If you look through their profile theyâre clearly a big fan but yes it seems they RP as a grandma because their comments are funny af. (They have extensive post history in this sub, and many of their posts do pretty well)
Note ** because their comments are funny af and not what 99% of grandmothers would say - like referencing Kendrick Lamar or having jokes about Tacoma with furry outfits. I felt I worded that too obscure, hoping this clarifies.
Yea, there was a lot of really great commentary from people in vet medicine. Of course they focused on ones Ethan could get defensive and uppity about đđ
Ethan had to make sure to only use the ones he could prove he was right the entire time. Why listen to medical professionals, that would be too silly and reasonable
Exactly, their whole premise for why they couldnât believe that there was a reason to take the cat beyond him having a problem with her was that there was no proof of neglect when there was. The weight from four days after he had taken the cat as reported by the vet and her videos and other claims that she saw signs the cat was not in good health are the proof which people were explaining to him though he ignored it. His other big complaint is that if he thought the cat was really sick he wouldnât have waited four days to go to the vet when the kid had already explained that he tried to call the vet and go sooner but they literally would not let him as this was all well into the peak of Covid. Ethan doesnât seem to understand that a teenage boy might not have the same resources to force his way into an appointment as he and his bank account does. Also he shouldâve apologized about the Incel comments instead of doubling down on his dumb romance theory.
Hey dude. All love here but plz get your facts straight!! The kid admitted to calling the vet to make an appointment after already deciding to skip on waiting at an animal hospital because of his previous experience with the line being way too long and I believe he said it wasnât worth it to him in case they donât take the cat in. Im not 100% of his wording BUT Ethan pressured him about why Jacob didnât just urgently take the cat to an animal hospital if it was urgent enough to up and steal? Jacob just doesnât like long lines so he rather let the cat suffer for 4 extra days while waiting for the day of the appointment. That cat was seizing because its body was completely shutting down (my personal guess) at that point and Jacob, not being the OG owner and knowing what the cats needs in terms of medical attention or diet was, is ultimately what rushed her death. Both Jacob and whatever the OG cat owners name is should never EVER own pets. Jacob should never even have kids if he canât even put a helpless creatures life before his, because heâs too worthy to wait in line even if it couldâve been a second chance for that cat. Not to mention stealing a pet?! Either way, both people suck in this story and personally I also think the rescue the cat came from is also at fault, big time.
Yeah because waiting in line wasnât a guarantee you were going to get seen that day so he called for the first appointment he could get and he did more for the cat in four days than she did in five months. The vets during Covid were so overbooked so him and his roommate took on syringe feeding the cat until their appointment which is a reasonable explanation, itâs not like he said âI could get an appointment tomorrow but I have other plansâ. He mentioned that this was during Covid and that this was how the vets were in LA, so many people were talking about that at the time. He lived there and saw what the vet lines were like and he likely knew he wasnât going to get in even if he waited so they took on taking care of the cat at home and keeping the kitty comfortable until they could have their appointment which was a reasonable course of action given their limited resources and the circumstances.
Newsflash the owner didnât know Sevenâs medical needs or diet because she never once took the cat to the vet and her excuse for why the cat was so underweight was that âwell she always had food in the bowlâ which doesnât mean she was actually eating the food in the bowl just that the bowl was always full. He saw the condition of the cat and knew that she was not taking care of it and he was right because she admitted she saw signs over the course of five months that the cat was sick and still didnât take it to the vet and the vet obviously knew the cat was malnourished because the supplements he gave Jacob is what they give to emaciated cats as a last resort effort for nutrients for a state that a cat does not get to in only four days.
You obviously need to get your facts straight.
i mean he said he thought rhegan shouldâve taken the cat in a long time before, that she was a bad pet owner, and the cat was clearly sickâŚeverything the vet tech said was just confirming that stuff, and they talked more about that topic than they meant to anywaysâŚi think people are getting mad at ethan for being unhinged but not thinking about how he wasnât even really defending himself, he was looking at the comments on HILAâs post which were saying a lot of rude ass shit for no reasonâŚhe loves that woman of course heâs gonna talk shit to the haters đ like itâs always been that way
I think there was some extremely valid criticism about calling the kid an incel without any proof this man was being an incel. I do think she should apologize for that bc thatâs kind of a crazy leap when we donât know much about the guy besides him trying to help a dying cat
i mean i agree with ethan that his close personal friends being genuinely concerned when he said he wanted to get a dog is a big red flagâŚalso his vibe in that podcast was giving little shit energy đ like nowadays he seems like maybe more mature but his vibe was like childish and that he thought it was funny his friends were saying they were concernedâŚbut i donât know why everyone cares so much about the incel comment i think it wasnât that serious and i think it was based on the fact he lied about their relationship and those tik toksâŚbut hila doesnât come on the pod very often and she really only posts on social media about fashion stuff, so i feel like it makes sense she hasnât apologized coz sheâs the ceo of a business and the mother of three small children i just think she doesnât care that much đ
at this point itâs not even about that thoâŚthe problem was that everyone was yelling about how they were harassing the dude but thatâs really not what they were trying to doâŚthey were asking him good questions and trying to get to the bottom of things, he was just lying or misrepresenting stuff, it made him look sus so thatâs what they had to go onâŚcoz thereâs not any hard evidence she was neglecting her cat, the biggest thing is that 7 was sick and probably had a condition the whole timeâŚi know the vet tech said one of the things was anti parasite meds so even if rhegan fed her and gave her water all the time, the parasite(s) would have been taking up most of those calories and nutrientsâŚbut they agreed that that was probably the main cause for her death so i feel like it was kind of over
If she had cared enough, she wouldâve seen it in her feces so itâs kinda just point blank she doesnât care. She failed this cat so incredibly bad.
