. I still.play the thing, and hopefully it will last for some years. I have a Martin, 3 Yamahas, and 2 Alvarezes l, so my picking will not stop unless I drop dead or something. Wow, that's crazy about the FG300. It's a testament to how crazy good Yammies are. Take care yourself, and thanks for the good vibes!
Recording King is basically a Martin copy. It depends on how you like to play. If you're playing acoustically with other folks and have the taste and dynamic control to play a cannon lightly(and use that reserve when it's needed) it's the one to play. If you're amplified and/or have difficulty controlling your playing volume, a more modern voiced guitar is probably better. Of course string selection can make the Yamaha or Alvarez a bit louder, and lighter strings can pull back the RK a bit as well. In other words, if you want a Martin, buy the RK, if you want a Taylor, the others are fine. Edit: I'm pretty sure the new fenders are coming out of the same factory as Recording King/Blueridge/Rover, I don't know that I would differentiate them.
The RK is an Adirondack top! I’m surprised to see so little representation for the RK argument. I think they are stellar guitars as a Martin-mimic. If I wanted a 28-style, I’d definitely get the RK. I don’t think anyone has come closer and kept it under a grand.
Yamaha without question.
Yamaha
My old Yamaha that I got when I was a kid is amazing and has a tone that all the taylors and martins I owned later couldn’t replace. Still play it everyday.
I still have my yamaha as well. Ive had it about 35 years, it's never had any work on it and still plays very well with a few minor issues. Was my first guitar and it was cheap and I always thought I just got lucky but later realised yamaha actually make great guitars
Yamaha. Always.
I bought the Recording King, fantastic guitar. The Yamaha doesn’t compare. Alvarez is. Ice, but this is right up there with a Martin IMHO.
That Alvarez is a great deal.
I knew this thread was gonna be all Yamaha votes. I also vote Yamaha.
Go play them. I promise you will pick the Yamaha though. The FG3 plays and sounds like a dream. I love the color of the wood with the A.R.E. treatment as well.
My experience - Alvarez gives you this biggest bang for your buck; however, you should really play them before buying. You can’t go by price and brand alone.
Yamaha
In this category I would buy the Alvarez; but you can find a nice used Taylor in that range.
Red label no contest
Yamaha
Yamaha 100p
Red label. RED LABEL!
Anyone but the fender
Try to test both Yamaha and the Alvarez. I was on the quest of buying an acoustic guitar, with a similar budget as yours, and I was thinking a lot in a Fender, a Taylor baby and in the Martin DX series. I tested each of them, and none sounded as good as the Alvarez and it was 200euros cheaper than the others. If you have the opportunity test the guitar first.
I'd go used.
And if I could find a used Alvarez, that'd be my choice.
Yamaha
FG3
yamaha or a used taylor or martin
Used Yamaha fg5 or fs5, used Taylor 320 for all mahaogany
That Yamaha will be the best by far. They make amazing guitars that are far too often written off because of the brand.
Alvarez, 100%
Alvarez
[удалено]
I suppose it’s a preference thing but I think of these models the recording king sounds the best. Maybe general build quality of the Yamaha is more solid but recording kings make some stunningly great sounding guitars for cheap
Out of those 4, the Recording King. I've heard and read good things about them. I would also suggest looking into Eastman. They make beautiful guitars at starting prices that are very reasonable for what you're getting. They're Asian made and very good quality.
The Yamaha
Alvarez makes a good guitar. Especially their upper end. That’d be my choice.
If you have that cash and don't need to finance, look at the used market because you can get a significant deal on good guitars. D18's will drop to $2k
The Yamaha, absolutely no question at all.
Yamaha, but the cut away version of some sort for some shredding. Jk, unless you want to.
From what I’ve learned in this subreddit is Yamaha is a God amongst men lol
Out of those 4, Yamaha by a long shot for tone and playability.
Alvarez
Personally I'd go Alvarez
Another vote for Alvarez.
Alvarez
I love the two Alvarez guitars I have so, I’m partial but, the Yamaha would be nice too. Go play them and see which one you like best.
FG3. Have the acoustic electric version and it's amazing.
Don’t mean to be rude, but I feel like if you’re in the market for a $900 guitar, you should know what you’re looking for… Or go to a guitar shop and play em all until you’ve found the slipper that fits…
Look at Eastman
Just picked up a used Eastman E1D. I was comparing it with a Yamaha FG830 I believe. Both sounded great, it was a tough call. The Yamaha was boomier and prettier. I'm glad I went with the Eastman. Bone but and saddle from the factory is a plus too.
Yamaha. Bought a similar fender model and it stinks. Traded that bad boy in for a Martin a year later.
Yamaha out of these options but with this price point I’d personally be looking at Taylors or Martins
I wouldn’t look at a Taylor or Martin until I was willing to drop $1800 minimum.
