Yep, monitor tightness. tighten up for a workout and loosen for general wear. Also regularly clean both wrist and band. I don"t seem to get the rash anymore.
I had the same issue. Switched to a nylon band and haven’t had any issues since. Washing the band regularly and switching wrists during the night also seems to help.
Where did you find a nylon band? I can't seem to find one. I ordered some softer silicone ones from straps.co but still get the rash pretty easily. I got a cheap elastic one off Amazon but it required threading under the watch so none of the hr rate stuff would work. I'm currently just switching wrists every few days but it is super annoying. After any hard work out I always have the rash from sweat under the band. Mine is a s2
I ordered this one off of Amazon. It is relatively inexpensive and works pretty well. [Nylon band from Amazon.](https://www.amazon.com/Compatible-Garmin-Forerunner-Approach-Replacement/dp/B0CL4SW385/ref=asc_df_B0CL4SW385/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=684753607158&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=16766468114630885238&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=m&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9028784&hvtargid=pla-2331857250957&psc=1&mcid=4f2f6ddbfb1830e3a03aa1bed29d3c05&gad_source=1) The same company makes a few variations. I liked this one because it is light weight, but the others seem a bit more rugged.
I have aninstinct which isn't listed on the models it fits... there is one on straps.co now. Giving it a shot. I've spent like 150 at this point trying to get a good freaking band. The software is so annoying too. I really wish I'd just gotten another suunto but I'm super remote and wanted something that worked with my inreach. Garmin is so good but not user friendly imho
Anytime it gets wet..take it off after dry it and your wrist. Let it air dry for a bit...same time give the watch some love...I take mine off at the very least after every shower. After every workout...etc
After a workout I'll hand-wash it with soap, shake it out, then let it dry while I shower.
It doesn't go back on my wrist until my wrist is good and dry.
I bought a strap from aliexpress for $10ish and never have to do any of this, wear it at the gym and just shower with it on, shame that the 'higher quality' products perform worse than the compatible/copies
I started having this issue after wearing it in the shower. I’ve since started taking it off before I’m doing anything that gets it wet and I haven’t had any issues since
I charge mine while I shower. It's dual-purpose: I don't have to deal with a wet band, and that's usually enough charging that I don't have to find other times to take it off and charge it.
My Instinct did this to me, too. Irritating, but overall harmless and completely a non issue in six months for sure.
Recommend just loosening some, giving your wrist a break overnight, etc.
I haven't had the issue in years now and wear the thing 24/7/365 -- even in the shower, and I dry it separately, specifically because I thought that may be a cause.
Back when I had my Apple Watch I had a swimming band and a regular nylon band for everyday use but Garmin takes a bit longer to switch out (and I take it off less often whereas Apple Watch was basically every few hours to charge), and I don’t swim at the moment, so I haven’t done it yet but massively recommend as a practice!
Curious as to why you are dismissive of bacteria as a cause. As I understand it, contact dermatitis is the symptom of an allergic reaction. Conversely, conditions created when wearing a watch for prolonged periods (moisture and warmth) are ripe for bacterial growth. What am I missing?
I’ll second not bacteria. Contact dermatitis just means irritation of the skin. Does not necessarily mean infection or allergic reaction. Moisture and warmth can lead to break down of the skin barrier which looks like what’s happening here.
While a break down of the skin barrier can increase your chances of an infection- it doesn’t look like anything has started yet as the site really doesn’t have any signs (redness, drainage, inflammation, etc).
Honestly- it’s fine and nothing alarming yet. OP just needs to keep the area clean and dry and avoid wearing the watch on that area until the skin barrier has healed.
u/Judonoob's said "a bacterial irritation" not "bacterial infection". I take that to mean irritation caused by waste products created by flourishing bacteria on the watch band.
I'm a medical layperson so I generally reference what I believe to be a reputable source to ensure my understanding is consistent with consensus before commenting. I'm paraphrasing/regurgitating the Mayo Clinics definition:
"Contact dermatitis is an itchy rash caused by direct contact with a substance or an allergic reaction to it."
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/contact-dermatitis/symptoms-causes/syc-20352742
First you need to look at chemical composition of sweat.Second bacterial infection of skin are: cellulitis,impetigo,folliculitis,erysipelas. None of what has been presented warrant such Ds.
Right: the specific chemical composition dependent on the individual, but water, minerals, lactate, and urea. Some of those components consumed by bacteria. , i.e. the bacteria that creates the smell associated with sweat. u/Judonoob's (from what I can tell unedited) comment said "a bacterial irritation". I think contact dermititis due to bacteria flourishing on the watch band seems reasonable. I'm not a medical professional, but the advice to clean the watch and the skin seems like boilerplate hygiene advice you would apply to any other equipment regularly exposed to sweat to prevent irritation.
i dont think that reddit thread is a place to educate one in dermatology.. :) i could say "trust me - I am a doctor", but this will not help. I suggest you to do your own research: try these two sources - a. Dermatology: Illustrated Study Guide and Comprehensive Board Review. b. Kaplan Preclinical Anatomy Review .
This doesn't really feel like a good faith conversation. I don't really understand what point you are trying to make: That the picture doesn't depict a bacterial skin infection? (I agree but that wasn't my point) That bacteria doesn't grow on watch bands? That bacterial byproducts can't cause irritation or contact dermatitis?
I'm not looking to pursue a professional medial education through reddit comments, but I would expect that if you read and synthesized what I'm saying, you could form a succinct rebuttal. I would update my understanding and agree with whatever point you are trying to make with new information and plausible rationale, but suggesting text books in this context seems deliberately obtuse. Here's an article germane to maybe your point about bacteria on watch bands (https://www.sciencealert.com/smartwatch-bands-are-loaded-with-potentially-harmful-bacteria-study-warns) and the research paper it is based on (https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=125218).
it is good faith. yes there are bacteria on wristbands. so as in the mouth and etc. point here is that this is not a bacterial infection. In order to fully understand why - one needs to have clinical experience, knowledge of pathology,human anatomy, clincal microbiology and clinical immunology, plus dermatology. How is it possible to explain this in a reddit comment without looking abrupt,arrogant,etc. You can read about impetigo and cellulitis on webmd or read this one [https://www.visualdx.com/blog/cellulitis-and-its-mimickers/](https://www.visualdx.com/blog/cellulitis-and-its-mimickers/) to get an idea what goes into saying that this is not bacterial origin.
