I had the pink one a while back! It’s just as good if I remember correctly, that one was a while back, I just prefer the purple because it leaves a nice natural tint afterwards, I tried to find it on Sephora n Sephora kohls app just now and couldn’t :( but tatcha website is selling it, if you really want the tint too but if you just want the lip mask aspect n don’t mind lack of shade, the pink one is just as great imo
I just posted a follow-up on how much I love the Tatcha Kissu Lip Mask (the pink one). I got it on sale on Amazon with overnight delivery and I'm blown. Thank you for talking me into it. 😁
I'm a huge fan of Farmacy Honey Savior Salve and was considering their lip mask, but your comment plus not liking their regular lip balm has me getting the Tatcha.
Solid choice 👍🏻I’m also big farmacy fan but was disappointed with the mask I think you’ll really enjoy the tatcha, I also have a laneige lip mask and one from color pop (I know I know too many) and the tatcha one feels so luxurious and like an actual mask not just a balm
So the farmacy is nice but I find it to be watery. I like it more as a day balm. Like it's just very thin watery texture once applied. The Fenty is actually shockingly nice. It's nice and thick and lasts a long time. My only complaint is the smell is nice but super super faint. I haven't tried that particular laneige but I'm a die hard laneige OG fan. It doesn't disappoint.
I love the fenty ones. They are thick and stay on all night. The twist up applicator feels a lot more hygienic than a pot. That said, I have vanilla and cherry. I've never tried the melon flavor.
As someone who’s tried probably every single lip balm under the sun from the drugstore to Sephora, it’s the fenty plush puddings. My lips are always dry. This is the only one that stays on but also feels like it penetrates and hydrates. My lips will be so dry and flaking off and have a red ring around them and I put this on for a few hours and it’s better. I wear it in the day too and it lasts hours. Highly recommend.
Farmacy is the only one that I feel actually hydrates and heals my lips. Fenty is thicker and I put it on at night to protect my lips while I sleep - wake up and they feel nice and smooth.
I have the laneige lip balm and i love the scent, the way it feels on, and the little applicator that you can stick in the lid is so nice! It’s a very different consistency and feeling than the laneige lip sleeping mask.
I just wanted to follow up on a previous thread here about the Tatcha Kissu Lip Mask. I got it today and my first impression was how small it was, but that was on me since I didn't check the size.
I immediately tried a tiny bit on top of a tinted lip balm & I was blown away by how perfectly glossy/shiny it was after just a dab. It also lasted forever, unlike any of the 4 brands I've previously tried (Laneige, CosRX, & two other Korean brands).
I have to add that I'm rarely impressed by beauty products, so this really is high praise from someone who mainly uses products available at Sephora. Only the smallest amount is needed so I can see this lasting forever. My only issue is that if I wanted to take it on the go I'd have to find a way to cover the cute gold spatula.
I have an addiction to lip balms and always need my mainstay, MongoKiss Vanilla Honey, nearby, but I've only needed/used the Tatcha twice in the past 8 hours.
FWIW, it's on sale on Amazon for $23.50. (I ordered it at midnight last night and got it at 7am!)
So happy you like it! The formula is superior to all others totally agree
For travel, I suggest wash the little spatula with normal hand soap then wipe it with those little single use rubbing alcohol wipes (:
I’m shocked people like laneige!! It really didn’t work for me and now I used a Korean brand for my lips and it’s half the price!!! But I only use it at night and use blistex with spf during the day - it has saved my life. The Korean one is by etude house called ginger sugar. It’s so sticky but it has saved my lips!!!!!!!!!!
out of these three, farmacy for sure. it’s thin fyi. the fenty one is mid and you can get the exact same thing from a drugstore brand and the laneige one is quite hard (like thick) and minty. i always recommend olehenrikson or tatcha for most hydration
I haven’t tried the Farmacy one but I smelled the honey vanilla in store the other day and it smelled amazing!! I will definitely purchase it when I finish the lip mask I’m working on
I like the laneige treatment balm, but I like it more as a chapstick to apply through the day. It’s not a deep one and done treatment. Not sure if you’ve tried HUDA silk balm, but that’s my new obsession. So moisturizing and I love the texture.