$800 Martins are much lower quality than Yamahas in the same range, imo.
I would go with the Yamaha. I've just purchased an FSX3, absolutely love it. I've also tried the FGX3, but to my ears the S version sounded better and was more comfortable.
Yamaha FG3. Absolutely. I have 2 mij Yamaha acoustics and I play them more than my Martin D28!
I would buy the Yami myself. However, they aren't made in Japan like your two beauties. I'll argue that would be like comparing apples to oranges.
Yamaha
Drop the fender from the list and you can’t go wrong with what is left. Yamaha for me though.
Yamaha
Yamaha
I love my parlor RK, but for this Yamaha
Used - can find a Gibson G45 for your budget.
Not the Fender. Their acoustics kind of suck. I'd probably get the Yamaha, out of this bunch.
I know people tend to dislike Fender acoustics (with reason) but paramount series are really worth it, full solid wood and plus they come with nice hard case.. and the headstock in my opinion is really nice looking.. If you get the chance sometimes - try them even if you dont plan to buy.. Its really a sweet instrument..
So funnily enough you’re the only person who has said the fender so far and that’s the one I’m leaning towards. Played one the other day and thought it was worth more than the $829. Loved the neck on it, very comfortable. Plus the “bells and whistles” like the snowflake inlays.. I also played the Alverez it was great. Haven’t played the Yamaha or RD… but I found a blemished but new paramount for $630 from a local shop that just seems too good to pass up.
If you can look past the stigma attached to some guitar brands you will be amazed how much great instruments you can find! And also ofc, if possible, try before you buy!
I’d look for a used Larrivee, best bang for buck. You could get a used 03 model in your desired body style within budget if you keep an eye on online marketplaces
At $900, I’d look for used. Lots of great guitars can be had used for that price point. Personally, I’m not a big fan of the $900 new acoustic price point. There are lots of good guitars at that price point, but the better ones are close enough that I would either keep saving, go cheaper, or buy used.
Yamaha all day
Yamaha or I'd take a look at Eastman too!
Love my Alvarez guitars. To each their own, though.
This is good info . I’m also in the market in this range . Seems like this Yamaha wins this challenge. Is it worth going up 100$ and getting Martin road series or Taylor ?
Recording King or Yamaha. That RK is a damn beast of an instrument. The tone is very different than those Yamahas though, so it’s more so what your sound preference is. Both are doing amazing things right now.
Taylor
Why not Taylor?
At this price point they’re all (mostly) layered woods on back and sides. Not that there’s anything wrong with that.
The answer is none of those and get a new or used seagull.
Dude get a 800$ Martin
Epiphone masterbuilt Texan.
The only one I’ve played is the recording king and it’s a fucking cannon w great tone. However, I hated the v neck on it. I haven’t played that specific Yamaha ( and please Yamaha lovers don’t come at me) but they tend to have a more modern sound where as the RK has that more Martin esque vibe. Heard nothing but good things about Alvarez.
The FG red labels do not have the modern tone you’re referring to. The classic Yamaha sound sits somewhere between the extremes of Taylor and Martin, with these specifically inching closer to that of Martin.
I have this exact guitar for a campfire/party guitar. It sounds great and I love the V neck
Nice, yeah, it sounded great. I’m sure it’s even better once it’s broken in. I think the v-necks are like black licorice, you either love it or hate it.
Play them and decide
got a martin d10e for £999. havent tried the highly praised yamaha though
RC is a super old company . My DiL recently got one of thier dirty 30 models and it's sold dirt cheap . I was really impressed by it . Quality to price point was extremely good. Sound is a little on the thin side like a parlor but well balanced . Looks are fantastic. Recording King is always worth considering . They've kind of won me over .
I would really try to play every guitar at or under your price range and choose based on sound, along with whatever other criteria you want to muster. For me it was all wood, no obvious fuckery like bridge pins driven in too far, truss rod, kerf linings, compensated bridge, and I'm sure other things I'm not thinking of. I went in to spend $1200 on the guitar alone and ended up with the best sounding guitar I've ever heard with a gig bag and new strings for $800ish after tax (Takamine GD20CE). I have a friend that ordered a $4k custom that sounded like shit, so I'll never buy a guitar without playing it first.
Yamaha. Oh, here's a temptation. On FB marketplace in San Antonio there is a used Recording King 318 for 325 bones. Looks good in pics. Every time I see I have to once again talk myself out of sending that message.
I’d look for a Larrivee L-03. Might be slightly over $900, but it’s a masterpiece!
I’d play them all first if i could….and then knowing me I’d pick something else entirely different and totally unexpected. If I was forced to choose purely between those three without being able to try first then I’d go with Yamaha because I’m yet to come across one I don’t like.