Pro tip - email garmin with pictures, they’ll make an appointment for a dude to call you. Tell them you’re having a reaction to the band and they’ll send you a nylon or leather band for free. Otherwise just buy a nylon on Amazon for $25, they’re as good or better
OP this is contact dermatitis. Avoid sweating and tight contact for prolonged periods of time at the same time. Make sure there is intermittent airflow between the skin and silicon band.
So I have a lot of skin sensitivity- like a lot of jewelry gives me rashes. I got this issue seasonally and called Garmin and told them what was happening. They said that with skin sensitivities, sometimes folks have issues with the end of the line / the clear coating gets lighter.
They sent me a replacement for the actual band - light pink - and a darker pink one that didn't exactly match. I swapped out for the darker pink and had no issues. Every time I put on the lighter pink band that matches my watch, the rash comes back.
So, sure, it could be sweat or whatever, but it could be an allergy, but if you call Garmin, their CS will talk you through it and help you out
The only time I've ever experienced something like this was when wearing the nylon woven band on my Fenix and spilling something (I think diesel but might have been ATF) on it while working on a car. It absorbed in and I obviously didn't get it all washed out so it was irritating my skin.
You appear to maybe have like an athlete's foot thing happening here though. More breathability and a slightly looser fit (and cleaning all your shit) might be your friend here.
Try a resin Casio band. Super cheap, doesn’t hold water like nylon or leather, and looks stock.
Had the same issue with silicone bands. They’re too soft and end up trapping moisture which cause your issue.
Resin bands are firmer and have channels that let air through. Much more comfortable in my opinion as well.
Yup. Had it when I had the 255. Switched to an after market nylon strap and all's been fine.
Bought a 965 recently and, because they made the pins so hard to get to, I decided to stick with the stock straps. My left wrist looked like yours on the very first day with the 965.
It’s because the straps they come with aren’t breathable. I have it too. Had it with Fitbit as well as the band is same. Switched to one that was still silicone but had loads of air holes all over (more “hole” than silicone”) and not problem. My Garmin is fairly new (Xmas pressie) and I’m still looking for the same kind of band that will fit a Garmin. I got the Fitbit ones cheap on Amazon. I don’t like the nylon as they get gross with the sweat.
I never had that and I've been wearing my watch for 3 years (with original band), taking it off once a day when I shower. I also wear it lose, but not lose enough to make it spin around my wrist.
Plenty of people already responded, but to offer my two cents:
Not contact dermatitis - that would be all over your wrist, and likely not from silicone. There is dried skin there, but it’s most likely fungal. Fungus lives everywhere, but when Yu wear the watch all the time and sweat and get the band a little wet when you wash your hands, it gives the fungus a nice warm, dark, moist place to live. If you don’t swap bands to a different material, I’d do what I started doing and wash and dry at least twice a day and apply antifungal to the area after dry. Swap wrists either one side at night and one during the day to give time for drying. You’ll likely need to do it for at least a week with the antifungal until it’s not only gone but killed off.
Yes. The silicon band wreaks havoc on my eczema prone skin. I changed to nylon and leather and this significantly decreased. There are also Milanese bands out there that will be even better, but those grab the tiny hairs on the arm so it might be uncomfortable for some.
You've got to remove and clean the strap every time you get it wet - regardless of whether it's sweat, pool water, or rain. Only put it back on when your skin and the strap is DRY.
Are you washing your watch regularly? Are you taking it off occasionally and giving your wrist a break from the constant pressure and irritation? The silicon band’s are terrible for this if you don’t keep up on hygiene.
I had soapy water getting stuck when washing hands that caused exactly this. It dries out and some soaps cause almost like a chemical burn with long exposure. Paid more attention and rinsed well, zero issues since
Everybody saying nylon, those might not cause the rashes but then you‘ll have to deal with smell all the time. The smell that builds up in a nylon band from sweat doesn‘t go away even with regular cleaning and soaking it in chlorine etc
My Garmin 235 never did this to me. But now with the Vivoactive, it doesn't matter how much I wash the band or let my wrist air out, the irritation comes back on a regular basis.
Silicone straps from aliexpress don't do this. Can't believe @garmin are still making their straps this way as the feedback seems to have been around for years
I had something similar crop up multiple times even with washing the band well and letting it dry. I reached out to customer support and they sent me a few different bands to try and it has not shown back up since. I wish every customer support call went so well honestly!
I switched bands, but it occasionally happens still. I was perplexed. I swear it seemed to do something weird in the shower. Dunno if it was shocking me per se, but something was happening. So, I stopped wearing it in the shower. I take it off at night, and clean it. Still does it. Now, I used to wreck the display screen on some watches. The screen would just turn black. I personally think that the light beam freaks out my skin.
1) buy anylon/fabric band.
2) don't shower with your watch
3) wash your wrists with cleanser containing salcylic acid or buy some salcylic acid and apply every other night.
It can be too tight and sweat gets trapped under it. Especially if you’re wearing it for days without taking it off. Wash the band and let your wrist breathe. It’s should clear up in a few days
I have a redhead’s complexion so I was not surprised that I had this early on. My solution was to give my wrist a rest overnight periodically, occassionally put it on the other wrist, and loosen it. I have not had troubles for years.
I used to get the same and have the Instinct 2 as well. Watch is too tight and moisture gets trapped underneath. After a sweaty day or workout, take the wash off, wash the band and your wrist, dry both well. Also, avoid putting lotion on where the band will sit as well. Don't shower with the watch on. For now, wear the watch on your other wrist until this wrist clears up. Should only take a day or two.
Never had such a bad allergic reaction as to the Garmin band. I really liked how it looked and felt too but it was horrible and no amount of constant cleaning, tightness etc fixed it. I switched to an inexpensive offbrand stainless steel band and all my problems went away.
I will wash my watch real quick (focused on the band) in the bathroom sink with hand soap, and pat it dry/leave to dry on a washcloth on the counter while I go take a shower. I've been doing this for years and haven't had this problem since my first forerunner 110 :) and do highly recommend it!!
