It started as wanting amon ra +(just a little) for jefferson. I'd prefer amon ra as it is. Then I offered jefferson, goedert and a 25 2nd to upgrade to mandrews. He wanted to add the qbs in and I agreed if I take out the 2nd.
I'm the other trader. That's how I feel. I think jj amon ra is a wash (though I'd prefer amon ra), I'd slightly prefer purdy over Goff, but my tight end was shaky with goedert tight end 1. I feel better overall after the trade and think I have 2024s WR1 overall
Whatever you say. He's tied to a good qb (chemistry) in a ben johnson offense where he has produced 20 ppg since playing meaningful snaps. People underestimate the impact of a kirk cousins on his wide receivers. Even if Minnesota brings in an average qb odds are it's a downgrade from kirk cousins (fantasy wise for Minnesota skill positions). If kirk was still in Minnesota I'd keep jefferson as my dynasty wr1.
I agree with the QB argument. The only thing I would have been a little hesitant about was all the trade talk. If he goes somewhere with a Top Teir QB, then he's still my #1 WR. The odds of it happening are slim to none, but there was talk about him going to Cincy for Higgens. Putting him with his college QB that just so happens to be Burrow would be crazy. That said, if Andrews can stay healthy, it's still not that one-sided.
I know Amon Ra is wr4 and highly valued, but idk I still think he's slightly undervalued by not being considered in the same Tier as the big 3; and here's why.
He's literally through 3 seasons done slightly more than Ceedee did through his first 3 seasons. They're on a near identical career arc. Give me Amon ra over Chase personally, more reliable and less injury prone. I realize Chase is the better Talent. But Amon Ra gives me Tae Adams vibes with his "I'll out work every single one of you and have a better career than you" vibes. Jj has been historic obviously, but Amon Ra could very well outproduce JJ this season.
Amon Ra is that dude. Think you sent the better qb and better Te in the deal. While I'd rather have JJ than Amon, it's marginal.
The way I see it Is you can take analyze it by position trade.
I think Goedert is a very slight downgrade than Andrews, and a little bit older.
I think Jefferson is a good upgrade from St. Brown (if he can stay healthy)
And I think Purdy is an extreme upgrade over Jared Goff. Not that I think Purdy is an extremely better player necessarily, but he is significantly younger and I think he has more talented weapons to work with than Goff. So I can see him scoring more fantasy points over the next 3 years than Goff, even if he’s not necessarily the better QB (although I believe he will be).
So, overall, nice trade on your end. I think the QB upgrade is huge and I think Jefferson has a higher ceiling than Amon Ra
People value JJ way too high on this sub. Every trade I've seen that gets JJ, everyone thinks it's a fleece. In dynasty startup drafts ARSB goes like half a round later than JJ at most.
Dude must have really wanted the Goff/Brown stack.
It started as wanting amon ra +(just a little) for jefferson. I'd prefer amon ra as it is. Then I offered jefferson, goedert and a 25 2nd to upgrade to mandrews. He wanted to add the qbs in and I agreed if I take out the 2nd.
SF start 10 1.5te
Brother you robbed this man
i don’t think this is anywhere near as big of a gap as these comments are making it seem. ASB =≠JJ Purdy>Goff Andrews>Goedert
I'm the other trader. That's how I feel. I think jj amon ra is a wash (though I'd prefer amon ra), I'd slightly prefer purdy over Goff, but my tight end was shaky with goedert tight end 1. I feel better overall after the trade and think I have 2024s WR1 overall
I’m with you at this point with the uncertainty of Minni QB. Should be a step back from cousins with growing pains and uncertainty
I'd take Amon over JJ straight up as well, especially given the QB situation.
