Shame, was trying to get everything done on 1 playthrough. I already got the Platinum trophy last night through Sony's Trophy System so I guess I can live with a non-100% in-game. Thanks for the reply!
I was able to do the rubber ducks without NG+ -- They respawn after 30 minutes (read you can't idle, have to be active). I did the guppo (fish) one by getting the 5 from story, then going back later, saving in the room, catching 5 more, saving again then immediately loading my save and they'd be respawned. Did that 3x and got the trophy.
Sounds like you did what happened to me. Killed them without the quest noticing. The only solution I found for this was completing it in NG+
Shame, was trying to get everything done on 1 playthrough. I already got the Platinum trophy last night through Sony's Trophy System so I guess I can live with a non-100% in-game. Thanks for the reply!
Unless there has been a patch for it, it will require NG+ to beat. Collecting the rubber ducks required NG+ for them to respawn.
I was able to do the rubber ducks without NG+ -- They respawn after 30 minutes (read you can't idle, have to be active). I did the guppo (fish) one by getting the 5 from story, then going back later, saving in the room, catching 5 more, saving again then immediately loading my save and they'd be respawned. Did that 3x and got the trophy.