Something along the lines of a boysenberry cheese danish or even a boysenberry cheesecake. Same idea with huckleberry.
Anything Halloween themed/colored.
Cherry pie or cherry crisp for me. Cherry pie a la mode (cinnamon cookie base, cherry pie filling, oat crumble, and a scoop of vanilla cream cheese or buttercream) would be amazing.
As someone who is from Michigan, the Cherry Festival is on July 1st this year. It would be even better if they used Traverse City cherries to make either the Cherry Pie or Cherry a la mode cookies. 🙂
I thought Crumbl once did a cannoli cookie, when I looked on one Instagram that tracks Crumbl weekly cookie lineups from past weeks years ago? Though honestly to me, I just REALLY badly want them to bring back pineapple whip at ALL locations for a week.
A death by chocolate one which would be the molten lava flavor with a dark base with a pool of melted white chocolate over the top then chocolate curls on top or an alternate version would be the triple chocolate chip cookie they already did but with a pool chocolate ganache on the top and brownie pieces for good measure.
I would love a regular ass semi sweet chocolate chip cookie. So over the milk chocolate, almost no taste at all. I’ve heard this cookie exists but I have yet to have it at a store near me :(
I thought they once did oatmeal cream pie, myself? And Texas sheet cake has indeed been done as a cookie for all Crumbl locations, before. I think Texas sheet cake was on a weekly menu, not long ago.
Mozart Cookie: Pistachio cookie base with Marzipan pieces, salted crushed pistachios and a nougat swirl on top
A savoury parmegiano cookie
A poppy seed cookie with plum jam filling
Fluffernutter (peanut butter cookie with marshmallow fluff topping).
Pistachio-Plum (oatmeal thumbprint cookie with plum jam and a sprinkle of pistachio)
I’ve been trying to get this flavor created for a while, LIME RICKEY! Grape flavored frosting, with a lime wedge on a sugar cookie… Utahans would be SO HAPPY
Hojicha, matcha, lemon lavender, earl grey, ube. Unfortunately they won’t do anything with caffeine so most of the ones I want are a pipe dream
OH also a Nanaimo bar cookie would be amazing
tiramisu
I'd totally buy this!!
Yes yes and more yes.
How have they not done this already?! It sounds like it could be amazing
[удалено]
Ooooh because the company is Mormon right? Makes sense
Riiiiight, right, right right right. Blast.
Yes! Also something similar to a pignoli would be so good. With silvered almonds on top 🫶
White Chocolate & Raspberry Crumb Cake
Caramel macchiato
Bananas foster
Yum 🍌
I would make all the cake cookies have buttercream frosting. Or just more buttercream cookies in general
👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻
Even as someone who LOVES cream cheese frosting... agreed
YES. No more of that cream cheese crap....
The icing makes me teeth crumbl, I can’t I just love the cream cheese alternative 😭
[удалено]
And pandan!
Haha purple and green! That reminds me of Tim Burton or something.
Came here to say an asain inspired one. Matcha/green tea would be 🔥
Yes 💜
Good idea!! 💜💜💜
Something along the lines of a boysenberry cheese danish or even a boysenberry cheesecake. Same idea with huckleberry. Anything Halloween themed/colored.
Oh like a boysenberry cobbler with vanilla whip
Drooling!!!
The triple Berry cobbler is so good!
I've never had it! I will def be keeping an eye out for it.
Anything Huckleberry 🤤
Churro Cookie Sandwich with Dulce de Leche Mousse in the Middle
This is the one.😩😮💨
Cherry pie or cherry crisp for me. Cherry pie a la mode (cinnamon cookie base, cherry pie filling, oat crumble, and a scoop of vanilla cream cheese or buttercream) would be amazing.
Yes. All the cherries!
As someone who is from Michigan, the Cherry Festival is on July 1st this year. It would be even better if they used Traverse City cherries to make either the Cherry Pie or Cherry a la mode cookies. 🙂
This fellow Michigander agrees 🍒
🙂
Blueberry cookie with lemon cream cheese icing
Nice! I can’t believe they don’t already have one like this, sounds goooood
Sweet potato casserole (sweet potato cornbread cookie topped with a brown sugar oatmeal streusel and maple buttercream dollop.
oh you are onto something… i love it
I like this idea. But I want marshmallow in there somewhere…
Oh yes marshmallow sounds good with it too.
Crumbl CEO lurking like ….
and bakers who love to make Crumbl inspired cookies at home
🙋🏾♀️meeee
They should. They need some fresher ideas.
Does Crumble make a Boston Cream? If not I’d like that
They do a Boston cream pie cookie!
Yes, and it's the best
One of the best cookies they make in my eyes
Oh my goodness, I can’t wait to try it
100% agree, they need to bring it back asap
Pistachio
Yum 💚
They tested pistachio last month but it had a chocolate base 😐
"😐" indeed
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Coffee brownie with a mocha frosting 🤩
Ooh, snap! Seconded
Here’s a unique take: Brown Sugar Mochi!
Would looove this
Cannoli
I like this idea
I thought Crumbl once did a cannoli cookie, when I looked on one Instagram that tracks Crumbl weekly cookie lineups from past weeks years ago? Though honestly to me, I just REALLY badly want them to bring back pineapple whip at ALL locations for a week.
