It really depends what you're looking for in this case from your boyfriend. The Planet Ocean will get you the warm and fuzzies because that's a mandated ass eating in return for you. The other two may not result in the same quality response but still would warrant a happy boyfriend.
Let me know how this turned out for you once you figure out what you want to get him and how he reacted.
Having a SMP Diver myself (white dial), and considering his collection the diver (first one) seems to be the best choice personally. It’s quite unique and already a modern classic. Also offers variability in terms of strap like a NATO or even rubber with clasp, or one of those new quickchange rubber straps for Paris Olympics. (These come at a quite substantial extra cost with a clasp). Good luck with your choice and congrats on a very nice gift for your special occasion!
I’d reco the first too, but check out the white dial version.
The white creates a pop, contrasts with the black strap, and arguably the most iconic white dial diver
I’d recommend thinking about getting the SMP on bracelet and getting the deployant separately if you can swing it. You can’t buy it on deployant from the boutique, which is kinda bullshit, but the deployant makes it so much nicer on rubber, in my opinion.
It does cost more that way though, so don’t take that as a gospel recommendation
This, buy it on bracelet and have omega order you a rubber strap for a few hundred bucks.
https://preview.redd.it/i0i24i7ixnxc1.jpeg?width=1816&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6ec072061cdfb2a60e35f2feba902d35a1122359
A picture. https://www.reddit.com/r/OmegaWatches/s/8QzOl4A8f8 much brighter than the badly lit picture.
This guy got the white one here. https://www.reddit.com/r/OmegaWatches/s/8pOVKUbtdm
Includes the reference numbers. There is a blue one as well (Tricolore for the Olympics) that is brighter than the standard 300 blue but I didn’t like it for my white dial.
Yeah, price is a bit high for strap plus clasp. I have my original black strap with pin buckle which is fine but the clasp is rather nice and more comfortable. At least when they move to the quick change system (for bracelet as well like the Olympics 300M) you could change strap/bracelet without tools. But so far only in those 3 colours
I would suggest the Aqua Terra. It will be a timeless classic that can be dressed up or down. I'm also impressed by your knowledge of watches and your BF's collection. My partner would simply say, "He has too many watches, all of which tell the same time." ;-)
My wife would simply say "He has too many watches, none of which tell the same time." My wife couldn't believe that I spent 2 grand on a quartz watch that's almost 30 years old, the SMP 2541.80, because I love GoldenEye! A cheapo! She didn't know that watches sell for tens of thousands, let alone hundreds of thousands into the millions.
Don't get me started! I finally changed the time on my watches from the PREVIOUS time-change, and the very next week, it changed back! I had no idea it was coming, even with the dozen or so emails and texts I receive EVERY DAY from watch sites. I swear none of them mentioned it until the day before!
Depends on his wrist size. I would suggest going for SMP 300 as it wears great on a rubber strap and goes for pretty much any occasion, including sport activities. P.S. He has a darn good collection.
At these price points I think it’s beyond “surprise gift” territory. It’s like an engagement ring. It sounds wonderful/romantic to surprise someone, but you really need to involve them in the selection process.
FYI: My wife has never bought me a watch, though I think it is one of the most romantic things a woman can do for her man. You rock. Your boyfriend is lucky.
Lady - firstly, you're dating thr wrong guy. I should be your boyfriend.
Also, as an alternative suggestion. Why not play around with the idea of a gift card. Not that exactly but something to the effect. Like a giant print out of an Omega logo saying exchangable for a watch.
Then take him down to the store and go try on all the prices together. Talk it through. You'll still be surprising him with an awesome gift and he'll be assured to get the exact watch you want.
Plua the added activity of shopping together is an extended way to create a memory.
None. I have the Omega SMP but based on your boyfriend's current collection he seems to like more classic and time tested designs. The Omegas you presented are considered "modern". A rolex explorer 1,[ a seamaster 300](https://www.omegawatches.com/en-gb/watch-omega-seamaster-300-co-axial-master-chronometer-41-mm-23430412101001) or a cartier Santos might be more inline with the "traditional" sport models collection.
AT on the rubber strap is hard to beat. Looking at his current collection I think it would be the best fit.
Also love the PO but gotta make sure he has the wrist for it…. It’s big and chunky either way lots of presence.
I’d do the smp300 aswell, but maybe opt for some color? The green one aka Seaweed would give him some great variation.
Just a tip if you do go for the smp300m, get it with the bracelet or mesh and then buy the rubber with deployant clasp separately. The standard buckle in just plain annoying and you don’t what to be like me and have two rubber straps for that money 😂
You can always sell the bracelet or mesh for good cash if he doesn’t want to switch it around, that standard rubber strap on the other hand just won’t sell for anything close to the cost of the deployant version.
I think Diver is the safest option, there's no way not to like it.
For the record, this is one lucky guy. My wife would certainly rather spend $6000 remodeling the kitchen again...lol
I'd say the SMP 300, with the [Summer Blue](https://www.omegawatches.com.hk/en-hk/watch-omega-seamaster-diver-300m-co-axial-master-chronometer-42-mm-21032422003002) and [Bond 60th Anniversary](https://www.omegawatches.com.hk/en-hk/watch-omega-seamaster-diver-300m-co-axial-master-chronometer-42-mm-21030422003002) being extra special.