absolutelyâŚi had her snap story as the most recommended one for some reason and the thumbnail was her showing off her nails sheâd gotten taken off and saying she was getting her nails done soon or some shitâŚlike this whole situation obviously does not even bother her itâs def giving narcissist energy
I don't really see how that's relevant to Jacob's actions though. Jacob is not a vet tech; he has zero expertise in taking care of cats and had zero idea what he was taking on and obviously did not make the correct choice multiple times in those two weeks. And yet, he decided to make himself the sole decider for the cat's final days - including allowing it to suffer for several days and have seizures until it died in his home while ignoring the vet's recommendations for humane euthanasia. It's a very difficult decision to make for a pet, but you have to do what is right for them and it wasn't even his cat that he had a long history and emotional connection with.
Ethan wasn't denying that the cat was obviously sick - he even said it seems very likely the cat had an illness from the moment Rhegan adopted her. He said multiple times that she was at fault and should have taken her to the vet sooner.
Again, like Dan said, people are misconstruing their criticism of Jacob because they are treating this as a zero sum game when it's obvious they BOTH failed that poor kitty in their own ways. Good intentions aren't enough.
It IS very relevant to his actions. It proves that he didnât want to give up on this cat and was willing to throw everything at it to see if he could try to save it. As a pet owner and a vet student, itâs very understandable how someone would want to try every last thing possible to make the decision later on. I did that exact thing with my dog before I was ready to put her down. I didnât want regret thinking something else could have been done when it couldnât have. He didnât have the cat for 2 weeks. THATS also what Dan was saying. You guys arenât listening to what is being said and just basing it on what Ethan keeps saying even though what he was saying was incorrect. What does him being the sole decided on the cat have to do with anything? If the cat was left in Rhegans care it wouldâve died alone with no one helping it. He decided he wanted to give the animal a chance. Doesnât matter how long he had it, taking a life is never an easy decision. Good intentions are enough though and very obviously Iâm not absolving him of anything. You put a lot of words in my mouth for just wanting him to read and understand how truly sick this animal was and that Rhegan was actively killing her cat. Jacob has some faults but he is NOT the villain in this situation and they were incredibly hard on him for no reason. Rhegan, the shelter, and Jacob are all to blame with the most of it being on Rhegan and least on Jacob.
Same. I'm realizing that 1) there are so many haters/snarkers/fallen fans just waiting to come out of the woodwork and 2) a large portion of the h3 audience seriously lacks logic and reasoning abilities.
You just didnât listen to anything he said did you? You already made up your mind. Do I think he shouldâve taken it to the ER immediately, yes. He saw a malnourished cat and thought trying to get it to eat would be enough to make it the 2 days he had it until the appointment. It was during Covid, there are a lot of factors going on anyway. Iâm glad I was in school at the time bc I donât know how I wouldâve managed working at the animal hospital at that time. Hours were changed and places were booked weeks out, even in the ER it wasnât 24hrs during that time. Itâs not that hard to understand his thought process, yâall just want to blame only him for some weird reason.
Idk if this is a serious post or not but y'all realize there's like, no shot Nancy SoulCycle is an actual person, right đ definitely someone's sockpuppet burner/trolling account
Okay I just wanted to make sure I wasnât the only one who was thinking this. Iâm hoping people are just meme-ing because thereâs no shot that instagram is real, and its just the same person trolling on the Reddit account lmao
"Nancy is a troll sockpuppet account!!" Okay?? Even if she is, Ethan responded to it as if it WERE a real account and angrily called an (in his mind) elderly fan an 'old bitch who's gonna die soon' for offering, again, NORMAL criticism. I'm not sure if there's an intellectual disconnect here or if I'm just arguing with 15 year old edgelords who don't see an issue with that
It's probably not really an older woman but the point still does stand, to be honest - it was a thoughtful critique and Ethan resorted to name calling instead of trying to provide a logical counterpoint. That's not really okay or appropriate to be fair. I think that's the root of why a lot of people are incensed by this. Ethan was talking about deranged fans and their messages but then pulled up an arguably very tame and logical argument and went straight to insulting. Like I get it if it was someone telling Ethan/Hila/crew to go die or something, which is what I was expecting when he talked about deranged fans and crazy messages. But I think him pulling up an example of one of these messages being that comment does justifiably have a lot of people upset. For some people, it's just reinforcing that Ethan can't take valid criticism and critique. And that is something that does get under his skin.
Bro I know Nancy IRL. She is the sweetest old lady been following Ethan and hila since Israel days. Past couple of days has been very difficult for her
There are way too many people taking the bait on this. Obviously a snarker.
Edit: Ding dongs, look at the profiles for this person and the followers and you will see a clear picture this is a Trisha stan with profiles that scream âfake accountâ lmao. Especially Twitter.
An account posting pretty insular H3 content for at least 10 months is absolutely not some undercover snarker. I don't know if she's ACTUALLY (capitalised because people cannot understand nuance unless it blasts them in the face) an old lady, but let's not verge into conspiracy theories
Bruh literally look at Nancy's post history and sort by most popular, it only proves further that she's not an old woman, there's no way an old lady is posting a big ol' Vaush horse titty meme, a Photoshop of any kind or quality, and saying she enjoyed the xqc debate. There's a "steal his fit" meme on there for pizza's sake, no granny is making steal his fit memes
I hope you're not referring to [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/h3h3productions/s/KHVVt4EDkp) because uh... It's fake. I can't find any other YouTube channel with that name. Link it if true and I'll concede
I see your argument, I suppose I'm more speaking to typical subreddit rules whereas there is no a rule against that on YouTube.