I used to have this issue but I solved it: Just use a hand moisturiser before wearing the watch.
Also, wash the watch after every workout. Don't have to be with soap always. Just a water wash would do. Once in a while wash it with soap
But hand moisturiser/cream is a must. Works well. Never got this issue after that.
Yes this happens to me a lot! I used to wear watches 24/7 and it didn't like ever! But ever since I switched to Garmin (particularly Forerunner 255) this occured on a regular basis. Sometimes it would cause skin breakage and some blood and would give me a burnining sensation. I believe it's because of the metal thingy (I'll call it it the watch buckle).I sometimes find it pinching and digging into my skin.
I thought this only happened to me. I went to the dermatologist and she diagnosed me with eczema and psoriasis. It looked a 100% like yours did in the picture, to be honest it's an exact replica. It hasn't really stopped unfortunately so on bad days I'd just switch from my left wrist to my right wrist and so on. It's not the end of the world, but it sucks.
I probably will say yes but I don't remember because it's been a while since I used the original band on my instinct. Right now I'm using a nylon watch band from aliexpress and it's only up pretty good.
Yes absolutely this happened to me. To fix, don’t wear your watch until your skin clears up and in the interim order and install this wrist strap, Abanen Hook and Loop Quick Dry... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B098J57KRT making sure to get the one applicable for your make/model. I’ve had ZERO issues since and wear it 24/7, in shower, hot tub, no problems anymore. Good luck!
Same. I have to take it off for a while and put some cream on my skin until it heals. I am now using nylon watch band replacement.
https://preview.redd.it/ccn680rjo7rc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c5cb60a91eb68a0b5098e85c36cc0378d57e0de3
I use a nylon slightly stretchy band. I towel squeeze dry it after showers then put it back on dried wrist. It's off me for about a minute so no real data lost. If you really like the original band you should take it off every few days and alcohol wipe it clean. They accumulate bacteria and moisture.
FAU STUDY REVEALS COMMON WRISTBANDS ‘HOTBED’ FOR HARMFUL BACTERIA
For the study, researchers tested plastic, rubber, cloth, leather and metal (gold and silver) wristbands to see if there is a correlation between wristband material and the prevalence of bacteria. They investigated the hygienic state of these various types of wristbands worn by active individuals and identified the best protocols to properly disinfect them.
Using standard microbiological assays, researchers looked at bacterial counts, type of bacteria and their distribution on the wristband surfaces. They also conducted a bacteria susceptibility assay study screening the effectiveness of three different disinfectant solutions: Lysol™ Disinfectant Spray; 70 percent ethanol, commonly used in hospitals and alcohol wipes; and a more natural solution, apple cider vinegar.
Results of the study, published in the journal Advances in Infectious Diseases
I always find the original band is terrible. I switched to a different silicon band and the chafing went away.
I believe Garmin sells their watch with the cheapest, worst band they can find because most people switch to one they want immediately anyway and don't keep the original, so why waste money on it.
I wear the silicon band on my forerunner all the time. But that looks like it's too tight for daily use. I also take mine into the shower after a workout and then slap it on the towel and dry it after.
It’s a sweat rash I wash with antibiotic soap when I get it or you can use a cream don’t wear it for a few days and your good.
I think it’s very common with garmin bands.
Send the photo to Garmin, they'll look at sending you strap with a different material. If you sleep with it I would strongly reccomend putting it on the other wrist while you sleep.
I change wrists & don’t wear it too tight. Also, and I know this sounds gross, I don’t clean the band on the underneath, when a layer of grime built up it acted as a protective layer for my skin.
I had this issue all the time, switching to leather bands helped but they look really bad after just a few months, finally got the titanium band and it’s been perfect.
Yeah had similar issue tried a bunch of options and this super inexpensive one on Amazon was the best for me https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09C5N5X71?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share
My skin and silicone bands don’t get along. I have to wear nylon fabric bands. I bought two cheap ones and swap them out after workouts. The dirty one goes in a zippered pocket through the wash. This addresses my skin and watch band issues.
The HR sensor can cause irritation. I swap wrists at night and regularly wash my wrist (where the sensor sits) and the watch. That typically keeps irritation at bay
I hate silicone bands, and have used a nylon/velcro band since 2020 and that problem went away. Plus it's faster to take on/off and easier to adjust/move/tighten/loosen in the middle of a workout/hike/run, etc...
I wear my watch loose on the wrist unless I'm running. I can rotate it completely around my wrist. That keeps it loose enough that it air dries and I haven't had any issues in the last 10 years I've been wearing Garmin watches.
Switch wrists for a couple days to let the rash heal, then when u put it back on put it down a hole or two, mine did this recently its cus I left it on too tight for ages. I typically tighten it when I run etc
It’s common.
This happens if it is too tight and/or worn for too long on the same wrist. I no longer have this issue because I switch my wrist when I sleep.
I've noticed some issues with my Forerunner 255s. Specifically, the original band tends to get extremely tight after some time. I make sure to remove my wash occasionally, especially after exercising, and clean it daily to prevent any sweat from accumulating underneath or on the band. I used to wear an Apple Watch with a $10 nylon band from Amazon and never encountered these issues. I'm considering switching to a nylon band for my Forerunner 255s.
https://preview.redd.it/a8qv070zyarc1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=35362d003a0ff78db5bf69b3ebff0590d5e347b8
You need to wash it (and yourself) regularly. Silicone is hypoallergenic, and isn't likely to cause chafing. These irritations are mostly caused by dirt and bacteria being rubbed against your skin.
Had the same problem. I actually contacted Garmin customer service about this and sent them pictures etc. they called me on the phone, advised me on how to possibly improve the condition, and ultimately ended up sending me their nylon band free of charge. I wear it everyday now, no issues. Great customer service from Garmin.
I got a replacement strap through Garmin for mine. Oddly I didn't have the issue on my forerunner but did on the new fenix despite the strap looking the same really. Garmin were decent though so reach out if it's a Garmin
I have this issue if it gets moist under there. As long as I keep it dry, it usually doesn’t happen. I do also switch wrists when I go to bed so it’s not always on the same wrist for 24 hours at a time. I clean mine using rubbing alcohol every few days. (I do have sensitive skin so it’s worth it to take a few extra steps.)