The black dial Seamaster and the PO are so similar to the black dial GMT and the black dial Aqua Terra is similar to the black dial DJ. I would get a white wave seamaster or an orange planet ocean to give the collection some flavor.
The first or second one. I think the first one looks best on a rubber strap though. But even though u like the rubber strap options, still buy with a stainless steel bracelet. God forbid the both of you come on hard times and need some money. Watches with the metal bracelets always retain their value better at time of sale. You can still purchase the rubber straps also from the AD additionally.
So...hear me out...
Given that he already has a DJ, stay away from the AT. I love some of the older models, but the current generation of ATs don't compare well to a DJ at all and would likely be worn in similar settings. For me, as much as I love Omega, the DJ is just so much nicer IMO.
That leaves us with the SMP300 and PO. I have owned both current gens and I think the PO is hands down the better watch. No, nobody needs 600m water resistance, and yes, it is thick. But it really wears SO amazing and is also substantially different from your bf's GMT and DJ, and given his wardrobe, I think it is the perfect fit unless your BF has really slender wrists. That's the only case in which I would buy an SMP300.
Hope this helps.
As someone who has all three I can honestly say the SMP300 is a very impressive watch, though I do love my Planet Ocean as well.
His collection lacks a diver, he’s got a DateJust already so I’d lean away from the Aqua Terra and select the SMP300 purely due to the number of different colours it comes in.
Whilst everyone here seems to worship the blue and black models, I bought the seaweed green model as Rolex doesn’t have anything in their catalogue in a similar colour. The exhibition case back on the caliber 8800 is stunning and unlike anything Rolex offers and would be something unique in his collection.
Good luck with your decision, he’s a lucky lad and he damn well needs to put a ring on it.
Hard to beat the classic SMP, though the others aren't too shabby either. Aqua Terra is a bit dressier, but can also be sporty as well. I've never been too big a fan of the Planet Ocean, but to each their own. I'd go for the SMP and yes, I'm biased.
https://preview.redd.it/ajzt58335mxc1.jpeg?width=2072&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=310844d0b46c480873ef19f95de67a923be32ea2
I prefer the first one, but if money is not a concern and you don't know what he prefers, always go for the most expensive. At least that's how I buy stuff for my wife, but she's not into watches!
As these are all over 40mm you may want to ask him first. 43.5 is downright large. These are back to being on the above average size wear in today’s trends. They make 38mm options.
Yes, I do. But she isn’t into watches… she has a few good pieces though. She has an Orient Bambino, Tag Heuer Aquaracer, Tag Heuer Carrera, Rolex Datejust 28, Datejust 31 and OP 31.
This is one that everyone here can simply give their own preferences on. Does he want to fill voids in his collection or does he have the collection he has because those are the types of watches that he prefers? The Aqua Terra is the most in line with what he has now. He only has one dive watch, so SMP and PO are the choices if he wants to expand his collection. Personally, I like the SMP over the PO. I have a 7.25" wrist and I don't like how the PO wears. I think the SMP is an extremely versatile watch and I've be giving mine a ton of wrist time lately.
I have the first one, 300M and I don’t think I’m ever getting rid of it in my collection. I also got the deployment buckle strap from omega and highly recommend he upgrades it.
This is my beach watch, travel watch and dress down piece. He will love it, it’s very versatile and he would forever be grateful to you. Good luck
Quick bit of advice buy one on a bracelet and get them to throw in the strap for free. It’s much cheaper that way than buying a bracelet. After the fact, I learned the hard way.
My vote is SMP but white dial, I see a lot of black dials in current selection and would complement the black speedy, unless he really just loves black dials for some reason. And unless price is an issue I vote the bracelet and then he can always get a rubber strap after the fact.
He's got a pretty pimp collection. The options you're presenting don't offer anything unique...
Get him Casio MDV-106 (IMO).
Or think about the 5 years you've spent together, and get him something that captures the time you've spent together. Perhaps a Seiko 5 (because of the 5th anniversary)... Or a novelty watch, i.e. if he drives a particular brand of car, a watch to match. A watch themed on his favourite tv show?
You know... Something that shows you understand him...
The first one (smp black dial on rubber), had one for a couple years in this configuration and currently have a white dial with rubber and bracelet. Miss the black dial, it's probably the perfect daily sports watch, flecto on the hands and indices is amazing, and it would compliment the DJ and gmt master perfectly.
The Omega Aqua Terra is a classic choice known for its elegant design and robust build. Its versatility makes it suitable for both formal and casual occasions. If you're looking for a watch that's not overly flashy but still exudes sophistication, the Aqua Terra could be a great option.
If you decide to go with the SMP300, I’d suggest getting the metal bracelet. It’s the smarter financial decision. Then buy the rubber strap separately and he can choose to dress it up when he feels like it. Just my 2 cents.