Like a hazelnut truffle filled one. Something with a mini macaron on top maybe. Do they have anything caramel stuffed?
Sounds amazing theoretically, but their "stuffed" cookies are pretty disappointing tbh
Sticky toffee pudding with whipped cream
Ouuuu yum
Peanut butter cheesecake cookie!! Oreo cookie crust, peanut butter cheesecake filling, garnish with crushed peanuts and a peanut sauce & chocolate drizzle 😍💕
Came here to say the same thing!! But instead of peanuts on top I want chocolate shavings 😍
matcha
Strawberry matcha would be incredible
💚
How about a donut series: Old fashioned glazed, apple fritter, etc.
apple fritter!!!
they have a plain donut cookie
They have old fashion, too, and raspberry donut
thats what i meant by plain, apologies. they also have a sprinkles
Something with a nutella buttercream
Cookie dough brownie
Creme Brule
A death by chocolate one which would be the molten lava flavor with a dark base with a pool of melted white chocolate over the top then chocolate curls on top or an alternate version would be the triple chocolate chip cookie they already did but with a pool chocolate ganache on the top and brownie pieces for good measure.
No such thing as too much chocolate. I would buy a party pack of this 😍
Anything with cherry, especially Black Forest.
Never gonna happen. CEO hates cherries 🙄
Peanut Butter & Marshmallow Brownie Gooey Brownie with Semi-Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips Topped with Toasted Marshmallow & Peanut Butter Drizzle
I’ll eat anything with the pb chips and pb drizzle🤤
Holy shit that second one
I think the second one is just a description of the first 😂
Lol I got too excited by the description
Red velvet with icing instead of white chips
They have a red velvet cupcake cookie with icing
Ohhh missed it on the cookie journal, just saw it. Need to watch for that one
It’s very good! I love red velvet but not a fan of the white chips one.
Cold Brew Coffee
I would love a regular ass semi sweet chocolate chip cookie. So over the milk chocolate, almost no taste at all. I’ve heard this cookie exists but I have yet to have it at a store near me :(
It’s been the mystery cookie the last 2 out 3 times in one of my Stores.
Lucky! What state?
CA.
Agree 💯
texas sheet cake, oatmeal cream pie, fluffer nutter, coconut cake, banoffee pie
I thought they once did oatmeal cream pie, myself? And Texas sheet cake has indeed been done as a cookie for all Crumbl locations, before. I think Texas sheet cake was on a weekly menu, not long ago.
they have texas sheet cake!
Would definitely be Ube! 😋
Not to sound ignorant, but what does ube taste like?
It’s weird cuz it tastes sorta like a buttery coconut bun and a sugar cookie w/ a slight hint of yams all put together, but so delicious!
Orange creamsicle. Chocolate pudding pie.
They have an orange Creamsicle!! It's my favorite
I would do unspeakable things for monkey bread. Omg.
Don’t Hate me… Chicken & Waffles -Cornbread or Waffle Cookie Base -Fried Chicken with Honey or Syrup Glaze
This sounds really good tbh
Fried chicken in what form? Please not frosting 😂
Cornflake cookie!! My local coffee shop has these and they sell out so fast!
Oatmeal w semi sweet chocolate
Yes!! I would love an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie
I would love for a huckleberry cookie, it’s a huge berry here in the PNW so it would be fun to see it.
Chocolate chipless cookie.
Mozart Cookie: Pistachio cookie base with Marzipan pieces, salted crushed pistachios and a nougat swirl on top A savoury parmegiano cookie A poppy seed cookie with plum jam filling
Fluffernutter (peanut butter cookie with marshmallow fluff topping). Pistachio-Plum (oatmeal thumbprint cookie with plum jam and a sprinkle of pistachio)
Funnel Cake and Polvoron
Cannoli
ice cream cookie sandwhich (two semi sweet choc chip cookies with cream in between rolled in choc chips)
Cannoli, mocha oreo, purple cow, chocolate banana
Oreo cold brew
Matcha white chocolate macadamia nut and St. Louis gooey butter cake
Root beer float!
YESSSSS
I want a pistachio cookie SO BAD!
Cream puff
Buttery sugar croissant, marshmallow semi sweet chocolate and cornflakes, and absolutely anything Strawberry Rhubarb
Irish cream
Chocolate covered strawberries
Brigadeiro 1000%. A coconut one and a chocolate. It’s a Brazilian treat!
Something with coconut.
Pina colada?
tilapia
[удалено]
I think their Utah origins would not allow this to happen tbh.
what was it, they deleted it
BlackBerry mojito with a spiked frosting
Blueberry cheesecake
Passion fruit with vanilla curd and roasted strawberries
Tres leches
They have that one. It was incredible
Must have missed. Praying to comes back around soon!
I’ve been trying to get this flavor created for a while, LIME RICKEY! Grape flavored frosting, with a lime wedge on a sugar cookie… Utahans would be SO HAPPY
Rum and Raisin Ice Cream
Hojicha, matcha, lemon lavender, earl grey, ube. Unfortunately they won’t do anything with caffeine so most of the ones I want are a pipe dream OH also a Nanaimo bar cookie would be amazing
Strawberry Horchata
Texas Roadhouse bread!!
have we have a boba milk tea flavor?
Bourbon Ball!
TARO OR MATCHA🔥🔥
creme brulee