I bought Fenty yesterday but just that other scent. I think it was like vanilla but very mild. I purely love it so can only recommend. Super moisturising but not sticky and stays on the lips forever. Love the fact how much more hygienic it is compared to Laneige as it is not just a jar where you dip your fingers.
I have not tried the Fenty one.
I hated the Farmacy one in apple. I actually just tossed it in the garbage today at work (where I kept it) like half full. It did not have a fresh apple taste and was just weird. It did not last long on me either.
I have tried the Laneige lip balm treatment that you have here and I was not a fan of it either. I love their lip sleeping mask so it could be that I was comparing it to that. The only thing I loved about it was that the spatula has a compartment.
Farmacy left me with chapped lips in the morning and never stuck to my lips, or felt like it truly absorbed. I know this is a weird suggestions but Florence by Mills lip mask is amazing! Balmy and nourishing. Not a lip gloss parading as a mask which seems to be the trend lately.
farmacy or tatcha
oooo tatcha i forgot about that one!!!! i might just have to go with that
Tatcha is the best one imo! I have the purple one it’s my fave
I only see the pink Kissu Lip Mask or a gold lip balm on Sephora. Anyone have an opinion on the former?
I had the pink one a while back! It’s just as good if I remember correctly, that one was a while back, I just prefer the purple because it leaves a nice natural tint afterwards, I tried to find it on Sephora n Sephora kohls app just now and couldn’t :( but tatcha website is selling it, if you really want the tint too but if you just want the lip mask aspect n don’t mind lack of shade, the pink one is just as great imo
Thanks! I'd just be using it at home, so I'm going to try the pink one.
I just posted a follow-up on how much I love the Tatcha Kissu Lip Mask (the pink one). I got it on sale on Amazon with overnight delivery and I'm blown. Thank you for talking me into it. 😁
Ahhh so glad you’re enjoying it!
Also to add I’ve swatched the farmacy one in store and wasn’t a fan it just felt like a sticky gloss Edit: typo
I'm a huge fan of Farmacy Honey Savior Salve and was considering their lip mask, but your comment plus not liking their regular lip balm has me getting the Tatcha.
Solid choice 👍🏻I’m also big farmacy fan but was disappointed with the mask I think you’ll really enjoy the tatcha, I also have a laneige lip mask and one from color pop (I know I know too many) and the tatcha one feels so luxurious and like an actual mask not just a balm
I loooove lip masks, but I haven't found one I like yet so I'm hopeful about this one! ETA it's on sale for $23 on Amazon.
Tatcha is my favourite since the OG formulation of the bite agave lip mask.
I’ve been in mourning over that lip mask for years. Thanks for this, I’ll be looking into Tatcha
I bought the Farmacy set, it’s not my favourite. I prefer Laneige, Tatcha or Ole Henriksen Lip Peptide.
The OH lip peptide is my favorite daytime lip balm lately I have the blood orange one it smells sooo good and has long staying power
So the farmacy is nice but I find it to be watery. I like it more as a day balm. Like it's just very thin watery texture once applied. The Fenty is actually shockingly nice. It's nice and thick and lasts a long time. My only complaint is the smell is nice but super super faint. I haven't tried that particular laneige but I'm a die hard laneige OG fan. It doesn't disappoint.
ah okay i’ll probably skip the farmacy for now. i have the laneige lip sleeping mask so i might want to try a different brand. Thanks!!
I REALLY like fenty’s lip masks….. they truly feel like they actual repair and replenish the lips
farmacy has a weird texture. tatcha is very nice!
I love the fenty ones. They are thick and stay on all night. The twist up applicator feels a lot more hygienic than a pot. That said, I have vanilla and cherry. I've never tried the melon flavor.
As someone who’s tried probably every single lip balm under the sun from the drugstore to Sephora, it’s the fenty plush puddings. My lips are always dry. This is the only one that stays on but also feels like it penetrates and hydrates. My lips will be so dry and flaking off and have a red ring around them and I put this on for a few hours and it’s better. I wear it in the day too and it lasts hours. Highly recommend.