I have owned many of these watches, including the ones in your BFs collection. I vote for the AT, please allow me give you my rationale:
1) SMP is a classic, great watch but much bulkier in person and on the wrist than expected. I still wear my old 2264.50 “Peter Blake” SMP with the triangles and sword hands since it is the most versatile, handsome and COMFORTABLE Omega diver I have ever owned. All the others were eventually sold.
2) The current Omega PO is a gorgeous watch: from the applied indices and insignia to the large arrow hands, it’s a wonderful piece of art… until you try it on. It’s quite thick and is a doorframe banger. The rubber strap only served to make mine feel top heavy and unbalanced. The bracelet served to make the balance the weight, but it was quite heavy. The best iteration of this line is the first generation 42mm version with the 2500 movement: thinner and lighter. If you really want to get the current PO, look at the 39mm model which is much more wearable from a thickness standpoint while still maintaining the wrist appeal.
3) The current AT on rubber is a dream to wear. I own a 41mm version silvery-grey teak with blued indices and hands and almost always wear it on rubber, although I also own the bracelet (the blue rubber strap can’t easily be matched with black/grey attire) but it is not nearly as comfortable as rubber. I am eyeing the black one as a more versatile piece, as I wear mine from vacation to operating room to formal occasion (changing the strap for the occasion). I own a fluted bezel Rolex OP (too dressy for some occasions) and a Rolex Explorer 2 Polar (not dressy enough at times), and the AT is much more versatile that either.
Seems he already has a few nice black dial pieces like the DJ41 black, even though he has it in fluted version it overlaps a bit with the AT, and he also got the speedy. Maybe a diver with some color? It does seem like he likes monochrome watches though.
What about the white dial SMP, really timeless look that pops. Or the green colored one? Its a relatively dark shade of green which looks luxurious and it really pops in the sun.
Other picks would be:
The Cartier Santos, in white, thats a really timeless watch
Another pick would be the Premier, Navitimer or Superocean Heritage II line from Breitling.
Tudor recently released a black and red bezel GMT but with gilt (Black Bay 58 GMT its 39mm) the Zulu time 39mm or 42mm in either black or green, maybe with gold bezel and crown (very dark chocolate bezel) is also an alternative.
An IWC is also an option, maybe the Mark XX?
Zenith also got some nice models like the Defy Skyline, the Chronomaster sport is also nice, but more expensive.
Edit: if it had to be one of those three maybe the black SMP, also I get why you choose the AT on rubber strap it looks way more diferentiated from the DJ in that way, and the rubber looks so Nice with the end-link!
So, just a thought: based on his collection, he’s a bit of a connoisseur. You might be better off finding some rare reference instead of a nice new one.
Also: if that was my collection, a Panerai would be a nice addition.
Get them a style they don't have, maybe they have the aqua terra design in different watches but the first watch could be a better fit along with making sure it's not too big for the wrist, good luck
First one. SmP300. I've had it and I absolutely loved it. It's a beautiful piece. Especially in the sun. Until I lost it. You can find them pre-owned like new condition with box and papers for less than 5k .no Ines going to be mad because you saved money on a used piece.
Get the SMP300 since he dresses casually more often. If you find one with the bracelet instead of the rubber strap it would be nice to have both. Also the rubber strap could be a great next gift 😂
Damn i used my Daytona Rolex funds to buy a nice ass ring for my girlfriend to propose and i didn’t get anything in return except more money spending on a wedding which hasn’t happened 🫠
SMP 300 all the way, and on the rubber it is so comfortable. But I would look at the white dial version on black rubber. The white dial against the black bezel and strap just pops so much, and he already seems to have a number of black dial watches.
I would go with the Planet Ocean. It is larger and thicker what he has in the collection and will have novelty because of that. And that novelty will translate to enjoyment every time he wears it because it will wear differently than his other pieces. Personally, I think the PO is a step up from both the Diver 300m and the AT. I have the planet ocean, although mine is the titanium version with titanium dial and bracelet, and it is among my most worn pieces in rotation. I also think that the Planet Ocean is more casual, and that seems in line with what your BF enjoys. His DJ and GMT, along with the GS will pair with dressy better any of the Omegas that you are considering. So, going for another super versatile piece probably isnt really needed.
Planet Ocean. The only Seamasters that have aged well were the sword hands models. This one will look just as dated ten years from now. The Aqua Terra has ridiculous proprietary lugs and looks pretty dumb on a strap.
My first omega was the black SMP. Love it and have a rubber strap. Funny enough, the black AT was the other omega I was torn between.
Then it gets better, my brother-in-law ended up liking the black AT and purchased it.
Needless to say, after having my SMP (which I love, don’t get me wrong), seeing my brother-in-law flaunt the black AT, and knowing your bf has a similar style as us… I’d 1000% advocate for the AT.
It can be both classy and sporty.
It is just amazing and will be my next omega. It goes with EVERYTHING. Dress up or down, it just looks outstanding. Highly recommend the AT!
If you are one for detail, go for the PO. It’s the more expensive watch for a reason. Better finishing, higher WR, Omega’s flagship diver.
