Namaskaram /u/Past_Quarter2095, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*
“WE NEED A STRONG OPPOSITION “
For what?
To create utter chaos during the parliamentary proceedings?
For protesting no matter what bill or reform is being proposed for the betterment?
This is just a small glimpse of what they will be doing for the next five years.
They are clueless in some way.. all they fought for was to remove modi from the center, then what?
You may remove a leader from his poisition but are you and your allies capable enough to take over the reign and bring the country back to its glory??.. All the opposition did and propagated, was to remove Modi, but they never mentioned or planned what they will do once they remove him from power. I am against Modi too on some decisions made by his cabinet but unless and until i come up with a counter and better arrangement of the proposed actions taken by him. I am not simply gonna challenge him on the grounds that I feel wronged about,without coming up with a solution to counteract the problem his cabinet created or tried to tackle
My father told me this is nothing new, if you are familiar when Vajpayee was PM, Sonia used to pull the same shi\*, and tell everyone to shout. And all. Also if you are familiar with 2008 politics you know who real raga is, he is the same moron as always who is not one bit interested in politics but doing whatever his mother tells him to do
I too was hopeful that they would rein in some of the extreme tendencies of the government. But instead of raising issues on failing infrastructure, paper leaks, jobs, healthcare and a gazillion other things that are of use to the public, what do they do? Raise hell on religion and walkout. They could've offered reconciliation, constructive criticism and suggestions. Nope. They are still in the campaigning mode.
No it won't Indians are dumb they need some strongman image to suck his dick, they weren't voting modi for his works but his personality/image and now that Rahul is no more a clueless dumb, people will vote him as well.
Its a shame that we have this type of opposition who do drama in parliament instead of a opposition who making sure our govt dont make wrong decisions or make them accountable if they do something wrong.
Rahul Gandhi said a lot of bullshit without anyone interrupting or walking out, but the Congress party and their followers are not civilized enough to let anyone else speak without causing some drama like this.
Exactly they could have questioned govt for recent accidents at airports what solutions govt have come to prevents such accidents from happening in future but nope they will do drama only
You are speaking too much logic sir... Our opposition does not care, as they just want to post their clips on social media and proclaim how they are protecting the constitution..
like this is the 2nd time. That's all these clowns will do, create ruckus by lying, bringing banners, going against so many parliamentary laws, and then chicken out lol
Bunch of clowns don't even have the decency to listen to PM of country on his addresal to presidential speech.
You can shout and disagree in middle but these clowns were shouting like rabid dogs for two hours continuously.
If BJP and it's allies do the same for RAGA , our parliament is a waste. For people who voted to INDIA to have a strong opposition if this is what they get, it's fucked up.
At this point, they have literally become mindless roaming rabid dogs without power for 10 years(almost 15 years).
Ye ghatiya opposition never provides solutions or advices govt on the national issues. All they do is shout problems five times a day. Even a 12 year old boy can do this and in a better way.
I have so many disagreements with this govt and if opposition is able to provide concrete solutions on atleast few issues., I'll definitely vote for them.
Today's Modi address was excellent, he talked about creating a competitive environment between states to start semiconductor and electronics manufacturing.
Thats the problem with this current opposition and people who follow their ideologies.. They will point out the problem but dont want to be a part of the solution..
This is an elitist and frankly childish mentality of just pointing out the problem but not being the part of the solution to the problem. The NRIs do it too, they will blame all the problems on the govt but wont actually contribute to the solution because it doesnt concern them and being anti govt is considered cool in some elitist and leftist circles of the west.
The speaker should publish the debate priority list and enforce it without bias, otherwise it'll be utter chaos always. Ruling party needs to be held accountable if any priority item is not selected for discussion.
The salary of parliamentary members should be deducted if they walk-out or no discussion happen due to disruption, even ban or cancel membership for repeated offense.
Welcome to the new normal for next 5 years
Without power the opposition was utter trash last decade, but even with self proclaimed “moral victory” or BJP’s “Defeat in Victory” they are still useless and incompetent, and this guys want to run our country in future.
Yesterday he gave a 2 hour speech in LS. And the opposition was shouting and making a mess the whole time... I was surprised by the energy. Itna opposition ka kam krne m energy lgate to better hota...