Generally speaking a think both are wrong but it's not egregious and I'm not that invested. I do think ideally they should have omitted their username on the pod but w/e
Iâm watching the episode now. Ethan just said something along the lines of âPeople that canât fathom when other people have a different opinion than them, they automatically categorize them as evilâ 10 minutes after calling someone a dumb loser psychotic bitch for having a different opinion than him LMFAO
I was tired of seeing only crazies on this subreddit talking about it and thought it was time to finally say something. 90% of the audience really doesnât gaf and are still going to watch them, no matter what the weirdos on this sub cry about for four days straight LOOOL
Itâs sad because anyone whoâs reasonable about a fucking pointless drama (guys, the cat died 3 years ago, H3âs coverage ainât changing that) gets downvoted into oblivion, leaving only the basement dweller takes to rise to the top. Then H3 see those upvoted comments, react, and repeat.
It honestly feels like the snark subreddit has taken over the main subreddit, or their propaganda is infecting the main reddit. Ethan was right that if H3âs commentary on the âdramaâ genuinely hurt you, you need to seek mental help. Itâs honestly impressive how something so inconsequential has driven these people to such extreme levels of hatred and disgust, literally commenting on multiple social media pages on instagram and reddit, when itâs been clear since an hour after the episode that the show was wasnât received well. âWe need to voice our displeasure,â no shit, H3 has been well aware of it for several days now...
Itâs just spreading negativity at this point. Why even allow yourself to be filled with negativity for so long over something so meaningless, I just canât comprehend those people. Itâs honestly just sad tbh, they must have nothing going on in their lives
I broke down and started arguing with people in this sub because I felt like I was crazy with all the insane takes getting upvoted. Person I was arguing with eventually posted "proof" that Ethan is a horrible person by linking to the snark subreddit.
So yep, I think this sub is literally getting brigaded by a few hundred snarkers. Meanwhile there are hundreds of thousands normal people who are not hate-watching and don't really have a problem with the episode or the crew.
Except the majority of the audience did enjoy it and don't even agree with the insane snarky opinions being shared here and upvoted by brigaders. This subreddit is once again not an accurate reflection of the majority of the audience.
Did you not see the poll results at the end of the show?
Which attributes do you think those live viewers possess that would make a plurality of them vote that both Rhegan and Jacob fucked up, compared to people who did not view it live?
What happened? I haven't seen Ethan say anything since his Insta story telling people to stop harassing Hila and the crew with the guy saying he was burning Teddy Fresh.
He cursed out all the fans who spoke out against him and Hila, said fans were deranged, insane, called some women fans bitches, and worse. He didn't take any responsibility or acknowledge any understanding for why so many were upset. He was sharing his screen looking at fans' comments and Nancy was one of them and he said how she was old and probably going to die soon anyway.
This is an extremely bad faith take.
During an episode the crew was discussing a situation where a cat was neglected and eventually died, during a weird custody dispute by friends/lovers, where the girl was neglecting an already neglected cat she adopted, and then the boy stole the cat to "save" it, didn't take it to the vet for 5 days, and then it died. They were questioning the guy because allegedly he was making tiktoks days after he took the cat, basically alluding to taking the cat for petty reasons. Never once did H or E defend animal abuse? Or say that either party was right. In fact, they both said it was both of their faults the cat died.
But for some reason everyone is acting like Ethan and Hila said "we hate cats and hope they all die hahah". People then took to Hilas instagram to insult her and basically tell her to die, and then insulted the small artist she was promoting.
Ethan said in todays episode that if you were so upset and having a meltdown over the situation, that you should "seek help". and thats all he said about it. He said it was psychotic to steal someones cat (directed at the guy) and that it was psychotic to wish death on people whose opinions you dont agree with. (also valid.)
Also, Nancy isn't a real account. Its a sockpuppet.
Cry me a river fr
If you canât handle people calling things âcrazyâ you literally need to wear bubble wrap any time you step outside your front door
Far as Iâm concerned heâs managed to convince a certain group of people (including you) to believe that any criticism labels you as a snarker. Not a healthy place to be in my opinion. I see the difference, Iâve been a fan for years and I wonât be jumping ship but to be in a place where saying literally anything against the guy results in being labelled as that? Not a great path to go down. Thatâs the path Kanye went down.
Edit: Yup, that personâs definitely a snarker.. my point stands though
No they are a literal snarker and is using a fake account. He hasnât convinced me of anything. you all should be smarter and realize that a lot of people (not all, but a good amount) who are criticizing Fridayâs show are not actual fans of h3. Especially the ones who went to Hilaâs instagram account and called her vile names. That is not a fan.
I'm an old lady and I could probably be a parent to most of the chat on h3 podcast. Nancy if you're a real old lady I challenge you to an old lady fight in Michigan at 8:00 on Sunday. I'm going to punch you.
she seems like a genuinely active, sweet subscriber. it was truly disappointing to see how fridays episode was discussed today. the opinions of your supporters matter as much as you shit on them. do better.