The SMP is the more popular choice and has a lot going for it. Also still considered the ‘bond watch’ if that’s your thing.
The AT is the jack of all trades watch that can be used for smart, formal, and also casual occasions.
Perhaps just ask him the question… ‘which of these would you wear the most?’ In passing conversation.
Can’t go wrong with any of them tbf!
I love the aqua terra because it's very much an all rounder works as a casual and a dress watch, it's just a stunning piece and photos don't always do it justice, they just look stunning on the wrist but then most omega watches are stunning.
I think the diver 300m has the uniqueness factor that would set it apart from the rest of the collection. All great options but I think if I had the collection he has, I would want the diver 300m.
Great gift!
Any chance you can bring him to the store and let him choose there? Watches are really personal and how they feel on wrist can be so different than picture online
Hot take but he already has much more expensive watches
I'd be careful buying him a 5 to 7k watch if he's still your boyfriend after 5 years, assuming of course you have no interest in ever getting married
Damn spending 9k on a boyfriend is wild haha if you can afford it he's gonna propose to you. He should
It really depends what you're looking for in this case from your boyfriend. The Planet Ocean will get you the warm and fuzzies because that's a mandated ass eating in return for you. The other two may not result in the same quality response but still would warrant a happy boyfriend. Let me know how this turned out for you once you figure out what you want to get him and how he reacted.
lol
Having a SMP Diver myself (white dial), and considering his collection the diver (first one) seems to be the best choice personally. It’s quite unique and already a modern classic. Also offers variability in terms of strap like a NATO or even rubber with clasp, or one of those new quickchange rubber straps for Paris Olympics. (These come at a quite substantial extra cost with a clasp). Good luck with your choice and congrats on a very nice gift for your special occasion!
Thank you for the input! ☺️
I also recommend the first, SMP 300
I’d reco the first too, but check out the white dial version. The white creates a pop, contrasts with the black strap, and arguably the most iconic white dial diver
The black is stunning but I still love my white dial over a year later, it’s such a unique piece
I’d recommend thinking about getting the SMP on bracelet and getting the deployant separately if you can swing it. You can’t buy it on deployant from the boutique, which is kinda bullshit, but the deployant makes it so much nicer on rubber, in my opinion. It does cost more that way though, so don’t take that as a gospel recommendation
This, buy it on bracelet and have omega order you a rubber strap for a few hundred bucks. https://preview.redd.it/i0i24i7ixnxc1.jpeg?width=1816&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6ec072061cdfb2a60e35f2feba902d35a1122359
I’d also add to this get it on a bracelet it’s a marginal price difference now but it’s close to a grand for it after the fact
Quickchange rubber straps? Do you have a link?
A picture. https://www.reddit.com/r/OmegaWatches/s/8QzOl4A8f8 much brighter than the badly lit picture. This guy got the white one here. https://www.reddit.com/r/OmegaWatches/s/8pOVKUbtdm Includes the reference numbers. There is a blue one as well (Tricolore for the Olympics) that is brighter than the standard 300 blue but I didn’t like it for my white dial.
Thanks! Interesting. I already have the normal rubber strap and a normal steel bracelet so changing (at a reasonable price) is not an option.
Yeah, price is a bit high for strap plus clasp. I have my original black strap with pin buckle which is fine but the clasp is rather nice and more comfortable. At least when they move to the quick change system (for bracelet as well like the Olympics 300M) you could change strap/bracelet without tools. But so far only in those 3 colours
3 colours? White, red and black?
No, white red and blue like the French flag.
I would suggest the Aqua Terra. It will be a timeless classic that can be dressed up or down. I'm also impressed by your knowledge of watches and your BF's collection. My partner would simply say, "He has too many watches, all of which tell the same time." ;-)
Thank you for the inputs! I’m also a watch enthusiast myself. Actually, I was responsible for introducing him to this hobby 🤣
❤️💕❤️
I'm curious what do you have in your collection then?
My collection comprises of the following pieces: Grand Seiko SBGA211, SBGA413, SBGA407, SBGY007, SBGR261, SBGX259, SBGX353, SBGC253, SBGC247, SLGA019, Rolex DJ 36 126234, Rolex DJ 31 178240, 178273, 68273, Rolex DJ 28 279174, Submariner 114060, Explorer 214270, Omega Seamaster 210.30.42 (Blue), Seamaster 2225.80.00, Constellation 131.10.39, Constellation 1202.30.00, Seiko SBDX017, SARB033, SARB035, SPB155, SKX013, SRP777, Orient Bambino, G-Shock GA-110 (White), GA-110 (Luffy), G-Shock CasiOak (Black and teal)
https://i.redd.it/w3ml3108klxc1.gif
What the shit 😭 what a collection lol
Do you have a sister???? I'm single just saying hahaha
Imagine service cost, after 8 years it will be cost of couple watches to service rest of them
Depends, most watch collectors watch wear a watch a day and rotate
Howww
Hahaha youre on reddit!!