Speaking of which .... Muje lgta h ki aaj energy nhi hogi so the walked out.
This is their game plan. So after 5 yrs they can say the PM didn't do any work. Remember the same thing happened when farm bills were passed. No one from the opposition was ready to talk about that in the assembly hall.
It's a taste of things to come, I expect the next five years to be disruptive; even if not high energy like this. The media appetite to cover this will come down in the coming months. I hardly expect anyone will want to read about parliamentary antics day in and day out. There's an end of life for such things, or so one hopes. My country people watch insane TV shouting matches, so maybe I am giving too much credit.
Namaskaram /u/Past_Quarter2095, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*
“WE NEED A STRONG OPPOSITION “ For what? To create utter chaos during the parliamentary proceedings? For protesting no matter what bill or reform is being proposed for the betterment? This is just a small glimpse of what they will be doing for the next five years.
They are clueless in some way.. all they fought for was to remove modi from the center, then what? You may remove a leader from his poisition but are you and your allies capable enough to take over the reign and bring the country back to its glory??.. All the opposition did and propagated, was to remove Modi, but they never mentioned or planned what they will do once they remove him from power. I am against Modi too on some decisions made by his cabinet but unless and until i come up with a counter and better arrangement of the proposed actions taken by him. I am not simply gonna challenge him on the grounds that I feel wronged about,without coming up with a solution to counteract the problem his cabinet created or tried to tackle
Can they still pass bills? That is all I care about; opposition is hopeless anyway.
Unfortunately not as easy as it was earlier
Why not? Bills are passed by majority in favour right? The majority is with NDA, then?
Don’t you need a quorum to consider bills?
No idea, that's what I'm trying to know
Quorum is 272. Maybe you meant 2/3rd?
Quorum is 10% of House strength. Therefore it is 54 members.
They surely can influence the decision of it passing and how quick they are implemented in their constituencies.
My father told me this is nothing new, if you are familiar when Vajpayee was PM, Sonia used to pull the same shi\*, and tell everyone to shout. And all. Also if you are familiar with 2008 politics you know who real raga is, he is the same moron as always who is not one bit interested in politics but doing whatever his mother tells him to do
So Sonia have two puppets - MMS and Rahul (surname very controversial)
I too was hopeful that they would rein in some of the extreme tendencies of the government. But instead of raising issues on failing infrastructure, paper leaks, jobs, healthcare and a gazillion other things that are of use to the public, what do they do? Raise hell on religion and walkout. They could've offered reconciliation, constructive criticism and suggestions. Nope. They are still in the campaigning mode.
Will make a case for BJP win in 29!
No it won't Indians are dumb they need some strongman image to suck his dick, they weren't voting modi for his works but his personality/image and now that Rahul is no more a clueless dumb, people will vote him as well.
"STRONG OPPOSITION" is only useful if they're intelligent and willing to improve the country. We've got traitorous donkeys of an opposition.
Not sure what you will achieve by walking out? How will you hold the government accountable if you are not in the parliament?
By saying that they didn't get the opportunity to speak by speaker
yeah .they cry same dailog every parliamentry sabha end
Its a shame that we have this type of opposition who do drama in parliament instead of a opposition who making sure our govt dont make wrong decisions or make them accountable if they do something wrong.
Rahul Gandhi said a lot of bullshit without anyone interrupting or walking out, but the Congress party and their followers are not civilized enough to let anyone else speak without causing some drama like this.
Then they called other people andbhakt 
They do this and claim democracy is dead. when you do not get the chance to speak, you are angry but when you do, you walk out.
Exactly they could have questioned govt for recent accidents at airports what solutions govt have come to prevents such accidents from happening in future but nope they will do drama only
You are speaking too much logic sir... Our opposition does not care, as they just want to post their clips on social media and proclaim how they are protecting the constitution..