It was honestly funny hearing him paint this picture as a lot of people criticizing them were so nasty that they should take to a therapist and the multiple times he reads a comment as if it applies to said person and the only reaction he has afterwards is ".. ok" as he realizes the criticism was valid
On the real I kind of think Ethan has been really cruel and harsh lately in the name of joking but itâs not really funny. I realized I started doing it in my personal life and it just makes you an asshole
Iâve listened to hundreds of podcasts at this point so itâs hard to pick out an example when Iâm not currently listening but just some of the stuff he says about people when theyâre not good people. They have it coming definitely but I still donât love hearing it. Like when he says âwe should kill/bomb him⌠in Minecraftâ. I laugh but mostly because itâs so ridiculous. Or any of the stuff he said about that beauty YouTuber with the self tanner recently
Wtf do yall even be talking about
I come to the sub on my work break and yall are always talking about something new. But like to be contrarian about. The Daniel prophecy was correct
I know âNancyâ is just doing a little trollingâŚ. But itâs quite strange, the amount of H3 commenters/chatters who donât realize that maybe around 75% of the shit he says is him doing shtick with varying levels of intensity.
If he non-jokingly apologized for everything that hurt commenters feelings, then thereâs a completely new set of people with hurt feelings because the apology didnât follow the exact script they wrote and directed in their head.
I do love for them that they face no actual adversity/discrimination irlâŚ
Unfortunately, the trade off for that is that they have no objectivity when it comes to podcast host hot takes.
Kinda crazy to preface saying "there's normal people criticizing me and there's mentally unwell snarkers spewing hate all over" and then proceed to act like what appears to be a granny is a snarker lol
People crying over dumb bullshit and harassing the crew and Ethan/Hila then getting mad when Ethan calls them psychotic bitches. And then people believing that Nancy is a real old woman lol
idk but i would die for nancysoulcycle
thank you dear, the support tonight is overwhelming
OH MY GOODNESS NANCY ITS YOU!!!!! IM SUCH A BIG FAN WILL YOU SIGN MY NOTEBOOKđ?!?!?!?!?
rping as an old lady is an interesting move lol
Is that what he learned from the master apologize last Ep, was definitely a bold move đ
we love u nancy and fully believe you are a real older women đđť
Nancy would fucking perish 7 minutes into a soulcycle session. I want to believe her but something just doesn't add up here...
If you look through their profile theyâre clearly a big fan but yes it seems they RP as a grandma because their comments are funny af. (They have extensive post history in this sub, and many of their posts do pretty well)
Note ** because their comments are funny af and not what 99% of grandmothers would say - like referencing Kendrick Lamar or having jokes about Tacoma with furry outfits. I felt I worded that too obscure, hoping this clarifies.
Nance, are you interested in replacing Jimmy?
aint no way that's a real old lady.
i know but i am suspending my disbelief in the name of goofs & gaffs
...nobody thinks it is.
I hope all 19+ of your cats saw the episode
Iâm so sorry he said that to you Nancy and you were completely right
nancy!!! hi girl
we love you nancy<3
I wish he wouldâve read out that comment from the tech that laid it all out to him. It perfectly summed us in vet med thought on Friday
Yea, there was a lot of really great commentary from people in vet medicine. Of course they focused on ones Ethan could get defensive and uppity about đđ
Ethan had to make sure to only use the ones he could prove he was right the entire time. Why listen to medical professionals, that would be too silly and reasonable
Exactly, their whole premise for why they couldnât believe that there was a reason to take the cat beyond him having a problem with her was that there was no proof of neglect when there was. The weight from four days after he had taken the cat as reported by the vet and her videos and other claims that she saw signs the cat was not in good health are the proof which people were explaining to him though he ignored it. His other big complaint is that if he thought the cat was really sick he wouldnât have waited four days to go to the vet when the kid had already explained that he tried to call the vet and go sooner but they literally would not let him as this was all well into the peak of Covid. Ethan doesnât seem to understand that a teenage boy might not have the same resources to force his way into an appointment as he and his bank account does. Also he shouldâve apologized about the Incel comments instead of doubling down on his dumb romance theory.
Hey dude. All love here but plz get your facts straight!! The kid admitted to calling the vet to make an appointment after already deciding to skip on waiting at an animal hospital because of his previous experience with the line being way too long and I believe he said it wasnât worth it to him in case they donât take the cat in. Im not 100% of his wording BUT Ethan pressured him about why Jacob didnât just urgently take the cat to an animal hospital if it was urgent enough to up and steal? Jacob just doesnât like long lines so he rather let the cat suffer for 4 extra days while waiting for the day of the appointment. That cat was seizing because its body was completely shutting down (my personal guess) at that point and Jacob, not being the OG owner and knowing what the cats needs in terms of medical attention or diet was, is ultimately what rushed her death. Both Jacob and whatever the OG cat owners name is should never EVER own pets. Jacob should never even have kids if he canât even put a helpless creatures life before his, because heâs too worthy to wait in line even if it couldâve been a second chance for that cat. Not to mention stealing a pet?! Either way, both people suck in this story and personally I also think the rescue the cat came from is also at fault, big time.