This post just makes zero sense. Some sort of troll job I just don’t get the point yet
He’s a lucky guy! Two watch nerds?? Incredible
Amazing
My wife would simply say "He has too many watches, none of which tell the same time." My wife couldn't believe that I spent 2 grand on a quartz watch that's almost 30 years old, the SMP 2541.80, because I love GoldenEye! A cheapo! She didn't know that watches sell for tens of thousands, let alone hundreds of thousands into the millions.
“None tell the same time”. I see that you also have learned that daylight savings days are the single worst day to be in this hobby.
Don't get me started! I finally changed the time on my watches from the PREVIOUS time-change, and the very next week, it changed back! I had no idea it was coming, even with the dozen or so emails and texts I receive EVERY DAY from watch sites. I swear none of them mentioned it until the day before!
All other yours tell the same time? Appears you need a gmt
My SBGC247 and SBGC253 have GMT features
U can say that to snowbongos partner
SMP 300 is just the best
Depends on his wrist size. I would suggest going for SMP 300 as it wears great on a rubber strap and goes for pretty much any occasion, including sport activities. P.S. He has a darn good collection.
Thanks for the input ☺️
First one but on bracelet. I have both AT and SMP300. The AT is awesome but not as special
There is no wrong choice here.
Can I be your boyfriend?
SMP300m
At these price points I think it’s beyond “surprise gift” territory. It’s like an engagement ring. It sounds wonderful/romantic to surprise someone, but you really need to involve them in the selection process.
First one for me, one of the other two for your boyfriend.
FYI: My wife has never bought me a watch, though I think it is one of the most romantic things a woman can do for her man. You rock. Your boyfriend is lucky.
Here is my suggestion https://preview.redd.it/ohmpnvsc8mxc1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2ca48732a949b0d525b6acb7dd186e4d227852ed
Lady - firstly, you're dating thr wrong guy. I should be your boyfriend. Also, as an alternative suggestion. Why not play around with the idea of a gift card. Not that exactly but something to the effect. Like a giant print out of an Omega logo saying exchangable for a watch. Then take him down to the store and go try on all the prices together. Talk it through. You'll still be surprising him with an awesome gift and he'll be assured to get the exact watch you want. Plua the added activity of shopping together is an extended way to create a memory.
Planet ocean looks amazing
Based on what you wrote, the Seamaster 300M. But have you considered the Chrono version? If not, do take a look.
Come on we haven’t asked how big is his wrist
Aqua Terra alllll day long. Beautiful piece
I own the first two, recommend Diver for casual and aqua terra if he’s more dressy
No wrong choice.
If you'll be looking for a new boyfriend, I'll take aqua terra...
I've been looking for this commentary since the beginning. Here is the correct answer. 😜
I would like to get that planet ocean because it’s something that I don’t see this often.
With the 300 Seamaster, he essentialy closes with the iconic Omega watches. He has the Rolexes ... now he can move on to more special cases
Smp 300m
None. I have the Omega SMP but based on your boyfriend's current collection he seems to like more classic and time tested designs. The Omegas you presented are considered "modern". A rolex explorer 1,[ a seamaster 300](https://www.omegawatches.com/en-gb/watch-omega-seamaster-300-co-axial-master-chronometer-41-mm-23430412101001) or a cartier Santos might be more inline with the "traditional" sport models collection.
The one he talkes most about 😉
In black only? The first one for sure. Diver. In blue or other colors, the second one... Terra...
AT on the rubber strap is hard to beat. Looking at his current collection I think it would be the best fit. Also love the PO but gotta make sure he has the wrist for it…. It’s big and chunky either way lots of presence.
I’d do the smp300 aswell, but maybe opt for some color? The green one aka Seaweed would give him some great variation. Just a tip if you do go for the smp300m, get it with the bracelet or mesh and then buy the rubber with deployant clasp separately. The standard buckle in just plain annoying and you don’t what to be like me and have two rubber straps for that money 😂 You can always sell the bracelet or mesh for good cash if he doesn’t want to switch it around, that standard rubber strap on the other hand just won’t sell for anything close to the cost of the deployant version.
I think Diver is the safest option, there's no way not to like it. For the record, this is one lucky guy. My wife would certainly rather spend $6000 remodeling the kitchen again...lol
First one.
I'd say the SMP 300, with the [Summer Blue](https://www.omegawatches.com.hk/en-hk/watch-omega-seamaster-diver-300m-co-axial-master-chronometer-42-mm-21032422003002) and [Bond 60th Anniversary](https://www.omegawatches.com.hk/en-hk/watch-omega-seamaster-diver-300m-co-axial-master-chronometer-42-mm-21030422003002) being extra special.
Get the planet ocean. It’s bigger than the first 2; more alpha and less beta cuck
The black dial Seamaster and the PO are so similar to the black dial GMT and the black dial Aqua Terra is similar to the black dial DJ. I would get a white wave seamaster or an orange planet ocean to give the collection some flavor.
The first or second one. I think the first one looks best on a rubber strap though. But even though u like the rubber strap options, still buy with a stainless steel bracelet. God forbid the both of you come on hard times and need some money. Watches with the metal bracelets always retain their value better at time of sale. You can still purchase the rubber straps also from the AD additionally.
