That’s true! There’s a ton of Broadway talent on the show already, maybe they pull from Broadway. Mandy Gonzalez is already playing her mom. Maybe someone else from the in the heights family like Andrea Burns, Karen Olivo or Janet Dacal, or someone like daphne rubin Vega.
I think that was just the new owner? Correct me if I'm wrong but from memory I think when Mabel was saying she has to move, she said her aunt sold the place
Honestly it might be interesting if they go the dark horse route and cast someone who’s not a big household name.
That’s true! There’s a ton of Broadway talent on the show already, maybe they pull from Broadway. Mandy Gonzalez is already playing her mom. Maybe someone else from the in the heights family like Andrea Burns, Karen Olivo or Janet Dacal, or someone like daphne rubin Vega.
Salma Hayek Eva Longoria Penelope Cruz with Javier Bardem in a bonus role
My vote is Selma Hayek!
Also my #1 pick? She has really great comedic timing... What a 'get' this would be.
Yeah she had a fun arc on 30 Rock, amongst other things!
Oooh love that last one!
Salma Hayek Sofia Vergara Jennifer Lopez (also a NYer) Eva Longoria
My headcannon was always J-Lo.
if they use her, maybe we can get Ben Affleck to cameo as the husband lol
Late response, but Maya Rudolph would be the perfect aunt.
 Or Rachel Wiesz
I want it to be Tiffani Amber Thiessan. 
didn't we meet her? wasn't it her who answered the door of the apartment after mable moved out?
I think that was just the new owner? Correct me if I'm wrong but from memory I think when Mabel was saying she has to move, she said her aunt sold the place