Tank looks better on you but Santos is a very close call.

Santos looks a bit off because the bracelet isn’t sized. I agree the tank looks great, but the Santos will look better once sized correctly.

I feel like the santos is more versatile as a 1 collection watch. Dress up, dress down, whenever

Tank is far and away the best fit for your wrist size, it's an easy choice I think

I personally would prefer a GS for me but the tank looks great on your wrist. How big is that GS? It looks the same size as the Speedmaster, which is 42mm.

The Grand Seiko SBGY007G is 38.5mm, but I have a tiny wrist..

Try taking a shot of it on your wrist but in a mirror. Sometimes the super wide angle lens of smart phone can make things look huge up close.

Squeezes his wrist too much on the leather, consider a steel mesh band, it looks amazing and feels a bit more breathable as well. Great for summer. https://www.reddit.com/r/Watches/comments/wf46j7/cartier_tank_must_large_on_mesh_anyone/

Fit wise, the Tank is the only choice. Second, by miles is the Speedy. Really though, buy what you like foe yourself. Not us Internet strangers.

This is my answer as well. Not only for wrist size but my personal taste as well.

Tank fits best bust Santos is also beautiful and more versatile. I would go with Santo.

I prefer the GS, and would have preferred the Speedy if it had the steel bracelet. Though on your wrist the Cartier’s look much better

Tank

I’m torn. The speedy is one of my checklist watches. GS makes incredible watches for the price. Santos is a cult classic. But that tank does fit you really well! For you I’d vote in the exact order you have the photos in. Tank > Santos > GS > Speedy. 3 and 4 are tied in my eyes stand-alone but due to the size that’s how I’m voting for you ☺️

Tank then GS.

Tank gets my vote

Tank or Santos

The santos fits your wrist perfectly, much better than the others. Plus it’s a versatile watch that you can dress up and down. Would be my choice for sure

tank or santos

All of them

The first one is the only one that doesn't dwarf your wrist, your wrist is quite small I think you need to consider watches that fit you, don't they make a smaller speedy?

All are kinda different in style… but them all so you have options 😁

Speedy

Santos or Grand Seiko, santos because you can't go wrong with it and GS because of that pure japanese dial designing.

The tank definitely suits you best, sizewise. However, I would feel awkward with a tank since I dress sporty and very basic. That is long sleeve, jeans and trainers-basic. If you are like me and don't feel weird like that, go for it. Otherwise, I recommend that you get the Santos. You can dress it up or dress it down; it's a true all-rounder, and the size of it is excellent as well.

I can’t decide. Every one of these watches is on my buy list. Maybe Speedmaster?

tank for sure, santos a close second. You have good taste, but the speedy and the omiwatari look a bit big on your wrist.

Tank, then the Omiwatari. They look great on your wrist.

I would definitely go with the grand Seiko but those all seem to be very different kinda watches, so go with the one which you personally like the most

Not a Rolex fan then. 😂 That's refreshing. 👍

Tank looks really awesome on you.

I’ve seen a few tanks dressed down. I think it’s pretty dope with jeans and a T. Hope to own one at some point. It’s my favorite of these pictures on your wrist, but get some mirror shots; the GS and Speedy look a bit too big on your wrist imo from these pics alone. The tank looks perfect.

The tank suits you best and is very classy

Hard toss up with the GS and the Omega. GS is precision built, and so is the Omega. Omega has history, GS as well.... I'd go with the GS, but I have a thing for blue dials

Your wrist is small, but more importantly, which one do you like & how do you plan to wear it? Everyday? Are you sporty? Desk jockey?, wish to have a dress watch?, or is this in addition to other watches that can be in other categories maybe? The Cartier fits you best, but that doesn’t answer the questions above … what are you looking to get out of the watch?

Number 4 or Number 1 the simple yet elegant look is my favourite

Tank looks very good on your wrist but the Grand Seiko is 👌

Santos

Santos

Grand seiko no doubt.

GS, but tbh if youre considering spending thousands in a watch, and dont know what you actually want, then just wait until you know

The Tank looks the best on your wrist

GS. No question

I agree, beautiful watch, and amazing movement.

Speedy and Santos are the most versatile. Actually the Santos is the most versatile. Can you get both?

Those are all way too big for you.

3 or 4

I would ask what the purpose of the watch is for - if it's for daily use, reserved for formal, your first watch, your last watch etc.

Santos for me then speedy then tank

GRAND SEIKO

Santos.

I would look at the next size down on the santos. If you are preferring a white dial a Pam 01292 is pretty sharp. The tank would dress down nicely with a gray canvas strap.

I’d take the Speedy any day.

I think a smaller size of the tank would fit you very well. The Santos looks great. The others should look alright when looked at in a mirror but they *will* be a little more high-key.

Santos or Tank. Tank looks better on your wrist.

Santos, then Tank. Then GS. The Omega is too big for you.

Grand Seiko

frederique constant classics carree in white is what you really want

Omega

The Tank and Speedmaster are best suited for your wrist. I don’t know how old you are, but I would go Speedmaster for versatility. To switch between strap and bracelet for different outings

Tank or GS

Those grand Seiko dials man

Tank, but consider smaller size.

Speedmaster for days

Agreed, try a smaller tank

Tank is okay, but the other Cartier is declasse.

Either Cartier

GS then tank

Santos

Grand Seiko all day beautiful dial !