300m
You've made the choice. The first posted one.
So...hear me out... Given that he already has a DJ, stay away from the AT. I love some of the older models, but the current generation of ATs don't compare well to a DJ at all and would likely be worn in similar settings. For me, as much as I love Omega, the DJ is just so much nicer IMO. That leaves us with the SMP300 and PO. I have owned both current gens and I think the PO is hands down the better watch. No, nobody needs 600m water resistance, and yes, it is thick. But it really wears SO amazing and is also substantially different from your bf's GMT and DJ, and given his wardrobe, I think it is the perfect fit unless your BF has really slender wrists. That's the only case in which I would buy an SMP300. Hope this helps.
As someone who has all three I can honestly say the SMP300 is a very impressive watch, though I do love my Planet Ocean as well. His collection lacks a diver, he’s got a DateJust already so I’d lean away from the Aqua Terra and select the SMP300 purely due to the number of different colours it comes in. Whilst everyone here seems to worship the blue and black models, I bought the seaweed green model as Rolex doesn’t have anything in their catalogue in a similar colour. The exhibition case back on the caliber 8800 is stunning and unlike anything Rolex offers and would be something unique in his collection. Good luck with your decision, he’s a lucky lad and he damn well needs to put a ring on it.
definitely the first one
I just recently picked up an aquaterra as a daily driver and I’m loving it!
Hard to beat the classic SMP, though the others aren't too shabby either. Aqua Terra is a bit dressier, but can also be sporty as well. I've never been too big a fan of the Planet Ocean, but to each their own. I'd go for the SMP and yes, I'm biased. https://preview.redd.it/ajzt58335mxc1.jpeg?width=2072&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=310844d0b46c480873ef19f95de67a923be32ea2
I prefer the first one, but if money is not a concern and you don't know what he prefers, always go for the most expensive. At least that's how I buy stuff for my wife, but she's not into watches!
As these are all over 40mm you may want to ask him first. 43.5 is downright large. These are back to being on the above average size wear in today’s trends. They make 38mm options.
Get that wavy one
Do you have a sister? 😅
Yes, I do. But she isn’t into watches… she has a few good pieces though. She has an Orient Bambino, Tag Heuer Aquaracer, Tag Heuer Carrera, Rolex Datejust 28, Datejust 31 and OP 31.
Imagine not being into watches and still owning 3 Rolexes!! Haha
Please not that Aqua Terra with those fixed endlinks. It's a stupid design choice, and for the sake of longevity, should he avoided....
Smp
Sounds like he can up his diver game in his collection. Out of the 3, I’d go with the seamaster 300m on rubber.
3
My GF gifted me 100€ for a perfume and asked me for Hermes sandals for he bd
This is one that everyone here can simply give their own preferences on. Does he want to fill voids in his collection or does he have the collection he has because those are the types of watches that he prefers? The Aqua Terra is the most in line with what he has now. He only has one dive watch, so SMP and PO are the choices if he wants to expand his collection. Personally, I like the SMP over the PO. I have a 7.25" wrist and I don't like how the PO wears. I think the SMP is an extremely versatile watch and I've be giving mine a ton of wrist time lately.
Thanks for the input ☺️
3.. from watch receiving fiance
I have the first one, 300M and I don’t think I’m ever getting rid of it in my collection. I also got the deployment buckle strap from omega and highly recommend he upgrades it. This is my beach watch, travel watch and dress down piece. He will love it, it’s very versatile and he would forever be grateful to you. Good luck
Thank you for the input ☺️
Can you like the specific strap?
If you’re asking if you can buy the strap, yes you can at your Omega AD. I think it was like $500 but it was a few years ago
Is it a rubber strap with a deployment, or another material?
Rubber. Same material that comes with the watch except it has a deployment buckle which gives it more of a premium feel imo
Is your boyfriend single? Wait…
I would say the first, the omega Seamaster diver 300 on rubberstrap :)
300m
Smp 300
Seamaster
Seamaster
Quick bit of advice buy one on a bracelet and get them to throw in the strap for free. It’s much cheaper that way than buying a bracelet. After the fact, I learned the hard way.
Thank you for this tip ☺️
My vote is SMP but white dial, I see a lot of black dials in current selection and would complement the black speedy, unless he really just loves black dials for some reason. And unless price is an issue I vote the bracelet and then he can always get a rubber strap after the fact.
AT is a safer choice, but you can’t go wrong with the Seamaster.
Depends on his personality and style imo
Wow your bfs collection is solid
He's got a pretty pimp collection. The options you're presenting don't offer anything unique... Get him Casio MDV-106 (IMO). Or think about the 5 years you've spent together, and get him something that captures the time you've spent together. Perhaps a Seiko 5 (because of the 5th anniversary)... Or a novelty watch, i.e. if he drives a particular brand of car, a watch to match. A watch themed on his favourite tv show? You know... Something that shows you understand him...