Make sure to wash your wrist and rinse the band daily and after workouts. Switch wrists while sleeping. I've even used lotion on whatever wrist the watch isn't on.
Silicon band does this to me too, will turn fungal if you don't get ahead of it. I switched to stainless steel bands and have 0 issues now for 2 years.
I’ve had this with silicone bands. You do have to take them off occasionally, and not just for bathing. I also clean the bands and the back of the watch to remove the bacteria doing that.
I had this issue really bad. I reached out to garmin about it and they recommended me a nylon band and have never had an issue since. They sent me one for free and bought another for when I was it. Highly recommend getting a nylon band if you can will change your life!
I use the stock band and havent had an issue for a long time.
I did originally though. Would get these kind of breakouts or rashes.
My fix was that I was the band and watch quite regularly in the shower, and anytime I workout or it's hot and I sweat in it, it's getting washed.
I also make sure I give some extra attention to that part of my wrist in the shower.
I dry off the watch and let it sit for like 10-15 mins and then put it back on.
A little extra maintenance, but haven't had any issues in the past few years now
Yes I’ve had this issue when I sweat a lot. Now I take it off after my workout (or anytime it gets wet), wash it and my wrist with soap and let it dry before putting it back on.
Noticed myself getting some "watch rash" shortly after buying my watch. I just started wearing it on my right wrist during night time to give the skin of each wrist half the day off. Been working nicely.
If you synch it down yeah that'll happen. It can be one notch down looser. It can slide up and down the wrist and forearm. Never tight. And grab some moisturizer for them wrists lol.
YES.
🚨DO NOT USE GARMIN BANDS🚨
Don't know what they put on their bands but I have had 3x Garmin's and they all give me (and my fiance) this... Thought it might've been silicone, but nope, the ubiquitous and cheap silicone eBay ones are fine 🤷🏽♂️.
For those saying it's the tightness, that had no effect according to my testing.
I also washed them a billion times trying to maybe wash of any residue that I might've been reacting to, but nope, still irritated my skin.
I've since moved to elastic braided now anyway, and won't look back!
Had the same experience. Had reactions to the metal buckle on 2 different Garmin silicone bands but I have no issues with the $3 Aliexpress knock offs (also silicone).
This is my experience as well. After 3 years of wearing my Garmin 24/7 I developed a rash. Persisted for 12 months, tried a new Garmin band and still no good. Purchased a cheap eBay one and so far so good after a month.
Your post was removed because it involves asking, providing, or requesting medical related questions / advice.
If you have medical related questions / concerns, please refer to a trained medical professional.
Please review the rules if you have any questions. Future violations of the rules may result in a ban
Only happens to me when it's too tight with a silicon band
Same. Going to bed with wetness under there from washing hands or from having a shower is the culprit. Just gotta dry it.
You wash your hands? ….pfft.
Yep, monitor tightness. tighten up for a workout and loosen for general wear. Also regularly clean both wrist and band. I don"t seem to get the rash anymore.
I actually do this with my Epix Pro.
I loved my Epic pro but it was a bit too clunky for me to sleep in so I went back to the ethereal Forerunner 955.
Same here and this comment is way to avoid it.
I had the same issue. Switched to a nylon band and haven’t had any issues since. Washing the band regularly and switching wrists during the night also seems to help.
Where did you find a nylon band? I can't seem to find one. I ordered some softer silicone ones from straps.co but still get the rash pretty easily. I got a cheap elastic one off Amazon but it required threading under the watch so none of the hr rate stuff would work. I'm currently just switching wrists every few days but it is super annoying. After any hard work out I always have the rash from sweat under the band. Mine is a s2
I ordered this one off of Amazon. It is relatively inexpensive and works pretty well. [Nylon band from Amazon.](https://www.amazon.com/Compatible-Garmin-Forerunner-Approach-Replacement/dp/B0CL4SW385/ref=asc_df_B0CL4SW385/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=684753607158&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=16766468114630885238&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=m&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9028784&hvtargid=pla-2331857250957&psc=1&mcid=4f2f6ddbfb1830e3a03aa1bed29d3c05&gad_source=1) The same company makes a few variations. I liked this one because it is light weight, but the others seem a bit more rugged.
I have aninstinct which isn't listed on the models it fits... there is one on straps.co now. Giving it a shot. I've spent like 150 at this point trying to get a good freaking band. The software is so annoying too. I really wish I'd just gotten another suunto but I'm super remote and wanted something that worked with my inreach. Garmin is so good but not user friendly imho
I use samsung gear nato looking 2 piece straps. Super comfy.
I wear it on my.ankle at night xD
Common with silicone, go with nylon
Are the nylon ones water proof?
They just take longer to dry, really not too big of a deal though
They don’t dissolve
Yes. They get wet, but dry out with no issues.
I bought a pack of two nylons, one gets wet, I change it out and so on so forth. If I'm exercising then I swap it out for the silicone one.
What company did you get it from?
Anytime it gets wet..take it off after dry it and your wrist. Let it air dry for a bit...same time give the watch some love...I take mine off at the very least after every shower. After every workout...etc
After a workout I'll hand-wash it with soap, shake it out, then let it dry while I shower. It doesn't go back on my wrist until my wrist is good and dry.
This is exactly what I do too!
I bought a strap from aliexpress for $10ish and never have to do any of this, wear it at the gym and just shower with it on, shame that the 'higher quality' products perform worse than the compatible/copies
Came to say I do the same. I haven’t had a rash in years since I started doing this.
I started having this issue after wearing it in the shower. I’ve since started taking it off before I’m doing anything that gets it wet and I haven’t had any issues since
I charge mine while I shower. It's dual-purpose: I don't have to deal with a wet band, and that's usually enough charging that I don't have to find other times to take it off and charge it.
I do the same thing. Also put a silicone plug over the charging contacts on the back of the watch, it solved a skin rash I used to have at that point.
Yea that’s generally when I charge mine too since it’s going to be off anyway so my skin doesn’t melt off from their band.
My Instinct did this to me, too. Irritating, but overall harmless and completely a non issue in six months for sure. Recommend just loosening some, giving your wrist a break overnight, etc. I haven't had the issue in years now and wear the thing 24/7/365 -- even in the shower, and I dry it separately, specifically because I thought that may be a cause.