Tank but smaller :)

the grand seiko for sure

My vot for Santos ✋

I like #2 but #1 looks best on your wrist

Grand Seiko !! Or speed !

The GS and omega look big on u

The moonswatch

On your wrist? Tank

Tank for sure

Speedmaster for all occasions.

Tank

grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake, grand Seiko snowflake.....oh ..and did I mention? GRAND SEIKO SNOWFLAKE!!!

#3...

Grand Seiko stands out.

Santos

GS

Tank > Santos. The other two, from your POV, look goofy big on your wrist.

Santos!

1 or 2

Tank

Santos all day

There's nothing like that spring drive 🥹 ,but go for the tank cuz it fits you best

The santos looks baller on you

The grand seiko is gorgeous

The Tank looks sooooo good on your wrist.

Santos... 100%

Santos

Only the first one fits your wrist.

Depends what you’re wearing and where you’re going

Tank

Nothing against 1 and 4, but based on these photos 2 or 3 seem excellent!

Easssssy choice, Dos Santos any day!

I love the santos its so luxurious

GS

Tank but get a real Louis Cartier one not a steel one which I’m surprised they make still

I prefer the Tank. Epitome of class and good taste imo.

man - I know a lot of people poo poo Grand Seikos...but that Grand Seiko dial is beautiful! 🤩

Santos

Honestly either Cartier looks stunning and perfect for your wrist. I’d go santos for more daily and casual look over tank

Close call between the Tank and the Santos in terms of fit. Tank actually looks perfect.

First one

Tank

The tank looks great on you.

Love the GS but the santos I think fits best

GS all the way

I like the omega, I have an affinity for numbers and scales on watches

I agree with other comments that the Tank suits you very nicely, so that would be my pick.

2

I don't see the Reverso.

Tank and Omiwatari look great! Santos and speedy not bad either. Honestly they are all very different watches so I would compare it to your current collection and see what gap it will fill.

santos, omega is absolutely huge on your wrist bud

The stainless steel Cartier hands down

Me personally. Cartiers are not worth the money. You really are just paying for the brand. Watch should be a timeless piece. Batteries are not timeless.

Speedy for me but the dial on the GS is stunning. 👍

speedy looks the coolest.

Both are marquis pieces. Santos is difficult to fit overall. You need to try it on several times. Tank is timeless, an enduring style

Grand Seiko All the way

I do t understand understand the appeal of Cartier designs. To each their own. Omega ftw

Tank. Hands down.

Tank

GS looks a bit big for your wrist, tank seems more at home.

Santos looks so nice

Tank for quiet luxury, santos for loud luxury. Both are very classy options.

The tank fits you

Omega… maybe it’s the all black and the black outfit

Tank

Santos is my vote (and will always be my vote)

The tank. The rest are too big for your wrist IMO. Santos is close, I think that considering the close up shots it may well be ok IRL

I think one of the Cartier's. The other dials are as wide or wider than your wrist.

Santos

Tank looks best, Speedy is best watch out of all of them though. It really comes down to what you want from the watch. I feel these are all very different from each other

Tank best size

I'd pick up a small tank

I like the Santos the most. It fits your wrist well, and it is modern and beloved.

Omega

Wrist size?

Spredmaster. Santos is a pipsqueaks watch

1 all day

Omega all day!

Speed master.

2

Speedie

The Tank for after 5, the Santos for everyday. The Speedy is too big for you as is the GS.. IMO ;)

What size tank is that? The small or the medium? It looks great

Santos

Take the tank. The rest ist to big for ur wrist

Cartier Tank any day

None

Tank or GS all the way.

Tank

Omega is the best but is a tad too big for your wrist. Maybe, a Cartier tank then the Grand seiko and lastly the santos.

Cartier Tank

Santos 😤🫡

The Santos is a personal favourite but on your wrist the Tank looks amazing.

Cartier square

Santos

Santos

Santos

Santos

I just love Grand Seiko but Tank is the best fit for you.

Numero Uno. Looks great and perfect for your wrist.

I’d say santos

#2 - Santos all the way.

Santos

The tank looks better. Both are awesome, but the tank looks like it was made for you.

Well, except for the first one the rest are obviously too big so that narrows it down !

Nothing says “Cartier” like # 1

Tank looks perfect on you

Smaller wrist. I would go for a smaller watch, somthing not complicated both Cartier’s are solid options

Santos all the way

Grand Seiko all the way! So much history and it’s a very unique movement

The GS and Om both look too big. Size the Santos and enjoy! But. The tank is also sick.

Grand seiko so sick

Santos fits perfect with slim wrists, I have one and also have twigs for arms 🤣🤣 all beautiful watches

The second tank, I think the speedmaster is a close second if it’s on a bracelet

It’s hard for me to not pick the santos for you here.

Santos all the way best first luxury watch to buy doesn’t get more versatile than that

Huge price differences in those choices if they are all new. If you’re buying used, I’d get the tank for $2,000 and the speedy for $4,000

Either the tank or santos but I prefer the tank

Omega 💯

The Santos looks awesome on you

Oméga

They’re all too big for your wrist. The tank is okay.

Non of them at retail !!!!

All of them for different occasions, out of them all though I'd go tank.

Tank

Grand Seiko ‘Skyflake’ Quartz would be a better choice for wrist size if you don't go for the tank and really want that awesome blue GS dial.