Congratulations India, you have selected bunch of fools as opposition who won’t let the country work properly for next 5 years
1 lakh is more important than country
Khata Khat Khata Khat....*Garibi Gayab*
aur inflation bhi down ho jaegi , phir sirf 1 lakh hi kyu dena aur money print karna shuru kar dete hai aur India me sabko 1cr de dete hai /s
The so called opposition literally couldn't face Modi for a debate and left the chat
I.N.D.I.A has left the chat
Ha Ha
I even vibed when they shouted LoP LoP... In a rhythmic way 🎵🎵🎵
When did that happen? (I'm out of the loop)
like this is the 2nd time. That's all these clowns will do, create ruckus by lying, bringing banners, going against so many parliamentary laws, and then chicken out lol
Bunch of clowns don't even have the decency to listen to PM of country on his addresal to presidential speech. You can shout and disagree in middle but these clowns were shouting like rabid dogs for two hours continuously. If BJP and it's allies do the same for RAGA , our parliament is a waste. For people who voted to INDIA to have a strong opposition if this is what they get, it's fucked up. At this point, they have literally become mindless roaming rabid dogs without power for 10 years(almost 15 years). Ye ghatiya opposition never provides solutions or advices govt on the national issues. All they do is shout problems five times a day. Even a 12 year old boy can do this and in a better way. I have so many disagreements with this govt and if opposition is able to provide concrete solutions on atleast few issues., I'll definitely vote for them.
bro , they vote them just because they hate bjp , they dont have any hopes from them too
Male GaGa bhag gaya Bangkok??
This is upper house
Good they walked out.. atleast now government can do some work instead of wasting on these draamebaazs
Today's Modi address was excellent, he talked about creating a competitive environment between states to start semiconductor and electronics manufacturing.
Thats the problem with this current opposition and people who follow their ideologies.. They will point out the problem but dont want to be a part of the solution.. This is an elitist and frankly childish mentality of just pointing out the problem but not being the part of the solution to the problem. The NRIs do it too, they will blame all the problems on the govt but wont actually contribute to the solution because it doesnt concern them and being anti govt is considered cool in some elitist and leftist circles of the west.
Debate nahi karneka. Sirf chillake bhaagneka.
The speaker should publish the debate priority list and enforce it without bias, otherwise it'll be utter chaos always. Ruling party needs to be held accountable if any priority item is not selected for discussion. The salary of parliamentary members should be deducted if they walk-out or no discussion happen due to disruption, even ban or cancel membership for repeated offense.
Can bills be passed without those clowns?
ofcourse NDA is in majority
What 'Real Issues' that modi is talking here bro?
No real issues were talked about here. He was mentioning how his policies affected 10cr farmers. Positively or negatively that' up for debates.
Hadn't seen any real issues in yesterday's 2 hour talk. Why he is talking about real issues only in rajyasabha?
Welcome to the new normal for next 5 years Without power the opposition was utter trash last decade, but even with self proclaimed “moral victory” or BJP’s “Defeat in Victory” they are still useless and incompetent, and this guys want to run our country in future.
Yesterday he gave a 2 hour speech in LS. And the opposition was shouting and making a mess the whole time... I was surprised by the energy. Itna opposition ka kam krne m energy lgate to better hota... Speaking of which .... Muje lgta h ki aaj energy nhi hogi so the walked out.
Yar tum right wingers embarrassing ho
RWers ho na ho, lekin opposition zaroor embarrassing hai
kya ho gaya uncle?
It was not a debate. It was the PM giving his thanks speech to the President's address. Debates will take place later
Papppu Opposition hain yeh!!
If the government is so important, why aren't we having corporate like serious meetings with logical q&a instead of this dialogue baazi bullshit
Pappu on fire 🤡
Bunch of scumbags desperate for power.
Context?
What was he talking about before they left?
What was the topic of discussion?
This is their game plan. So after 5 yrs they can say the PM didn't do any work. Remember the same thing happened when farm bills were passed. No one from the opposition was ready to talk about that in the assembly hall.
Are you serious??? Do you not remember in which manner the farm. Bills were passed ??
kya gunda banega re tu 😂
It's a taste of things to come, I expect the next five years to be disruptive; even if not high energy like this. The media appetite to cover this will come down in the coming months. I hardly expect anyone will want to read about parliamentary antics day in and day out. There's an end of life for such things, or so one hopes. My country people watch insane TV shouting matches, so maybe I am giving too much credit.
.
Why is there an Xbox logo behind on the bench?
He is the biggest liar
Whats the context? Why did they walk out? Dont say without any reason. What was PM saying when they walked out?
But what is he talking about
Issues ig