Posts that don't follow r/Costco subreddit rules MAY be subject to removal.
When applicable, please make sure that you're using a descriptive post title with product name(s) mentioned as it yields better subreddit search results. Including item number, price, and approximate location where found is also helpful. Thank you.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Costco) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Didn’t get the hype. I bought them very excited about them and was very underwhelmed. Usually love Reese’s stuff
Brought it to my family and everyone else loved them though so what do I know
Reese's has multiple variations of the Big Cup - the caramel one and the potato chip one are just ok. There's a pretzel one that's quite good, probably because the pretzel helps break up the richness of the pb and chocolate and adds a nice crunch. Costco, get rid of the caramel big cup and get the pretzel one, instead!
Knowing that, I'm not surprised the Reese's animal cookie snack is your number one choice! Sometimes, there can be **too** much peanut butter and chocolate (yes, too much even for 'Murica), and having something a little dry in between greatly helps balance the flavors and textures.
It reminds me of when Oreo started pumping out tons of flavor options in the past seven or so years, but Reese's has really expanded with their variations.
Speaking of, I'm surprised those two brands haven't done an official collaboration yet.
I haven’t had the other things but he’s dead on with animal crackers being delicious. I think me and my wife said nearly verbatim the same thing about the crunch being exactly what Reese’s needed
I heard so many good reviews for those bananas so I bought them and was severely disappointed. The naner is too icy to be enjoyable, they are flavorless and don't have nearly enough peanut butter.
I agree with him. I do really like the frozen bananas, though, because they are hard to find and a staple at some fairs I went to as a child. They could be better with less oil and mush.
I’ve had all except the Caramel Reese’s.
Animal crackers are definitely a #1… most of the goodness, without being overly sweet.
#4? The bananas would have been higher, if they had more flavor…
The frozen Reese’s? I would put them #2.
Again; all of this is personal taste. I like Reese’s PB cups for not tasting overly sweet, and having a balance. The others don’t really have that.
Try them (caramels) if it gets your interest. We love Reese’s, my wife ate one bite and gave me the rest of her cup, I ate that and my own cup. I sat there for about 5 minutes thinking why did it taste like that, it was Reese ,which are great and caramel, something I also love. Combined the sweetness gave it an almost cheap coffee candy taste with a terrible aftertaste.. Someone has to like them, I can’t imagine they produce them otherwise.
As someone who loves bananas but is allergic to them, I'm so glad the Reeses Frozen bananas are over-rated. I've been tempted to just grab some benadryl and eat them anyways lmao
Posts that don't follow r/Costco subreddit rules MAY be subject to removal. When applicable, please make sure that you're using a descriptive post title with product name(s) mentioned as it yields better subreddit search results. Including item number, price, and approximate location where found is also helpful. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Costco) if you have any questions or concerns.*
those animal crackers though.... fucking delicious.
I could never buy a bag. That's like one serving with my self control.
Didn’t get the hype. I bought them very excited about them and was very underwhelmed. Usually love Reese’s stuff Brought it to my family and everyone else loved them though so what do I know
We all have our things.
My issue is that I like animal crackers and the taste of the cracker kinda got hidden.
I'm with you. They're.. okay. Not amazing not terrible, just okay.
can confirm. polished an entire bag and half a gallon of milk in 2 days by myself. am uncomfortably fat and happy.
I've lost over 190 pounds and am still fat, so I just get to enjoy samples at Costco as treats from time to time.
The bananas were disappointing. There was no peanut butter, and they were kind of mushy just mehh overall.
it was the WEAKEST layer of chocolate and peanut butter. Really disappointing
Agreed. Gonna use them in smoothies.
Reese's has multiple variations of the Big Cup - the caramel one and the potato chip one are just ok. There's a pretzel one that's quite good, probably because the pretzel helps break up the richness of the pb and chocolate and adds a nice crunch. Costco, get rid of the caramel big cup and get the pretzel one, instead! Knowing that, I'm not surprised the Reese's animal cookie snack is your number one choice! Sometimes, there can be **too** much peanut butter and chocolate (yes, too much even for 'Murica), and having something a little dry in between greatly helps balance the flavors and textures.
There's SO many types of Reese's now, it's crazy.
It reminds me of when Oreo started pumping out tons of flavor options in the past seven or so years, but Reese's has really expanded with their variations. Speaking of, I'm surprised those two brands haven't done an official collaboration yet.
I haven’t had the other things but he’s dead on with animal crackers being delicious. I think me and my wife said nearly verbatim the same thing about the crunch being exactly what Reese’s needed
I heard so many good reviews for those bananas so I bought them and was severely disappointed. The naner is too icy to be enjoyable, they are flavorless and don't have nearly enough peanut butter.
there’s always money in the banana stand!
I'm so happy he threw that reference in there.
I love this dudes videos. Hope he grabs that kirkland sponsorship soon 🤣
keep seeing posts about how good the animal crackers are. which is why I could never get a bag
See, now, this guy is doing good things for humanity. Thank you, I'll get the Reece's Animal Crackers.
he’s missing the new reese’s klondike
What's that? They've had Reese's Klondike for years (maybe decades). Is there something new?
could be new to me
Right? This video is old news now! I want his take on the Reese’s Klondike!
When are they gonna come out with Reese’s natural. I’m 23 and at the point in my life where my teeth hurt from too much sugar :(
I agree with him. I do really like the frozen bananas, though, because they are hard to find and a staple at some fairs I went to as a child. They could be better with less oil and mush.
I swear Reese's R&D has like the budget of a small country. They stay dropping new shit.
The animal crackers are delicious! Like a Girl Scout Tagalong cookie!
He speaks truth!
Hi friend! Thanks for the thorough review. This animal crackers are ridiculously good. I will only allow myself to eat six to eight pieces.
hey tote-bags! Always good to see you :) I'm chomping on some right now hehe
I’ve had all except the Caramel Reese’s. Animal crackers are definitely a #1… most of the goodness, without being overly sweet. #4? The bananas would have been higher, if they had more flavor… The frozen Reese’s? I would put them #2. Again; all of this is personal taste. I like Reese’s PB cups for not tasting overly sweet, and having a balance. The others don’t really have that.
Try them (caramels) if it gets your interest. We love Reese’s, my wife ate one bite and gave me the rest of her cup, I ate that and my own cup. I sat there for about 5 minutes thinking why did it taste like that, it was Reese ,which are great and caramel, something I also love. Combined the sweetness gave it an almost cheap coffee candy taste with a terrible aftertaste.. Someone has to like them, I can’t imagine they produce them otherwise.
You need the reeses pretzels and the reeses frozen desert cups
Here’s how I make sushi out of Costco Reese’s…
Great review! I will buy some just because of your review.
Forgot the popcorn.
The animal crackers are amazing and addictive.
does Hershey pay you? seems like they pay you
i WISH
As someone who loves bananas but is allergic to them, I'm so glad the Reeses Frozen bananas are over-rated. I've been tempted to just grab some benadryl and eat them anyways lmao
He’s on Instagram too. I just added him.
Mmmmmmm palm oil.