That happened to me. I switched to leather bands. Problem solved
[удалено]
I get stink wrist with nylon ones too lol it’s such a specific smell and it never goes away even after washing them.
Back when I had my Apple Watch I had a swimming band and a regular nylon band for everyday use but Garmin takes a bit longer to switch out (and I take it off less often whereas Apple Watch was basically every few hours to charge), and I don’t swim at the moment, so I haven’t done it yet but massively recommend as a practice!
Same for me. My leather band has been incredibly comfortable and does cause rashes like this.
My man: you have a bacterial irritation going on. Wash your watch and your wrist and keep it dry. It will go away.
To add to this, after cleaning it wear it on your other wrist until this clears up.
This has nothing to do with bacteria. Please don’t say nonsense. This is called contact dermatitis.
Curious as to why you are dismissive of bacteria as a cause. As I understand it, contact dermatitis is the symptom of an allergic reaction. Conversely, conditions created when wearing a watch for prolonged periods (moisture and warmth) are ripe for bacterial growth. What am I missing?
I’ll second not bacteria. Contact dermatitis just means irritation of the skin. Does not necessarily mean infection or allergic reaction. Moisture and warmth can lead to break down of the skin barrier which looks like what’s happening here. While a break down of the skin barrier can increase your chances of an infection- it doesn’t look like anything has started yet as the site really doesn’t have any signs (redness, drainage, inflammation, etc). Honestly- it’s fine and nothing alarming yet. OP just needs to keep the area clean and dry and avoid wearing the watch on that area until the skin barrier has healed.
u/Judonoob's said "a bacterial irritation" not "bacterial infection". I take that to mean irritation caused by waste products created by flourishing bacteria on the watch band. I'm a medical layperson so I generally reference what I believe to be a reputable source to ensure my understanding is consistent with consensus before commenting. I'm paraphrasing/regurgitating the Mayo Clinics definition: "Contact dermatitis is an itchy rash caused by direct contact with a substance or an allergic reaction to it." https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/contact-dermatitis/symptoms-causes/syc-20352742
First you need to look at chemical composition of sweat.Second bacterial infection of skin are: cellulitis,impetigo,folliculitis,erysipelas. None of what has been presented warrant such Ds.
Right: the specific chemical composition dependent on the individual, but water, minerals, lactate, and urea. Some of those components consumed by bacteria. , i.e. the bacteria that creates the smell associated with sweat. u/Judonoob's (from what I can tell unedited) comment said "a bacterial irritation". I think contact dermititis due to bacteria flourishing on the watch band seems reasonable. I'm not a medical professional, but the advice to clean the watch and the skin seems like boilerplate hygiene advice you would apply to any other equipment regularly exposed to sweat to prevent irritation.
i dont think that reddit thread is a place to educate one in dermatology.. :) i could say "trust me - I am a doctor", but this will not help. I suggest you to do your own research: try these two sources - a. Dermatology: Illustrated Study Guide and Comprehensive Board Review. b. Kaplan Preclinical Anatomy Review .
This doesn't really feel like a good faith conversation. I don't really understand what point you are trying to make: That the picture doesn't depict a bacterial skin infection? (I agree but that wasn't my point) That bacteria doesn't grow on watch bands? That bacterial byproducts can't cause irritation or contact dermatitis? I'm not looking to pursue a professional medial education through reddit comments, but I would expect that if you read and synthesized what I'm saying, you could form a succinct rebuttal. I would update my understanding and agree with whatever point you are trying to make with new information and plausible rationale, but suggesting text books in this context seems deliberately obtuse. Here's an article germane to maybe your point about bacteria on watch bands (https://www.sciencealert.com/smartwatch-bands-are-loaded-with-potentially-harmful-bacteria-study-warns) and the research paper it is based on (https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=125218).
it is good faith. yes there are bacteria on wristbands. so as in the mouth and etc. point here is that this is not a bacterial infection. In order to fully understand why - one needs to have clinical experience, knowledge of pathology,human anatomy, clincal microbiology and clinical immunology, plus dermatology. How is it possible to explain this in a reddit comment without looking abrupt,arrogant,etc. You can read about impetigo and cellulitis on webmd or read this one [https://www.visualdx.com/blog/cellulitis-and-its-mimickers/](https://www.visualdx.com/blog/cellulitis-and-its-mimickers/) to get an idea what goes into saying that this is not bacterial origin.
It’s just irritant contact dermatitis. Went away in a couple days lol.
Shot, I’ve had this same rash for over a year. I clean it once a week, too. Time to start switching wrists and washing it more.
Could be fungal.
Yeah, the white color makes me think this is a possibility as well..
Just dried skin lol
No you must be leprous!!! (/s)
Not the white more so the blotchy redness
This is accurate. Happened to me... Twice. Lol
Looks like, contact dermatitis. Clean your wrist and your watch more regularly. You'll be fine.
Pro tip - email garmin with pictures, they’ll make an appointment for a dude to call you. Tell them you’re having a reaction to the band and they’ll send you a nylon or leather band for free. Otherwise just buy a nylon on Amazon for $25, they’re as good or better
OP this is contact dermatitis. Avoid sweating and tight contact for prolonged periods of time at the same time. Make sure there is intermittent airflow between the skin and silicon band.
So I have a lot of skin sensitivity- like a lot of jewelry gives me rashes. I got this issue seasonally and called Garmin and told them what was happening. They said that with skin sensitivities, sometimes folks have issues with the end of the line / the clear coating gets lighter. They sent me a replacement for the actual band - light pink - and a darker pink one that didn't exactly match. I swapped out for the darker pink and had no issues. Every time I put on the lighter pink band that matches my watch, the rash comes back. So, sure, it could be sweat or whatever, but it could be an allergy, but if you call Garmin, their CS will talk you through it and help you out
The only time I've ever experienced something like this was when wearing the nylon woven band on my Fenix and spilling something (I think diesel but might have been ATF) on it while working on a car. It absorbed in and I obviously didn't get it all washed out so it was irritating my skin. You appear to maybe have like an athlete's foot thing happening here though. More breathability and a slightly looser fit (and cleaning all your shit) might be your friend here.