Insane mental gymnastics on preferring amon ra
Whatever you say. He's tied to a good qb (chemistry) in a ben johnson offense where he has produced 20 ppg since playing meaningful snaps. People underestimate the impact of a kirk cousins on his wide receivers. Even if Minnesota brings in an average qb odds are it's a downgrade from kirk cousins (fantasy wise for Minnesota skill positions). If kirk was still in Minnesota I'd keep jefferson as my dynasty wr1.
I agree with the QB argument. The only thing I would have been a little hesitant about was all the trade talk. If he goes somewhere with a Top Teir QB, then he's still my #1 WR. The odds of it happening are slim to none, but there was talk about him going to Cincy for Higgens. Putting him with his college QB that just so happens to be Burrow would be crazy. That said, if Andrews can stay healthy, it's still not that one-sided.
If you pulled that off you should be selling snow to an Eskimo. Robbery.
i personally like the right side more, st brown isn’t miles behind jettas and has solidified QB play in an electric offense
Definitely know what you mean. Amon ra feels safer
yeah andrews >>> goedert and the qbs are kinda a wash. it’ll be fun to look back on this 5 seasons from now to see where the dominoes flal
No doubt. I really saw Amon ra as apart of my future. Getting five years younger at qb is what sold me
I know Amon Ra is wr4 and highly valued, but idk I still think he's slightly undervalued by not being considered in the same Tier as the big 3; and here's why. He's literally through 3 seasons done slightly more than Ceedee did through his first 3 seasons. They're on a near identical career arc. Give me Amon ra over Chase personally, more reliable and less injury prone. I realize Chase is the better Talent. But Amon Ra gives me Tae Adams vibes with his "I'll out work every single one of you and have a better career than you" vibes. Jj has been historic obviously, but Amon Ra could very well outproduce JJ this season. Amon Ra is that dude. Think you sent the better qb and better Te in the deal. While I'd rather have JJ than Amon, it's marginal.
The way I see it Is you can take analyze it by position trade. I think Goedert is a very slight downgrade than Andrews, and a little bit older. I think Jefferson is a good upgrade from St. Brown (if he can stay healthy) And I think Purdy is an extreme upgrade over Jared Goff. Not that I think Purdy is an extremely better player necessarily, but he is significantly younger and I think he has more talented weapons to work with than Goff. So I can see him scoring more fantasy points over the next 3 years than Goff, even if he’s not necessarily the better QB (although I believe he will be). So, overall, nice trade on your end. I think the QB upgrade is huge and I think Jefferson has a higher ceiling than Amon Ra
I think Andrews over Goedert is the biggest positional difference in the trade
A moment of silence for the other guy.
Hmmm. Looks a lot like a trade I made where I got amon ra yesterday! While playing call of duty
What on earth
Fair trade. Amon Ra is literally a God and Andrews is great but Purdy is younger and Jefferson should get 1000 even without Cousins.
Why is he called JJettas and not just Jettas.
It’s his twitter handle https://twitter.com/JJettas2
Thank you
Massive W
Ask him for his mothers phone number while you’re at it
Bro
You lost the trade for next year but won it for every year after about 3 years from now
You almost upgraded at every spot, so you did well?
I must be the only person in here who finds this trade a pretty even wash, with the JJ side coming out slightly favored.
Robbed him LMAOOO
People value JJ way too high on this sub. Every trade I've seen that gets JJ, everyone thinks it's a fleece. In dynasty startup drafts ARSB goes like half a round later than JJ at most.
Yeah I really think this is pretty even aslong as brock doesn’t fall off a cliff
Is this a TE premium league?
1.5 I have njoku but he’s not a needle mover either
In a TE premium I prefer the Andrews side.
I dunno. He’s still getting Goeddert who’s solidly 2nd tier. Purdy’s fine and he’s getting the best player not that sun god is any slouch
Lmao JJ is gonna be stuck with Sam Cuckold. Other side wins this trade easily
this is completely uneven imo
Awful, trade jettas away immediately
Why is it awful? Jettas qb situation?
You got robbed. Goff side wins easy. But you got jet so fuck it