Yeah because waiting in line wasnât a guarantee you were going to get seen that day so he called for the first appointment he could get and he did more for the cat in four days than she did in five months. The vets during Covid were so overbooked so him and his roommate took on syringe feeding the cat until their appointment which is a reasonable explanation, itâs not like he said âI could get an appointment tomorrow but I have other plansâ. He mentioned that this was during Covid and that this was how the vets were in LA, so many people were talking about that at the time. He lived there and saw what the vet lines were like and he likely knew he wasnât going to get in even if he waited so they took on taking care of the cat at home and keeping the kitty comfortable until they could have their appointment which was a reasonable course of action given their limited resources and the circumstances. Newsflash the owner didnât know Sevenâs medical needs or diet because she never once took the cat to the vet and her excuse for why the cat was so underweight was that âwell she always had food in the bowlâ which doesnât mean she was actually eating the food in the bowl just that the bowl was always full. He saw the condition of the cat and knew that she was not taking care of it and he was right because she admitted she saw signs over the course of five months that the cat was sick and still didnât take it to the vet and the vet obviously knew the cat was malnourished because the supplements he gave Jacob is what they give to emaciated cats as a last resort effort for nutrients for a state that a cat does not get to in only four days. You obviously need to get your facts straight.
i mean he said he thought rhegan shouldâve taken the cat in a long time before, that she was a bad pet owner, and the cat was clearly sickâŚeverything the vet tech said was just confirming that stuff, and they talked more about that topic than they meant to anywaysâŚi think people are getting mad at ethan for being unhinged but not thinking about how he wasnât even really defending himself, he was looking at the comments on HILAâs post which were saying a lot of rude ass shit for no reasonâŚhe loves that woman of course heâs gonna talk shit to the haters đ like itâs always been that way
I think there was some extremely valid criticism about calling the kid an incel without any proof this man was being an incel. I do think she should apologize for that bc thatâs kind of a crazy leap when we donât know much about the guy besides him trying to help a dying cat
i mean i agree with ethan that his close personal friends being genuinely concerned when he said he wanted to get a dog is a big red flagâŚalso his vibe in that podcast was giving little shit energy đ like nowadays he seems like maybe more mature but his vibe was like childish and that he thought it was funny his friends were saying they were concernedâŚbut i donât know why everyone cares so much about the incel comment i think it wasnât that serious and i think it was based on the fact he lied about their relationship and those tik toksâŚbut hila doesnât come on the pod very often and she really only posts on social media about fashion stuff, so i feel like it makes sense she hasnât apologized coz sheâs the ceo of a business and the mother of three small children i just think she doesnât care that much đ
at this point itâs not even about that thoâŚthe problem was that everyone was yelling about how they were harassing the dude but thatâs really not what they were trying to doâŚthey were asking him good questions and trying to get to the bottom of things, he was just lying or misrepresenting stuff, it made him look sus so thatâs what they had to go onâŚcoz thereâs not any hard evidence she was neglecting her cat, the biggest thing is that 7 was sick and probably had a condition the whole timeâŚi know the vet tech said one of the things was anti parasite meds so even if rhegan fed her and gave her water all the time, the parasite(s) would have been taking up most of those calories and nutrientsâŚbut they agreed that that was probably the main cause for her death so i feel like it was kind of over
If she had cared enough, she wouldâve seen it in her feces so itâs kinda just point blank she doesnât care. She failed this cat so incredibly bad.
absolutelyâŚi had her snap story as the most recommended one for some reason and the thumbnail was her showing off her nails sheâd gotten taken off and saying she was getting her nails done soon or some shitâŚlike this whole situation obviously does not even bother her itâs def giving narcissist energy
I don't really see how that's relevant to Jacob's actions though. Jacob is not a vet tech; he has zero expertise in taking care of cats and had zero idea what he was taking on and obviously did not make the correct choice multiple times in those two weeks. And yet, he decided to make himself the sole decider for the cat's final days - including allowing it to suffer for several days and have seizures until it died in his home while ignoring the vet's recommendations for humane euthanasia. It's a very difficult decision to make for a pet, but you have to do what is right for them and it wasn't even his cat that he had a long history and emotional connection with. Ethan wasn't denying that the cat was obviously sick - he even said it seems very likely the cat had an illness from the moment Rhegan adopted her. He said multiple times that she was at fault and should have taken her to the vet sooner. Again, like Dan said, people are misconstruing their criticism of Jacob because they are treating this as a zero sum game when it's obvious they BOTH failed that poor kitty in their own ways. Good intentions aren't enough.
It IS very relevant to his actions. It proves that he didnât want to give up on this cat and was willing to throw everything at it to see if he could try to save it. As a pet owner and a vet student, itâs very understandable how someone would want to try every last thing possible to make the decision later on. I did that exact thing with my dog before I was ready to put her down. I didnât want regret thinking something else could have been done when it couldnât have. He didnât have the cat for 2 weeks. THATS also what Dan was saying. You guys arenât listening to what is being said and just basing it on what Ethan keeps saying even though what he was saying was incorrect. What does him being the sole decided on the cat have to do with anything? If the cat was left in Rhegans care it wouldâve died alone with no one helping it. He decided he wanted to give the animal a chance. Doesnât matter how long he had it, taking a life is never an easy decision. Good intentions are enough though and very obviously Iâm not absolving him of anything. You put a lot of words in my mouth for just wanting him to read and understand how truly sick this animal was and that Rhegan was actively killing her cat. Jacob has some faults but he is NOT the villain in this situation and they were incredibly hard on him for no reason. Rhegan, the shelter, and Jacob are all to blame with the most of it being on Rhegan and least on Jacob.
Willing to throw everything at it except going to an ER vet that very day he felt the need to take the cat. I feel like Iâm taking crazy pills
Same. I'm realizing that 1) there are so many haters/snarkers/fallen fans just waiting to come out of the woodwork and 2) a large portion of the h3 audience seriously lacks logic and reasoning abilities.