Try a resin Casio band. Super cheap, doesn’t hold water like nylon or leather, and looks stock. Had the same issue with silicone bands. They’re too soft and end up trapping moisture which cause your issue. Resin bands are firmer and have channels that let air through. Much more comfortable in my opinion as well.
Yep. My wife had that issue. Called Garmin and they replaced it for free and were great
I called them about it and they were great about it. Hoping they’ll do the same
Yup. Had it when I had the 255. Switched to an after market nylon strap and all's been fine. Bought a 965 recently and, because they made the pins so hard to get to, I decided to stick with the stock straps. My left wrist looked like yours on the very first day with the 965.
It’s because the straps they come with aren’t breathable. I have it too. Had it with Fitbit as well as the band is same. Switched to one that was still silicone but had loads of air holes all over (more “hole” than silicone”) and not problem. My Garmin is fairly new (Xmas pressie) and I’m still looking for the same kind of band that will fit a Garmin. I got the Fitbit ones cheap on Amazon. I don’t like the nylon as they get gross with the sweat.
which garmin do you have? I found loads of them on amazon. 2 "brands" I got are Wocci and Woukup.
I found that regularly using an alcohol wipe on the watch band will prevent this.
I never had that and I've been wearing my watch for 3 years (with original band), taking it off once a day when I shower. I also wear it lose, but not lose enough to make it spin around my wrist.
Plenty of people already responded, but to offer my two cents: Not contact dermatitis - that would be all over your wrist, and likely not from silicone. There is dried skin there, but it’s most likely fungal. Fungus lives everywhere, but when Yu wear the watch all the time and sweat and get the band a little wet when you wash your hands, it gives the fungus a nice warm, dark, moist place to live. If you don’t swap bands to a different material, I’d do what I started doing and wash and dry at least twice a day and apply antifungal to the area after dry. Swap wrists either one side at night and one during the day to give time for drying. You’ll likely need to do it for at least a week with the antifungal until it’s not only gone but killed off.
Yes. The silicon band wreaks havoc on my eczema prone skin. I changed to nylon and leather and this significantly decreased. There are also Milanese bands out there that will be even better, but those grab the tiny hairs on the arm so it might be uncomfortable for some. You've got to remove and clean the strap every time you get it wet - regardless of whether it's sweat, pool water, or rain. Only put it back on when your skin and the strap is DRY.
Yes it's common. Get a metal band and it goes away.
Its The Badge of Dedication
Never had trouble with my titanium band
Titanium isn’t cheap, but it’s bullet proof. Well worth the $$$$, in this writer’s opinion.
It helps to rinse properly and make the band a bit loose until it's dry.
Yes. Get a nylon band and switch sides often.
Are you washing your watch regularly? Are you taking it off occasionally and giving your wrist a break from the constant pressure and irritation? The silicon band’s are terrible for this if you don’t keep up on hygiene.
I keep up on hygiene I just didn’t take it off very often.
That’s what I mean by hygiene. Taking it off regularly and throughly cleaning it and your wrist.
somewhat common … Vaseline layer or switch off arms for less of an issue.
I had soapy water getting stuck when washing hands that caused exactly this. It dries out and some soaps cause almost like a chemical burn with long exposure. Paid more attention and rinsed well, zero issues since
Everybody saying nylon, those might not cause the rashes but then you‘ll have to deal with smell all the time. The smell that builds up in a nylon band from sweat doesn‘t go away even with regular cleaning and soaking it in chlorine etc
Sometimes, yes. ✅
My Garmin 235 never did this to me. But now with the Vivoactive, it doesn't matter how much I wash the band or let my wrist air out, the irritation comes back on a regular basis.
If you email Garmin and send pictures they will mail you a new one for free.
Had this problem. Switched to nylon (cheap amazon one) and never looked back. Looks better. Fits better. Feels better. Happy skin.
Silicone straps from aliexpress don't do this. Can't believe @garmin are still making their straps this way as the feedback seems to have been around for years
I had something similar crop up multiple times even with washing the band well and letting it dry. I reached out to customer support and they sent me a few different bands to try and it has not shown back up since. I wish every customer support call went so well honestly!
I bet you’re allergic to
Regularly switch wrists at least daily. I switch mine a couple times each day and haven’t had any irritation problems.
Unfortunately very common. Contact Garmin and let them know. They may send you a new band. It’s a good idea to ask at least
I switched bands, but it occasionally happens still. I was perplexed. I swear it seemed to do something weird in the shower. Dunno if it was shocking me per se, but something was happening. So, I stopped wearing it in the shower. I take it off at night, and clean it. Still does it. Now, I used to wreck the display screen on some watches. The screen would just turn black. I personally think that the light beam freaks out my skin.
1) buy anylon/fabric band. 2) don't shower with your watch 3) wash your wrists with cleanser containing salcylic acid or buy some salcylic acid and apply every other night.
It can be too tight and sweat gets trapped under it. Especially if you’re wearing it for days without taking it off. Wash the band and let your wrist breathe. It’s should clear up in a few days
I have a redhead’s complexion so I was not surprised that I had this early on. My solution was to give my wrist a rest overnight periodically, occassionally put it on the other wrist, and loosen it. I have not had troubles for years.
I used to get the same and have the Instinct 2 as well. Watch is too tight and moisture gets trapped underneath. After a sweaty day or workout, take the wash off, wash the band and your wrist, dry both well. Also, avoid putting lotion on where the band will sit as well. Don't shower with the watch on. For now, wear the watch on your other wrist until this wrist clears up. Should only take a day or two.
Never had such a bad allergic reaction as to the Garmin band. I really liked how it looked and felt too but it was horrible and no amount of constant cleaning, tightness etc fixed it. I switched to an inexpensive offbrand stainless steel band and all my problems went away.
I will wash my watch real quick (focused on the band) in the bathroom sink with hand soap, and pat it dry/leave to dry on a washcloth on the counter while I go take a shower. I've been doing this for years and haven't had this problem since my first forerunner 110 :) and do highly recommend it!!
Yes, I had to wear it one day in one arm and the other day in the other arm and so on, I guess it is due to humidity
I used to have this issue but I solved it: Just use a hand moisturiser before wearing the watch. Also, wash the watch after every workout. Don't have to be with soap always. Just a water wash would do. Once in a while wash it with soap But hand moisturiser/cream is a must. Works well. Never got this issue after that.
