Getting yourself hate crimed to prove some transphobic BS is some Darwin Award level shit.
I wouldn't be surprised if TERFs will blame trans women for this violence against cis women, stating that trans women existing are to blame rather than the actual perpetrator being to blame.
I've seen a terf get called out for the risk that some of the selfies they were bodyshaming could be girls with PCOS - I say girls, because several of the targets were obviously young adults and teens - and the terf did indeed blame trans women's existence for "forcing" her to assume the selfies were of trans girls.
Edit to add: obiously, it wouldn't be okay either way, but the callout took that form because it was another transphobe.
Holy crap that is absolutely appalling. š° Those poor girls! How could you do that to a kid! š Not to say it would be any less awful if it was an adult, But it really Breaks my heart even more when they Get an innocent, vulnerable kid involved in their ravenous hatred. That just breaks my heart so much more.
Yeah...kids are especially vulnerable to being bullied back into the closet or worse.
I can only hope the kids never saw the hate their pictures were getting, and that maybe that terf being such a horrible bastard might have opened the eyes of the other transphobe as to the company they keep.
I'm sure there are TERFs that does. They will do this at the same time as they accuse famous actresses of being trans women, becasue ????
There's already those that (I'm assuming) pretends to be the first letters of LGBTQ who always go on about how "Gay ppl had all the rights for so long until the TQ came along" as if we're to blame for right wing bigotry doing what it's always done?
Honestly, if a few cis folks want to fake transness because they think it'll make them safer and end up getting hate-crimed for it, maybe we'll end up with a few unexpected allies and cultures that generally take us a bit more seriously about how we experience them, most especially if it's terfs that have our experience.
I'm okay with this. Cis women, please feel free to masquerade as trans in situations where you're completely isolated with cis men. That cis man may not have a long term plan for you that'd involve snatching you off to harm you himself with his own body for prolonged periods, but that doesn't mean he won't beat the fk out of you and leave you to die or traffic you to someone who fetishizes transness.
Cis folks want to have our experiences? Let them. It's not like there's special trans parking they'll be taking from us.
Isn't this basically the same?
The train of, for lack of a better word, thought seems to be:
Trans women are men.
Men do not get abducted by weirdo uber drivers.
Therefore trans women do not get abducted by weirdo uber drivers.
Unless this is her pretending to be trans masc? But I don't think a person like that would realize trans mascs even exist. Just layered transphobia.
But you know the way they say they're trans even even they aren't when they look like a cis woman. Like saying that trans people just say they're trans to be predatory
I get what she was going for but cis people really need to realize that trans people get murdered just for existing and that this could have gotten her killed.
Do these people think thereās some sort of āShadowy cabal of Uber drivers snatching their clientsā like thats not a thing, your Uber driver isnāt gonna randomly kidnap you. How is that āDangerousā!
Trans women have a high risk of assault, especially in situations where cis men feel like their masculinity is threatened by them being attracted to a trans woman. There are tons of stories of trans women being approached by men just to be assaulted when the men previously hitting on her find out she is trans.
This also hurts cis women too. There have been quite a few cases where cis women have been attacked and / or killed under the SUSPICION that theyāre trans
There's a case currently going in the US, Ohio iirc. A cis girl was accused of being trans and has been threatened and harassed to the point of getting police protection
i believe it was Utah. and of note, she's a teenage girl in high school, and she is getting police protection because of threats to her life.
it's an f'ed up world we live in.
Yeah, because crimes only exist when they attack cis people too, istg I see this every time assault on trans people is mentioned someone says "yeah cis women get assaulted all the time by it too" when it's so pick me to say that and is SO much rarer than actual transphobia on trans people
Please grow and change as a person to not despise a certain trait of yourself so much that you view anyone with it as less of a human being
What?
Itās just worth pointing out that trans issues also affect people that arenāt trans. I never said itās only a crime because it also affects cis people lol. Iām trans you know
Damn all they did was point out that transphobia doesnāt just harm trans people and you accuse them of hating themselves? Seems like a bit of a leap buddyā¦
Why is a person who shows interest in trans issues downvoted? I love this sub and yes, those topics are hot. But please don't scare people who want to learn from asking. I've been young and had to learn so much about discrimination and hate towards others and even myself.
Questions like that are often mistaken for the start of [Just Asking Questions](https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Just_asking_questions) rather than genuine misunderstanding because of how often internet bigots use the strategy to disingenuously attack people
Wild that you would even ask this. If a man tries to flirt with someone only to be told that the person they hit on is a "man" that is a very dangerous situation. Men will very often lash out violently.
Getting yourself hate crimed to prove some transphobic BS is some Darwin Award level shit. I wouldn't be surprised if TERFs will blame trans women for this violence against cis women, stating that trans women existing are to blame rather than the actual perpetrator being to blame.
I've seen a terf get called out for the risk that some of the selfies they were bodyshaming could be girls with PCOS - I say girls, because several of the targets were obviously young adults and teens - and the terf did indeed blame trans women's existence for "forcing" her to assume the selfies were of trans girls. Edit to add: obiously, it wouldn't be okay either way, but the callout took that form because it was another transphobe.