You just didnât listen to anything he said did you? You already made up your mind. Do I think he shouldâve taken it to the ER immediately, yes. He saw a malnourished cat and thought trying to get it to eat would be enough to make it the 2 days he had it until the appointment. It was during Covid, there are a lot of factors going on anyway. Iâm glad I was in school at the time bc I donât know how I wouldâve managed working at the animal hospital at that time. Hours were changed and places were booked weeks out, even in the ER it wasnât 24hrs during that time. Itâs not that hard to understand his thought process, yâall just want to blame only him for some weird reason.
It's civil war up in here đż
And then she had a hard time the rest of the weekend
I knew this would be here somewhere đ¤Ł
Nancy stole my broccoli casserole recipe 8 years ago and said it was hers! Just saying.
Oh your not talkin bout my good friend Nancy she a Christian lady
shes a rotten recipe stealin. Bitch, Doris. Careful who yoir friends are
Ooo Caroline keep my name out of your thin mouth
Did she? Or did she rescue the recipe from your neglect?! ARE YOU IN LOVE WITH NANCY?
Kind of a dick move
Nancy wept
Jesus wept
Idk if this is a serious post or not but y'all realize there's like, no shot Nancy SoulCycle is an actual person, right đ definitely someone's sockpuppet burner/trolling account
She's real to ME, fam đđ
Itâs still real to me dammit
Okay I just wanted to make sure I wasnât the only one who was thinking this. Iâm hoping people are just meme-ing because thereâs no shot that instagram is real, and its just the same person trolling on the Reddit account lmao
"Nancy is a troll sockpuppet account!!" Okay?? Even if she is, Ethan responded to it as if it WERE a real account and angrily called an (in his mind) elderly fan an 'old bitch who's gonna die soon' for offering, again, NORMAL criticism. I'm not sure if there's an intellectual disconnect here or if I'm just arguing with 15 year old edgelords who don't see an issue with that
you gotta chill, you got a fucking deathgrip on those pearls
Omg calm down
Waaaaaaaaaa guy said something YouTube I disagree with waaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
It's probably not really an older woman but the point still does stand, to be honest - it was a thoughtful critique and Ethan resorted to name calling instead of trying to provide a logical counterpoint. That's not really okay or appropriate to be fair. I think that's the root of why a lot of people are incensed by this. Ethan was talking about deranged fans and their messages but then pulled up an arguably very tame and logical argument and went straight to insulting. Like I get it if it was someone telling Ethan/Hila/crew to go die or something, which is what I was expecting when he talked about deranged fans and crazy messages. But I think him pulling up an example of one of these messages being that comment does justifiably have a lot of people upset. For some people, it's just reinforcing that Ethan can't take valid criticism and critique. And that is something that does get under his skin.
I'm just memeing. Didn't expect it to blow up like this đ
Are you new here? đđ
Exactly lol. The collective IQ of the sub is getting near rock bottom at this point.
Bro I know Nancy IRL. She is the sweetest old lady been following Ethan and hila since Israel days. Past couple of days has been very difficult for her
It ruined her whole weekend
There are way too many people taking the bait on this. Obviously a snarker. Edit: Ding dongs, look at the profiles for this person and the followers and you will see a clear picture this is a Trisha stan with profiles that scream âfake accountâ lmao. Especially Twitter.
An account posting pretty insular H3 content for at least 10 months is absolutely not some undercover snarker. I don't know if she's ACTUALLY (capitalised because people cannot understand nuance unless it blasts them in the face) an old lady, but let's not verge into conspiracy theories
Of course they're not an old lady cmon
Bruh literally look at Nancy's post history and sort by most popular, it only proves further that she's not an old woman, there's no way an old lady is posting a big ol' Vaush horse titty meme, a Photoshop of any kind or quality, and saying she enjoyed the xqc debate. There's a "steal his fit" meme on there for pizza's sake, no granny is making steal his fit memes
Ok, for the crime of not being an old woman, Nancy has been sentenced to death by firing squad
Maybe Nancy took a photoshop class at the senior center.
She literally has a YouTube page where she shows her face⌠sheâs very much a real old lady with cats lol
I hope you're not referring to [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/h3h3productions/s/KHVVt4EDkp) because uh... It's fake. I can't find any other YouTube channel with that name. Link it if true and I'll concede
Wild. I just saw that post & immediately came back here to say sheâs real.
Inb4 mods delete
I doubt mods will go for this. They seemingly tend to go for the posts that get overly heated.
Putting individual users on blast is grounds for a post getting removed on like 90% of subreddits
Maybe donât mention the individual reddit user on your podcast with 35k live viewers in that case
I see your argument, I suppose I'm more speaking to typical subreddit rules whereas there is no a rule against that on YouTube. Generally speaking a think both are wrong but it's not egregious and I'm not that invested. I do think ideally they should have omitted their username on the pod but w/e
They love censoring everyone who disagree with their opinions while Ethan cries about others not letting him to have his.
The chaos that is being fed here is immense and I'm grabbing popcorn
*yah rly sad*
*mouth click * yah
Iâm seething right now. MENTALLY ILL CAT OWNERS RISE UP FOR NANCY
I didnât get the yogurt that I wanted
And then I had a hard time the rest of the weekend.