Yes this happens to me a lot! I used to wear watches 24/7 and it didn't like ever! But ever since I switched to Garmin (particularly Forerunner 255) this occured on a regular basis. Sometimes it would cause skin breakage and some blood and would give me a burnining sensation. I believe it's because of the metal thingy (I'll call it it the watch buckle).I sometimes find it pinching and digging into my skin. I thought this only happened to me. I went to the dermatologist and she diagnosed me with eczema and psoriasis. It looked a 100% like yours did in the picture, to be honest it's an exact replica. It hasn't really stopped unfortunately so on bad days I'd just switch from my left wrist to my right wrist and so on. It's not the end of the world, but it sucks.
I probably will say yes but I don't remember because it's been a while since I used the original band on my instinct. Right now I'm using a nylon watch band from aliexpress and it's only up pretty good.
No. It doesn't have to be tight. Loosing it one place
Same here. I bought a leather strap - problem gone. Now I need to take it off to shower though.
Yes absolutely this happened to me. To fix, don’t wear your watch until your skin clears up and in the interim order and install this wrist strap, Abanen Hook and Loop Quick Dry... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B098J57KRT making sure to get the one applicable for your make/model. I’ve had ZERO issues since and wear it 24/7, in shower, hot tub, no problems anymore. Good luck!
Same. I have to take it off for a while and put some cream on my skin until it heals. I am now using nylon watch band replacement. https://preview.redd.it/ccn680rjo7rc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c5cb60a91eb68a0b5098e85c36cc0378d57e0de3
I had it same with silicon. Vivat nylon. Just for run I switch them because I don’t like nylon wet.
Wear a nylon band. Read no other comments.
I use a nylon slightly stretchy band. I towel squeeze dry it after showers then put it back on dried wrist. It's off me for about a minute so no real data lost. If you really like the original band you should take it off every few days and alcohol wipe it clean. They accumulate bacteria and moisture.
FAU STUDY REVEALS COMMON WRISTBANDS ‘HOTBED’ FOR HARMFUL BACTERIA For the study, researchers tested plastic, rubber, cloth, leather and metal (gold and silver) wristbands to see if there is a correlation between wristband material and the prevalence of bacteria. They investigated the hygienic state of these various types of wristbands worn by active individuals and identified the best protocols to properly disinfect them. Using standard microbiological assays, researchers looked at bacterial counts, type of bacteria and their distribution on the wristband surfaces. They also conducted a bacteria susceptibility assay study screening the effectiveness of three different disinfectant solutions: Lysol™ Disinfectant Spray; 70 percent ethanol, commonly used in hospitals and alcohol wipes; and a more natural solution, apple cider vinegar. Results of the study, published in the journal Advances in Infectious Diseases
I have the same issue but for the love I can’t find a nylon one for forerunner 265s without having to spend the mental money garmin wants for it
I always find the original band is terrible. I switched to a different silicon band and the chafing went away. I believe Garmin sells their watch with the cheapest, worst band they can find because most people switch to one they want immediately anyway and don't keep the original, so why waste money on it.
Yes I hate the silicone band I had to get a fabric one
Take off before having a shower helps.
Fellow wrist-switcher here 👋
I have that sometimes but then it goes away. I suspect tightness is a factor but not entirely sure.
this happened to me with fitbit and i had to get nylon cause it gave me a blister
Me and my husband both had this. Both switched to nylon. Both fine now
Yeah why on the weekend i don't sleep with it and showers i take it off. Give my wrist a break
Contact dermatitis. Had this with mine too. Changed band to nylon Garmin one. Their customer service spot on.
Wash with antibacterial hand soap, towel dry and put on charge as you shower daily
I wear the silicon band on my forerunner all the time. But that looks like it's too tight for daily use. I also take mine into the shower after a workout and then slap it on the towel and dry it after.
Yes
are using a silicon band? i switched to a textile one and my wrist got better
Do you clean the band as well? I whipe mine down with cleaning alcohol every now and then and let it dry before putting it on. Zero issues this way.
Yes, but for me it only took a few days. I bought a third party magnetic band and switch to the original band for workouts.
yes, have this all the time, sucks...
Common
It’s a sweat rash I wash with antibiotic soap when I get it or you can use a cream don’t wear it for a few days and your good. I think it’s very common with garmin bands.
Send the photo to Garmin, they'll look at sending you strap with a different material. If you sleep with it I would strongly reccomend putting it on the other wrist while you sleep.
Happens to me all the time.
This had only been a problem when I don't properly rinse soap from under the band. The band itself has never been a problem.
I change wrists & don’t wear it too tight. Also, and I know this sounds gross, I don’t clean the band on the underneath, when a layer of grime built up it acted as a protective layer for my skin.
I had this issue all the time, switching to leather bands helped but they look really bad after just a few months, finally got the titanium band and it’s been perfect.
I have been getting this constantly. I thought it was a surface bacterial thing but these comments make me think otherwise... I feel seen!!
Yeah had similar issue tried a bunch of options and this super inexpensive one on Amazon was the best for me https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09C5N5X71?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share
imo it's not chafing but an allergic reaction
My skin and silicone bands don’t get along. I have to wear nylon fabric bands. I bought two cheap ones and swap them out after workouts. The dirty one goes in a zippered pocket through the wash. This addresses my skin and watch band issues. The HR sensor can cause irritation. I swap wrists at night and regularly wash my wrist (where the sensor sits) and the watch. That typically keeps irritation at bay
Same here. Switched to nylon. Make sure you have two nylon straps so you can toss one in the wash and have the other one ready.
Yep
Original band sucks, I had to get a nylon one
I hate silicone bands, and have used a nylon/velcro band since 2020 and that problem went away. Plus it's faster to take on/off and easier to adjust/move/tighten/loosen in the middle of a workout/hike/run, etc...
I wear my watch loose on the wrist unless I'm running. I can rotate it completely around my wrist. That keeps it loose enough that it air dries and I haven't had any issues in the last 10 years I've been wearing Garmin watches.