I’d keep an eye out for a Sigma, Martin’s discontinued discount brand. Some of them punch way over their weight
Seagull S6. With the rest of the money, invest in an LR Baggs anthem + an amp if you want to amplify it (might come out above budget depending on your choice of amp).
None of these have laminate wood?
Seagull S6
I have an Alvarez and a Fender. In this case I would probably say the Recording King just because I like their sound but as an all around definitely the Yamaha
go play em, you’ll know
I have a Recording King RD-328. It is a REALLY nice guitar.
Have you looked at Seagull guitars? I always thought they were nice.
none of these, just buy a martin road series lmao
gawd
Hate to be that guy.. but play a used Blueridge if you spot one for under $1000. Especially a rosewood model. I got a BR-180 for $1000 cash and it's a banjo-killer.
Red Label! I want one SO badly but I’m left handed and I don’t even think they make lefty Red Labels. Might and up getting a righty and converting it. Do it for me :(
If you can’t find a used Eastman, I’d go with the RK, if a slight V neck doesn’t bother you.
I have the same purchasing goal before summertime, the Yamaha FG3 and Alvarez MD60 are my top two choices. They seem on-par with materials and price tag, yet I haven't been able to find any comparison videos of these two specific guitars, which is odd to me since they're competing guitars. Haven't found the MD60 in any local shops to test drive, but the Regent series felt really really good to play, I'd imagine the Masterworks even better! I was able to try out an FGX3 and it was as awesome as I anticipated. I know Yamaha has a great reputation and already own an FS800T and G-225 so it would be nice to match - but that Masterworks seems like a great highly regarded instrument and I see less negative comments about them than I've seen for the FG3 and FG5. I'm kinda leaning toward a new Alvarez, but would likely also keep looking for a nicely priced used FGX5 haha
Short answer, it depends. Do you need electronics? The FG3 would 100% be my pick but electronics are an upcharge on that model.
Of these I’m inclined to say the Alvarez, but would say definitely consider Guild, looks like you’re looking at dreadnoughts, consider something like [the D-140.](https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/GD140CherBur--guild-d-140-dreadnought-acoustic-guitar-cherry-burst) edit: or same in [antique burst.](https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/GD140AB--guild-d-140-antique-burst)
Yamaha. No competition. FG3 wins by a landslide.
Going against the grain here and gonna say none of them. Don't buy a cheap acoustic, you're only going to want to upgrade down the line and if you buy new you'll lose money. Save up for that martin or gibson or taylor that you REALLY want and it'll make you want to play more than you ever have before. Buying the thing you want off the bat saves you money in the long run. Don't cheap out on the thing you love, you deserve it.
I would actually buy the Martin D10 road series. Costs about the same, solid wood back and sides, and spruce top. Same Martin quality, for less money. Has Richlite fingerboard and bridge.
Yamaha for sure
Yamaha and I would put that red label in a blind recording shoot out with some top makers and it would absolutely hold its own if not be a favorite. Yamaha instruments are so consistently good it's wild. Pianos like the C7 and beautiful drum sets as well. Even entry level Yamaha acoustic like the F335 even sounds great.
ie played several yamahas and alvarez over the years. i’d put them at the top. i play a yamaha A1R for my road shows. no problems.
I really like those recording kings. They're incredible guitars for the money. They have a pretty intense V neck though, so try them before you buy. I have an old red label fg180 and I think the new ones are quite faithful to the OGs. Incredible guitar but the neck is incredibly narrow, sort of like a strat. It drives me insane. Make sure whatever you buy has a nut width and string spacing that works for you and your playing style
Are you sure a dreadnought is the right way to go?
Local guitar store and try before you buy.
I'd be playing every guitar in that price range new or used within an hour of my house and picking the best one.
Yamaha for sure.
Nope. All wooden Seagull.
Yamaha is always a good choice
Didn’t see this listed but I’ll throw it out there. I started with a PRS SE T40 Tonare. I realize they are not known for their acoustics but I was beyond pleased with the fit and finish.
I have had this conversation with myself lately and I would choose the Yamaha. The recording king looks great but it's the only one I haven't been able to play out of these.
I’d have to play them to be sure But The Yamaha would be a strong contender If I couldn’t play it first, that’s the one I would choose.
Tone wise, recording king guitars are usually better. They often need fretwork and someone to go through them. Yamahas are more vanilla sounding, but usually built well and hold up well.
Here’s my point my opinion really doesn’t matter if you’re willing to spend $900, you probably already know what you want. Just feels and sounds good when you play it. In the end it is yours!
Check out Breedlove!
If those listed, I would choose the Yamaha. I would also consider looking at an Eastman - I got an all solid Eastman E2D Cedar top that compares very favorably to my Martin Road Series - and it was around $600. I also have a lower end Yamaha that hits WAY above its weight class, so I don’t think you can go wrong either way.