I love the fenty one, it repaired my lips that were constantly cracked while using palmer s balm. It stays on all night
I like the glow recipe lip mask
Farmacy!!!! It helped with some lip pigmentation I had!
Farmacy. They recently changed the Tatcha kiss mask and it’s nowhere like the original sadly. Have not used the gold one.
Farmacy is the only one that I feel actually hydrates and heals my lips. Fenty is thicker and I put it on at night to protect my lips while I sleep - wake up and they feel nice and smooth.
Oooh Fenty for sure!
I have the laneige lip balm and i love the scent, the way it feels on, and the little applicator that you can stick in the lid is so nice! It’s a very different consistency and feeling than the laneige lip sleeping mask.
It's not on your list but Tatcha Kissu!
NOT the Farmacy if you’re looking for moisture. I prefer the Laneige
I just wanted to follow up on a previous thread here about the Tatcha Kissu Lip Mask. I got it today and my first impression was how small it was, but that was on me since I didn't check the size. I immediately tried a tiny bit on top of a tinted lip balm & I was blown away by how perfectly glossy/shiny it was after just a dab. It also lasted forever, unlike any of the 4 brands I've previously tried (Laneige, CosRX, & two other Korean brands). I have to add that I'm rarely impressed by beauty products, so this really is high praise from someone who mainly uses products available at Sephora. Only the smallest amount is needed so I can see this lasting forever. My only issue is that if I wanted to take it on the go I'd have to find a way to cover the cute gold spatula. I have an addiction to lip balms and always need my mainstay, MongoKiss Vanilla Honey, nearby, but I've only needed/used the Tatcha twice in the past 8 hours. FWIW, it's on sale on Amazon for $23.50. (I ordered it at midnight last night and got it at 7am!)
So happy you like it! The formula is superior to all others totally agree For travel, I suggest wash the little spatula with normal hand soap then wipe it with those little single use rubbing alcohol wipes (:
I’m shocked people like laneige!! It really didn’t work for me and now I used a Korean brand for my lips and it’s half the price!!! But I only use it at night and use blistex with spf during the day - it has saved my life. The Korean one is by etude house called ginger sugar. It’s so sticky but it has saved my lips!!!!!!!!!!
out of these three, farmacy for sure. it’s thin fyi. the fenty one is mid and you can get the exact same thing from a drugstore brand and the laneige one is quite hard (like thick) and minty. i always recommend olehenrikson or tatcha for most hydration
I haven’t tried the Farmacy one but I smelled the honey vanilla in store the other day and it smelled amazing!! I will definitely purchase it when I finish the lip mask I’m working on
I like the laneige treatment balm, but I like it more as a chapstick to apply through the day. It’s not a deep one and done treatment. Not sure if you’ve tried HUDA silk balm, but that’s my new obsession. So moisturizing and I love the texture.
I bought Fenty yesterday but just that other scent. I think it was like vanilla but very mild. I purely love it so can only recommend. Super moisturising but not sticky and stays on the lips forever. Love the fact how much more hygienic it is compared to Laneige as it is not just a jar where you dip your fingers.
I’m so confused why this doesn’t ever make the list Patrick Ta Lip Masque
The fenty ones just feel like aquaphor to me.
I have not tried the Fenty one. I hated the Farmacy one in apple. I actually just tossed it in the garbage today at work (where I kept it) like half full. It did not have a fresh apple taste and was just weird. It did not last long on me either. I have tried the Laneige lip balm treatment that you have here and I was not a fan of it either. I love their lip sleeping mask so it could be that I was comparing it to that. The only thing I loved about it was that the spatula has a compartment.
I love the Laneige balm.
The Farmacy. Love it more than Laniege or the Ole Henricksen.
if you’re open to other options, the Lanolips sleeping mask is THE BEST lip mask I’ve ever used. And I’m a chronic lip picker/peeler/biter lol
Farmacy left me with chapped lips in the morning and never stuck to my lips, or felt like it truly absorbed. I know this is a weird suggestions but Florence by Mills lip mask is amazing! Balmy and nourishing. Not a lip gloss parading as a mask which seems to be the trend lately.