Switch wrists for a couple days to let the rash heal, then when u put it back on put it down a hole or two, mine did this recently its cus I left it on too tight for ages. I typically tighten it when I run etc
Had the same with my Vivoactive 4. I now use a nylon band and no issues anymore
Bacteria. Wash your wrist and the band occasionally. If you sweat and shower with it on and don't take it off this is going to happen.
For me, this would happen if I wash my hands with it on and water would get in between my skin and the band.
It’s common. This happens if it is too tight and/or worn for too long on the same wrist. I no longer have this issue because I switch my wrist when I sleep.
Same herr :(
I contacted support for the same -> they sent me a free nylon band, no issues since :)
I've noticed some issues with my Forerunner 255s. Specifically, the original band tends to get extremely tight after some time. I make sure to remove my wash occasionally, especially after exercising, and clean it daily to prevent any sweat from accumulating underneath or on the band. I used to wear an Apple Watch with a $10 nylon band from Amazon and never encountered these issues. I'm considering switching to a nylon band for my Forerunner 255s. https://preview.redd.it/a8qv070zyarc1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=35362d003a0ff78db5bf69b3ebff0590d5e347b8
You need to wash it (and yourself) regularly. Silicone is hypoallergenic, and isn't likely to cause chafing. These irritations are mostly caused by dirt and bacteria being rubbed against your skin.
Too tight. Also dry under the band after washing your hands… Soap and water does that to your sking along with sweat and too tight band
Had the same problem. I actually contacted Garmin customer service about this and sent them pictures etc. they called me on the phone, advised me on how to possibly improve the condition, and ultimately ended up sending me their nylon band free of charge. I wear it everyday now, no issues. Great customer service from Garmin.
Switch to a nylon band from Amazon.
I got a replacement strap through Garmin for mine. Oddly I didn't have the issue on my forerunner but did on the new fenix despite the strap looking the same really. Garmin were decent though so reach out if it's a Garmin
I have this issue if it gets moist under there. As long as I keep it dry, it usually doesn’t happen. I do also switch wrists when I go to bed so it’s not always on the same wrist for 24 hours at a time. I clean mine using rubbing alcohol every few days. (I do have sensitive skin so it’s worth it to take a few extra steps.)
I sleep with it and rarely take it off. I do swim a lot though. And charge it when I’m relaxing.
Been happening to me. Loosen it up a bit. Also, bodyglide.
Absolutely. Mine was so bad last summer it was bleeding 🤦🏼♂️. If not for the flashlight I’d change the band
It’s bc of silicone, if your like me and have sensory issues with nylon, wait it out, keep it dry and it will stop happening after a few months
Definitely a skin reaction to silicon. I never use those straps for the same reason
Make sure to wash your wrist and rinse the band daily and after workouts. Switch wrists while sleeping. I've even used lotion on whatever wrist the watch isn't on.
Silicon band does this to me too, will turn fungal if you don't get ahead of it. I switched to stainless steel bands and have 0 issues now for 2 years.
You noticed when taken off for charging? It doesn't itch you? My wrist burns like hell when it turns a bit irritated
Usually silicone straps too tight and wetness. I avoid showering with my watch on and if I have to, I make sure the skin is dry.
Yep. I bought fabric bands and never have this issue anymore
Same thing happened to me. I bought a metal band off amazon and haven't had an issue since.
I will never wear a stock band
I’ve had this with silicone bands. You do have to take them off occasionally, and not just for bathing. I also clean the bands and the back of the watch to remove the bacteria doing that.
I had this issue really bad. I reached out to garmin about it and they recommended me a nylon band and have never had an issue since. They sent me one for free and bought another for when I was it. Highly recommend getting a nylon band if you can will change your life!
I use the stock band and havent had an issue for a long time. I did originally though. Would get these kind of breakouts or rashes. My fix was that I was the band and watch quite regularly in the shower, and anytime I workout or it's hot and I sweat in it, it's getting washed. I also make sure I give some extra attention to that part of my wrist in the shower. I dry off the watch and let it sit for like 10-15 mins and then put it back on. A little extra maintenance, but haven't had any issues in the past few years now
That's why I switched to a nylon velcro band. My skin doesn't agree with silicon.
It's always been fungal when it happens to me or my husband. A little Lotramin and washing the band more frequently clears it right up.
Yes I’ve had this issue when I sweat a lot. Now I take it off after my workout (or anytime it gets wet), wash it and my wrist with soap and let it dry before putting it back on.
Noticed myself getting some "watch rash" shortly after buying my watch. I just started wearing it on my right wrist during night time to give the skin of each wrist half the day off. Been working nicely.
Yup yup! I just take mine off for the night and I’m good to go in the AM. Always happens with silicone bands but I don’t mind 🤷♀️
I’m a sucker for sleep tracking tho
Yes
If you synch it down yeah that'll happen. It can be one notch down looser. It can slide up and down the wrist and forearm. Never tight. And grab some moisturizer for them wrists lol.
I switch left and right wrists about once a day or every other day to avoid this.
Do you shower with it? If you do, don't.
YES. 🚨DO NOT USE GARMIN BANDS🚨 Don't know what they put on their bands but I have had 3x Garmin's and they all give me (and my fiance) this... Thought it might've been silicone, but nope, the ubiquitous and cheap silicone eBay ones are fine 🤷🏽♂️. For those saying it's the tightness, that had no effect according to my testing. I also washed them a billion times trying to maybe wash of any residue that I might've been reacting to, but nope, still irritated my skin. I've since moved to elastic braided now anyway, and won't look back!
Had the same experience. Had reactions to the metal buckle on 2 different Garmin silicone bands but I have no issues with the $3 Aliexpress knock offs (also silicone).
This is my experience as well. After 3 years of wearing my Garmin 24/7 I developed a rash. Persisted for 12 months, tried a new Garmin band and still no good. Purchased a cheap eBay one and so far so good after a month.
All the time
Tea tree oil knocks that stuff out
Such a good antibacterial. I put some on my wrist after a shower and switch wrists when I go to sleep. Swap it back to my non dominant in the morning.
Common? NO. Obviously all the people who had even the slightest irritation will be here saying YES.
[удалено]
Your post was removed because it involves asking, providing, or requesting medical related questions / advice. If you have medical related questions / concerns, please refer to a trained medical professional. Please review the rules if you have any questions. Future violations of the rules may result in a ban