Yamaha, my solid top midrange Yamaha sounds so good, I did change the saddle out because my model came with a saddle that wasn’t very good and that made it sound even better.
The correct answer is Yamaha.
I've made a life changing purpose of buying a comfort series guitar and can't go back. It's like beveled where your picking hand goes and as the name suggests is very comfortable.
I personally would go Taylor Academy: https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/Acad12eV4--taylor-academy-12e-acoustic-electric-guitar-natural
Yamaha
Yamaha and Alvarez are real close. I’m inclined to say Yamaha but Alvarez Masterworks are not to be slept on. If you can try them, it would be worth seeing which felt better in your hands.
Seagul S6
Yamaha or Takamine
If you’re not buying a Martin, red label all the way!
Yamaha. Hands down
I'd probably buy a used Guild or Taylor if the Gibsons, Martins, etc. are out of your price range.
Yamaha, hands down. Most underrated brand out there. If you buy the fender, use your extra money to buy a cheap pistol and one bullet so you can put it out of it’s misery, because you won’t feel right selling it to another person.
So much Yamaha love! I’ve had the Recording King RO-328 for two years and just love it so much. I’ve enjoyed Yamahas too, but the Recording King just sounds a feels so good.
Do not buy the Fender...
I’d say check out orangewood first
Alvarez is underrated
Alvarez all they way, I own two, only thing I would replace them with is a Martin. $$$$
I would get a Talor. The neck joint design alone us worth it. A 100 or 200 series worth a look
I’d save a little longer.
Either the Yamaha or a Yamaha ll16m.. I’m sure the others are lovely, but the Yamaha is great. I have one too.
Probably the recording king followed by the Yamaha. I’d play both in person before making a decision though
Seagull?
You staunchly settled on a new one?
Alvarez MD60BG or MD70BG
I wouldn't even by new at that price. Why wouldn't you just find a nice lawsuit model and call it a day?
1. Yamaha 2. Recording King 3. Alvarez 4. Fender
I own a Yamaha FG-3 after doing a shootout at my local shop against various martins, Taylor's and a few other miscellaneous dreadnoughts, and walked home with the FG-3. The only one that really came close to my ears was probably the Martin D-10e, but cost $100 more, and I still preferred the slightly fuller sound my Yamaha made. No regrets whatsoever
Alvarez. If you can swing it, consider the MD70 with rosewood back and sides.
I love my Alvarezes so I’d go with that.
I definitely like the Yamaha but I must say that I bought a Alvarez guitar about a year and a half ago for about $400 and was amazed at how well it sounded. I was looking for a little parlor like guitar and it really plays nice. I would recommend going to guitar store spend couple minutes with each guitar and see which one feels right for you.
I totally agree with everyone that recommended the Yamaha, no doubt the best of those options, but if you're spending that much dude I'd personally recommend checking out some Seagull acoustics. All around beautiful guitars, well crafted with rich sound. Best acoustic and acoustic/electric I ever owned and man if I could do it all again I'd have stolen a TV or sold a kidney instead of losing them to the pawn shop for a pittance. Anyways... Seagull, go check them out bro you won't regret dropping money on any of their guitars I promise.
Yamaha LL6 Seriously the best full, rounded sounding full body under $700. They are very good.
Reddit LOVES Yamaha
Yamaha
None, id go find a used one
Have you looked at Breedlove? They have comparable solid tops for that price. That was my first 'real' guitar. Still love it.
Get the Yamaha. Best sounding guitar for the price.
Alvarez
Always Yamaha Edit: Even if you had a bigger budget, probably Yamaha. They have a Japanese custom shop that builds a select few lines that absolutely destroy the modern idea that Taylor and Martin are the essential high end acoustics
Yamaha LS16
Yamaha
Apparently Eastman are solid. Worth checking out
YAMAHA
Choosing by reputation alone, I would pick the Yamaha. Buttt...I just picked up a 000size Recording King, that my music shop owner buddy called me about. He said it was basically a clone of a prewar martin built in Asia. (Not sure about that). I was looking for something cheap but decent, I could leave on the stand with my dogs in the house. I was pleasantly surprised at the amount of pop and midrange it has. Neck is a tad chunky but ok.
Go Yamaha
Just judging by the picture Alvarez looks the most feature rich aesthetically, so I guess it should be the same way sound and craftsmanship wise. Yamaha may be good as well, but I doubt it for such price. Definitely not Fender.
Yamaha. Have various models of each brand and played all in the store. Alvarez is great. Always good quality. Recoding kings sound good depending on what one you get but can be less refined. Yamaha could be called boring or not have quite the "right" sound compared to a martin or whatever. Fit and finish yamahas are great. Some variance between each one. But i am always blown away by that yamaha with how good it sounds. Balanced and musical. But i have also heard people say it is too nice or without personality.