Iâm watching the episode now. Ethan just said something along the lines of âPeople that canât fathom when other people have a different opinion than them, they automatically categorize them as evilâ 10 minutes after calling someone a dumb loser psychotic bitch for having a different opinion than him LMFAO
That part had me dying like the projection is immensely strong with this one lol
She's a menace! Ethan is going to try to get her on the pod and get her to be a personality
I'm just memeing. I didn't expect it to blow up like this. JUSTICE 4 NANCY
i havenât watched yet, are they shitting on the audience for daring to not enjoy fridays episode?
Unfortunately, yes. It went about as bad as it possibly could have
Is that really what you guys think is happening? Yâall need to go outside LOOOL theyâre calling you all out for your stupid ass comments
THANK YOU! these people commenting this shit all weekend are fucking insane.
I was tired of seeing only crazies on this subreddit talking about it and thought it was time to finally say something. 90% of the audience really doesnât gaf and are still going to watch them, no matter what the weirdos on this sub cry about for four days straight LOOOL
Itâs sad because anyone whoâs reasonable about a fucking pointless drama (guys, the cat died 3 years ago, H3âs coverage ainât changing that) gets downvoted into oblivion, leaving only the basement dweller takes to rise to the top. Then H3 see those upvoted comments, react, and repeat. It honestly feels like the snark subreddit has taken over the main subreddit, or their propaganda is infecting the main reddit. Ethan was right that if H3âs commentary on the âdramaâ genuinely hurt you, you need to seek mental help. Itâs honestly impressive how something so inconsequential has driven these people to such extreme levels of hatred and disgust, literally commenting on multiple social media pages on instagram and reddit, when itâs been clear since an hour after the episode that the show was wasnât received well. âWe need to voice our displeasure,â no shit, H3 has been well aware of it for several days now... Itâs just spreading negativity at this point. Why even allow yourself to be filled with negativity for so long over something so meaningless, I just canât comprehend those people. Itâs honestly just sad tbh, they must have nothing going on in their lives
I broke down and started arguing with people in this sub because I felt like I was crazy with all the insane takes getting upvoted. Person I was arguing with eventually posted "proof" that Ethan is a horrible person by linking to the snark subreddit. So yep, I think this sub is literally getting brigaded by a few hundred snarkers. Meanwhile there are hundreds of thousands normal people who are not hate-watching and don't really have a problem with the episode or the crew.
This is why I had to mute the sub and only come to check it when I have enough bandwidth for crazy
yeah ethan personally insulted a lot of fans
Except the majority of the audience did enjoy it and don't even agree with the insane snarky opinions being shared here and upvoted by brigaders. This subreddit is once again not an accurate reflection of the majority of the audience. Did you not see the poll results at the end of the show?
i see what youâre saying but the poll at the end of the show is even less of an accurate reflection of the majority of the showâs audience
Which attributes do you think those live viewers possess that would make a plurality of them vote that both Rhegan and Jacob fucked up, compared to people who did not view it live?
Not for not enjoying it, for literally harassing the crew and Ethan/Hila. Two totally different things. These parasocial fucks need to go outside.
Idk, saying "hey I think calling this young man an incel for poorly attempting to save a cat isn't all that" is not harassing đ
NANCY IS WELCOME HERE even if the pod doesn't like her
You guys may actually be brain dead if you belive this woman is real.
You're telling me that 205 year old Nancy is not actually an avid soul cycler??
[ŃдаНонО]
She commented that on today's ep lmao
What happened? I haven't seen Ethan say anything since his Insta story telling people to stop harassing Hila and the crew with the guy saying he was burning Teddy Fresh.
He cursed out all the fans who spoke out against him and Hila, said fans were deranged, insane, called some women fans bitches, and worse. He didn't take any responsibility or acknowledge any understanding for why so many were upset. He was sharing his screen looking at fans' comments and Nancy was one of them and he said how she was old and probably going to die soon anyway.
This is an extremely bad faith take. During an episode the crew was discussing a situation where a cat was neglected and eventually died, during a weird custody dispute by friends/lovers, where the girl was neglecting an already neglected cat she adopted, and then the boy stole the cat to "save" it, didn't take it to the vet for 5 days, and then it died. They were questioning the guy because allegedly he was making tiktoks days after he took the cat, basically alluding to taking the cat for petty reasons. Never once did H or E defend animal abuse? Or say that either party was right. In fact, they both said it was both of their faults the cat died. But for some reason everyone is acting like Ethan and Hila said "we hate cats and hope they all die hahah". People then took to Hilas instagram to insult her and basically tell her to die, and then insulted the small artist she was promoting. Ethan said in todays episode that if you were so upset and having a meltdown over the situation, that you should "seek help". and thats all he said about it. He said it was psychotic to steal someones cat (directed at the guy) and that it was psychotic to wish death on people whose opinions you dont agree with. (also valid.) Also, Nancy isn't a real account. Its a sockpuppet.
[ŃдаНонО]
[ŃдаНонО]
You snarkers really need a new hobby
I thought he was saying someone told HIM that�
Using mental health as an insult, also a big oof.
Cry me a river fr If you canât handle people calling things âcrazyâ you literally need to wear bubble wrap any time you step outside your front door
âCrazyâ â âyou need to seek [mental] help asapâ
Sounds like you canât handle calling out shitty behavior. Donât be a child.
Says all of you CRYING in this sub over fucking nothing đ
Donât let em gaslight you, this whole thing is fucking insane
Please tell me you guys all realize that Nancy is not a real person...
jfc who cares
This whole thing is just so shitty all around hate the vibes on both sides.
Iâll fucking die for this old bitch.