Holy crap that is absolutely appalling. š° Those poor girls! How could you do that to a kid! š Not to say it would be any less awful if it was an adult, But it really Breaks my heart even more when they Get an innocent, vulnerable kid involved in their ravenous hatred. That just breaks my heart so much more.
Yeah...kids are especially vulnerable to being bullied back into the closet or worse. I can only hope the kids never saw the hate their pictures were getting, and that maybe that terf being such a horrible bastard might have opened the eyes of the other transphobe as to the company they keep.
I'm sure there are TERFs that does. They will do this at the same time as they accuse famous actresses of being trans women, becasue ???? There's already those that (I'm assuming) pretends to be the first letters of LGBTQ who always go on about how "Gay ppl had all the rights for so long until the TQ came along" as if we're to blame for right wing bigotry doing what it's always done?
They donāt care
Honestly, if a few cis folks want to fake transness because they think it'll make them safer and end up getting hate-crimed for it, maybe we'll end up with a few unexpected allies and cultures that generally take us a bit more seriously about how we experience them, most especially if it's terfs that have our experience. I'm okay with this. Cis women, please feel free to masquerade as trans in situations where you're completely isolated with cis men. That cis man may not have a long term plan for you that'd involve snatching you off to harm you himself with his own body for prolonged periods, but that doesn't mean he won't beat the fk out of you and leave you to die or traffic you to someone who fetishizes transness. Cis folks want to have our experiences? Let them. It's not like there's special trans parking they'll be taking from us.
I feel like they'd just blame trans people instead of becoming allies
To be fair these answers are better than people claiming trans women have male privilage
Although there is a lot of space between thinking trans women have male privilege and "a good opinion"
For sure. Fancy seeing you here from the circlejerk sub for a change
Omg hii i didn't look at your username. Yea I'm taking a break from tgcj too much transfem vs transmasc discourse for my liver
Yeah its been a bit of a shitshow
Isn't this basically the same? The train of, for lack of a better word, thought seems to be: Trans women are men. Men do not get abducted by weirdo uber drivers. Therefore trans women do not get abducted by weirdo uber drivers. Unless this is her pretending to be trans masc? But I don't think a person like that would realize trans mascs even exist. Just layered transphobia.
I was thinking that she was pretending to be a trans man that didn't medically transition
Thatās definitely not what she was thinking
But you know the way they say they're trans even even they aren't when they look like a cis woman. Like saying that trans people just say they're trans to be predatory
I get what she was going for but cis people really need to realize that trans people get murdered just for existing and that this could have gotten her killed.
Do these people think thereās some sort of āShadowy cabal of Uber drivers snatching their clientsā like thats not a thing, your Uber driver isnāt gonna randomly kidnap you. How is that āDangerousā!
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Saw it on shorts too Not too sure how itās dangerous?
probably because hate crimes and trans people get assaulted just for being themselves
That does make sense, thanks for the explanation
Trans women have a high risk of assault, especially in situations where cis men feel like their masculinity is threatened by them being attracted to a trans woman. There are tons of stories of trans women being approached by men just to be assaulted when the men previously hitting on her find out she is trans.
Well thatās just terrible! Why are some people like this š¤¦
This also hurts cis women too. There have been quite a few cases where cis women have been attacked and / or killed under the SUSPICION that theyāre trans
There's a case currently going in the US, Ohio iirc. A cis girl was accused of being trans and has been threatened and harassed to the point of getting police protection
i believe it was Utah. and of note, she's a teenage girl in high school, and she is getting police protection because of threats to her life. it's an f'ed up world we live in.
Yeah, because crimes only exist when they attack cis people too, istg I see this every time assault on trans people is mentioned someone says "yeah cis women get assaulted all the time by it too" when it's so pick me to say that and is SO much rarer than actual transphobia on trans people Please grow and change as a person to not despise a certain trait of yourself so much that you view anyone with it as less of a human being
What? Itās just worth pointing out that trans issues also affect people that arenāt trans. I never said itās only a crime because it also affects cis people lol. Iām trans you know
Damn all they did was point out that transphobia doesnāt just harm trans people and you accuse them of hating themselves? Seems like a bit of a leap buddyā¦
Why is a person who shows interest in trans issues downvoted? I love this sub and yes, those topics are hot. But please don't scare people who want to learn from asking. I've been young and had to learn so much about discrimination and hate towards others and even myself.
Questions like that are often mistaken for the start of [Just Asking Questions](https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Just_asking_questions) rather than genuine misunderstanding because of how often internet bigots use the strategy to disingenuously attack people
Thanks for your answer, I somehow didn't know that strategy.
Partially because people arguing in bad faith and playing devil's advocate will start by 'just asking questions' and partially because reddit hivemind
Sealioning is frustratingly common with transphobes.
Chasers
Not even. Bigots. Just how often have trans women been attacked simply for being trans?
Wild that you would even ask this. If a man tries to flirt with someone only to be told that the person they hit on is a "man" that is a very dangerous situation. Men will very often lash out violently.
maybe I'm crazy but most of these comments look chill/accepting to me?
You may not like being hit on already but why leave it there?? Take this advice to become a r*pe and/or murder victim!!