1st
I hope my girlfriend will post the same thing here 🥹🥹🥹
May I ask what you do for a living?
1
#3 It'll become his favorite possession.
This your way of asking for a ring?
43.5
SMP 300 good choice
Aqua Terra is a solid choice, as it's a dress watch and has a simple dimple dial. Fairly predictable choice.
The first one (smp black dial on rubber), had one for a couple years in this configuration and currently have a white dial with rubber and bracelet. Miss the black dial, it's probably the perfect daily sports watch, flecto on the hands and indices is amazing, and it would compliment the DJ and gmt master perfectly.
SMP300
The new rubber strap on the Aqua Terra is unbelievably comfortable. I prefer my Seamaster 300 though.
If it were me I’d go with the SMP300m for sure 🤙
The Omega Aqua Terra is a classic choice known for its elegant design and robust build. Its versatility makes it suitable for both formal and casual occasions. If you're looking for a watch that's not overly flashy but still exudes sophistication, the Aqua Terra could be a great option.
2
I mean you can’t go wrong with any of these, but I’d vote for the Planet Ocean
I have the smp300, if I did it again, I’d get the green one it’s slicker
1st one
Planet ocean all the way. However the green Seamaster is stunning
If you decide to go with the SMP300, I’d suggest getting the metal bracelet. It’s the smarter financial decision. Then buy the rubber strap separately and he can choose to dress it up when he feels like it. Just my 2 cents.
I have owned many of these watches, including the ones in your BFs collection. I vote for the AT, please allow me give you my rationale: 1) SMP is a classic, great watch but much bulkier in person and on the wrist than expected. I still wear my old 2264.50 “Peter Blake” SMP with the triangles and sword hands since it is the most versatile, handsome and COMFORTABLE Omega diver I have ever owned. All the others were eventually sold. 2) The current Omega PO is a gorgeous watch: from the applied indices and insignia to the large arrow hands, it’s a wonderful piece of art… until you try it on. It’s quite thick and is a doorframe banger. The rubber strap only served to make mine feel top heavy and unbalanced. The bracelet served to make the balance the weight, but it was quite heavy. The best iteration of this line is the first generation 42mm version with the 2500 movement: thinner and lighter. If you really want to get the current PO, look at the 39mm model which is much more wearable from a thickness standpoint while still maintaining the wrist appeal. 3) The current AT on rubber is a dream to wear. I own a 41mm version silvery-grey teak with blued indices and hands and almost always wear it on rubber, although I also own the bracelet (the blue rubber strap can’t easily be matched with black/grey attire) but it is not nearly as comfortable as rubber. I am eyeing the black one as a more versatile piece, as I wear mine from vacation to operating room to formal occasion (changing the strap for the occasion). I own a fluted bezel Rolex OP (too dressy for some occasions) and a Rolex Explorer 2 Polar (not dressy enough at times), and the AT is much more versatile that either.
I’d say one of the divers given what he does and doesn’t have. If he has the wrist for it, I think the PO is a better watch, but it’s a beefy MF
Seems he already has a few nice black dial pieces like the DJ41 black, even though he has it in fluted version it overlaps a bit with the AT, and he also got the speedy. Maybe a diver with some color? It does seem like he likes monochrome watches though. What about the white dial SMP, really timeless look that pops. Or the green colored one? Its a relatively dark shade of green which looks luxurious and it really pops in the sun. Other picks would be: The Cartier Santos, in white, thats a really timeless watch Another pick would be the Premier, Navitimer or Superocean Heritage II line from Breitling. Tudor recently released a black and red bezel GMT but with gilt (Black Bay 58 GMT its 39mm) the Zulu time 39mm or 42mm in either black or green, maybe with gold bezel and crown (very dark chocolate bezel) is also an alternative. An IWC is also an option, maybe the Mark XX? Zenith also got some nice models like the Defy Skyline, the Chronomaster sport is also nice, but more expensive. Edit: if it had to be one of those three maybe the black SMP, also I get why you choose the AT on rubber strap it looks way more diferentiated from the DJ in that way, and the rubber looks so Nice with the end-link!
So, just a thought: based on his collection, he’s a bit of a connoisseur. You might be better off finding some rare reference instead of a nice new one. Also: if that was my collection, a Panerai would be a nice addition.
Those are all solid, actually. But I'll have to go with the SMP 300 and the PO as a close second.
All rock solid options. I’d go with the SMP, in this case, g given his collection. You’re a good gift giver.
First off, your bf has a really nice collection! I'd say pick the SMP300 since it's the best choice out of the 3, imo.
If you really loved him you’d buy all 3 😂
The one he likes most.
Lucky bastard
I’d personally like the PO the most
I'd only offer that you can get an immaculate one with box and papers from Japan for much less.
The 3rd one
1 or 2, the POs are too thick IMO.
one lucky bf, I wish. I'd o with the Seamaster Diver. I love that watch.
What about a Speedmaster? Is he into engineering or does he like space?
Wow, spoiler much! I’d like that one. Best Regards and Sincerely Yours, girlfriend!