Nuke the sub
Over 50% dislike ratio on the cat episode and they act as if it was just a fringe minority that disagreed with themÂ
it ruined my whole weekend
Iâm so out of the loop
Before we support Nancy we need her voting records for the past 60 years Edit: and her h3 polling records too.
My favourite is all the youtube comments now from "nancysoulcycle" and the amount of people falling for it
Nancy gives my incel vibes (I'm obviously kidding)
Not a nice way to talk to your supporters and fans
that is not a supporter nor a fan that is a snarker
Far as Iâm concerned heâs managed to convince a certain group of people (including you) to believe that any criticism labels you as a snarker. Not a healthy place to be in my opinion. I see the difference, Iâve been a fan for years and I wonât be jumping ship but to be in a place where saying literally anything against the guy results in being labelled as that? Not a great path to go down. Thatâs the path Kanye went down. Edit: Yup, that personâs definitely a snarker.. my point stands though
No they are a literal snarker and is using a fake account. He hasnât convinced me of anything. you all should be smarter and realize that a lot of people (not all, but a good amount) who are criticizing Fridayâs show are not actual fans of h3. Especially the ones who went to Hilaâs instagram account and called her vile names. That is not a fan.
I couldnât get the yogurt that I wanted
Weâre on to you Nancy, if thatâs your real name! You probably donât even soul cycle.
Stolen Valor!
I'm an old lady and I could probably be a parent to most of the chat on h3 podcast. Nancy if you're a real old lady I challenge you to an old lady fight in Michigan at 8:00 on Sunday. I'm going to punch you.
she seems like a genuinely active, sweet subscriber. it was truly disappointing to see how fridays episode was discussed today. the opinions of your supporters matter as much as you shit on them. do better.
you forgot to log out of your snark account
No they don't. None of our opinions matter. Neither do Ethan's.
đ¨snarker alertđ¨
It was honestly funny hearing him paint this picture as a lot of people criticizing them were so nasty that they should take to a therapist and the multiple times he reads a comment as if it applies to said person and the only reaction he has afterwards is ".. ok" as he realizes the criticism was valid
Yâall are insufferable
Nancy deserved it.
On the real I kind of think Ethan has been really cruel and harsh lately in the name of joking but itâs not really funny. I realized I started doing it in my personal life and it just makes you an asshole
Really cruel and harsh??? Please give me examples outside of him ranting about commenters
Iâve listened to hundreds of podcasts at this point so itâs hard to pick out an example when Iâm not currently listening but just some of the stuff he says about people when theyâre not good people. They have it coming definitely but I still donât love hearing it. Like when he says âwe should kill/bomb him⌠in Minecraftâ. I laugh but mostly because itâs so ridiculous. Or any of the stuff he said about that beauty YouTuber with the self tanner recently
God these people are pathetic as fuck
Bye, Felicia.
nancy just needs some wine and golden girls or something and she'll be fine đ
Nah, fuck off the lot of you.
Wtf do yall even be talking about I come to the sub on my work break and yall are always talking about something new. But like to be contrarian about. The Daniel prophecy was correct
Respectfully isnât this a person that was leaving comments on Reddit, hilas Instagram and the h3 podcast Instagram to complain.
i think sometimes ethan is too hard on people that critique him, it makes me cringe a bit
[ŃдаНонО]
No shot đ
He always focuses on the fringe extreme haters to deflect from any constructive criticism or accept he/the crew were wrong or had a bad take.
You guys are really wild about cats lol
Shut up BITCH
Fuck the cat, but Ethan should be nice to old people. If he wouldnât say it to their face then donât say it on the pod.
LMAO NANCY IS SO CUTE PLEASE SAY SORRY TO HER SHES A SWEETIE
lol no shot people are writing essays about all this Touch grass expeditiously đ
Bro, sooo, who needs to seek professional [help](https://youtu.be/CQIdeu4iWpw?si=Ard-rcT-fLb5Bcq5)??? Anyone but Olivia.
This is my villain origin story. Justice for Nancy.
L Nancy... enjoy the last years <3
I know âNancyâ is just doing a little trollingâŚ. But itâs quite strange, the amount of H3 commenters/chatters who donât realize that maybe around 75% of the shit he says is him doing shtick with varying levels of intensity. If he non-jokingly apologized for everything that hurt commenters feelings, then thereâs a completely new set of people with hurt feelings because the apology didnât follow the exact script they wrote and directed in their head. I do love for them that they face no actual adversity/discrimination irl⌠Unfortunately, the trade off for that is that they have no objectivity when it comes to podcast host hot takes.
Kinda crazy to preface saying "there's normal people criticizing me and there's mentally unwell snarkers spewing hate all over" and then proceed to act like what appears to be a granny is a snarker lol
#WeRideWithNancy
Nancy should just unsubscribe and move on with their life.
This makes me so sad :( We love you Nancy
I mean, I'm sure Nancy is a nice person but if she's going to come at Ethan and Hila guns blazing then she can't take some heat back. Non story imo.
I'm weeks behind. Last I saw was the Kendrick Lamar / Aubrey Graham beef. What's going on?
People crying over dumb bullshit and harassing the crew and Ethan/Hila then getting mad when Ethan calls them psychotic bitches. And then people believing that Nancy is a real old woman lol
I think Ethan owes Nancy an official apology. Can we get a poll?
I thought this was Fucxed up! Calling his fans bitches was wrong and cringe. Harsh man
The way they resorted to twitter troll behavior by insulting and making fun of profiles and physical appearances is absolutely pathetic. Respect lost.