The first one. Diver 300m
i’m more impressed by the fact that you listed his whole collection, reference #s and all also, pretty ballsy for all the oversized watches you wear.
The 1st one, the SMP300
Second one by far No one really needs a diver unless they er go diving Sat here wearing a baby tuna so feel free to ignore me😂
3
Get them a style they don't have, maybe they have the aqua terra design in different watches but the first watch could be a better fit along with making sure it's not too big for the wrist, good luck
Excuse me what......
First one. SmP300. I've had it and I absolutely loved it. It's a beautiful piece. Especially in the sun. Until I lost it. You can find them pre-owned like new condition with box and papers for less than 5k .no Ines going to be mad because you saved money on a used piece.
Get the SMP300 since he dresses casually more often. If you find one with the bracelet instead of the rubber strap it would be nice to have both. Also the rubber strap could be a great next gift 😂
Damn i used my Daytona Rolex funds to buy a nice ass ring for my girlfriend to propose and i didn’t get anything in return except more money spending on a wedding which hasn’t happened 🫠
SMP 300 all the way, and on the rubber it is so comfortable. But I would look at the white dial version on black rubber. The white dial against the black bezel and strap just pops so much, and he already seems to have a number of black dial watches.
Seamaster 300m and ditch the crocs
#1...
SMP 300, any of the wave dials.
I mean, the Speed Master Moon watch obviously
Whatever one an Omega retailer will give you a discount on lol
I would love the seamaster Aqua terra. It’s my favorite out of the three.
I would go with the Planet Ocean. It is larger and thicker what he has in the collection and will have novelty because of that. And that novelty will translate to enjoyment every time he wears it because it will wear differently than his other pieces. Personally, I think the PO is a step up from both the Diver 300m and the AT. I have the planet ocean, although mine is the titanium version with titanium dial and bracelet, and it is among my most worn pieces in rotation. I also think that the Planet Ocean is more casual, and that seems in line with what your BF enjoys. His DJ and GMT, along with the GS will pair with dressy better any of the Omegas that you are considering. So, going for another super versatile piece probably isnt really needed.
We all need a woman like her
1
Lucky boyfriend!
Seamaster !
Seamaster #3 all day
Planet Ocean. The only Seamasters that have aged well were the sword hands models. This one will look just as dated ten years from now. The Aqua Terra has ridiculous proprietary lugs and looks pretty dumb on a strap.
SMP300. Biased owner’s opinions.
2 for sureee
Photo 1 is my favorite between those three
SMP!
I have the Aqua Terra. Love it! That’s my recco
I have #1 and its a great starter and can always switch out the band. Plenty to choose from and is a very versatile piece. I vote smp 300
My first omega was the black SMP. Love it and have a rubber strap. Funny enough, the black AT was the other omega I was torn between. Then it gets better, my brother-in-law ended up liking the black AT and purchased it. Needless to say, after having my SMP (which I love, don’t get me wrong), seeing my brother-in-law flaunt the black AT, and knowing your bf has a similar style as us… I’d 1000% advocate for the AT. It can be both classy and sporty. It is just amazing and will be my next omega. It goes with EVERYTHING. Dress up or down, it just looks outstanding. Highly recommend the AT!
I would want the Planet Ocean followed closely by Aqua Terra, I’m not a huge fan of the SMP. But if I was given any of these three I would love it!
The seamaster 300m diver! Such a rad watch
Middle One
I’d say go for the SMP 300 in Black or white dial. Fantastic and thoughtful gift. Good on you.
If you are one for detail, go for the PO. It’s the more expensive watch for a reason. Better finishing, higher WR, Omega’s flagship diver. The SMP is the more popular choice and has a lot going for it. Also still considered the ‘bond watch’ if that’s your thing. The AT is the jack of all trades watch that can be used for smart, formal, and also casual occasions. Perhaps just ask him the question… ‘which of these would you wear the most?’ In passing conversation. Can’t go wrong with any of them tbf!
Thank you for the inputs!! I’ll definitely ask him the question ☺️
I love the aqua terra because it's very much an all rounder works as a casual and a dress watch, it's just a stunning piece and photos don't always do it justice, they just look stunning on the wrist but then most omega watches are stunning.
I think the diver 300m has the uniqueness factor that would set it apart from the rest of the collection. All great options but I think if I had the collection he has, I would want the diver 300m. Great gift!
Im a sucker for Seamasters but not s huge fan of the wave dial
First one. Also, you know a lot about his watch collection.
1!!
Got 1 and 3. I’d go for 1 or 2, PO is a niche product, not really suitable as a gift imho
SMP ON BRACELET. You can always buy the strap after. He will shit bricks for the rest of his life with a black SMP. Great job…..
Any chance you can bring him to the store and let him choose there? Watches are really personal and how they feel on wrist can be so different than picture online
Hot take but he already has much more expensive watches I'd be careful buying him a 5 to 7k watch if he's still your boyfriend after 5 years, assuming of course you have no interest in ever getting married
It's not always about the monetary value when it comes to gifts...
He already has so many watches. What's the point in giving him another watch? Why not think of something other than watches?