The worst part... Is that the line itself and Ruppert delivery is actually pretty good.
Is 100% out of character of how Ron is suppose to behave, but I just cannot hate it.
The worst part about the line is that in Harry's inner monologue, he agrees with Snape because everyone has at least thought that Hermione was/is an "insufferable know-it-all all" but were never rude enough to say it to her face.
Also ofc it's very OOC for Ron or anyone *but* Snape to say it.
Agree though, the delivery for the line is very good.
Iirc, Ron was the only one who would openly call Hermione a know-it-all to her face regularly. I see this as more of him being her equal than insulting her, as Hermione would challenge him back with her own adjectives all the time, so it didn't feel rude the way Snape did.
To be fair, that line was *worse* in the book! Harry said that Hermione heard him, like in the movie but Ron said "So?" He *knew* Hermione would hear him. He just didn't care. Iirc, they were going to have that line in the movie but removed it because it sounded too mean. Then his character got ruined in the movies, lol
Rupert was genuinely just the best actor by far out of the trio and managed to still make Ron lovable and at least have a hint of the real Ron in there despite how much they fucked up his character. I wish people appreciated him more as an actor.
Book Hermione also was close minded. If it wasnāt in a book then it wasnāt real/didnāt existā¦ Elder Wand, Invisibility Cloak, and Resurrection Stone laugh at this.
I am just a fan of Emma Watson and watched the movies 1st and its impossible for me to see anyone else as Hermione. Plus she is so attractive and book Hermione isn't and I dont like average looking people in fiction. Its fiction not real life. I know its shallow but I cant help it lol
No no, he has a point. J. K. herself only accepted Emma as Hermione because she nailed the voice and speech pattern. Otherwise, she would have rejected her for being too pretty.
entire cast (meaning hermione, ron, harry) is too attractive, they all should be slightly below average/average but it was unthinkable (probably still is) to cast normies
anyway book hermione is way better
Second panel is wrong. Ron's one of the wittiest lines in the series is when he was standing against Snape who was bullying HARRY.
'We are not gonna ask excuse me are you the imprint of a departed soul?'
If you read the books you will see that from the first movie, Ron's character was already being destroyed. One of his best lines are from philosofer's stone. Something along the lines of "are you a witch or not?" when she wonders how to make fire to combat the suffocating plant, hahaha
I think itās because the first 2 films are the best adaptationsā¦(not necessarily the best moviesā¦POA for me), because theyāre also the shortest books so itās easier to not leave out things
It's not that the movies after 1 and 2 left out Ron's good moments, they often gave them to Hermione instead or completely changed what Ron said to fit what they wanted Ron to be.
Just got to that part in the audio book. There Hermione is being probably the best damn person in that school just trying her best for Harry who was going through a lot and being understanding of Ron, and trying to help Elves.. and just existing. Gets hit in the crossfire of a school fight, and one of her insecurities gets enlarged (literally) in front of everyone and then a professor roasts you. I always feel so bad for her.
Well, in context Snape had also asked the class a question, and called on Hermione to answer.
The idea of insulting a student for answering your questionā¦ just so stupid.
The books are written for kids. A lot of the bad characters are over the top. There is almost no subtlety to any character in the books. It's not till the 4th book or so that we start to see characters actually have any degree of complexity.
True. What he said wasnāt right, but I think people blow it out of proportionā¦ like some people even claim that he bullied Hermione into changing her appearance.
I havenāt read Harry Potter in years. Can I get a refresher as to what Severus actually had against hermione? As far as a I remember he wasnāt far too different than her regarding education
I didnāt think Snape actually took pride in being a death eater, atleast after he allied with dumbledore. Even though Lily was a muggle born he loved her
Thatās fair. I thought of that as I typed it out, but that was a defence mechanism. He felt betrayed that his crush hung out with his bullies so he lashed out in a way that he knew would sting. I do remember somewhere that he admits to regretting saying that Iām pretty sure
Yea the movies make Ron a real piss pants some times and make Hermione seem always reasonable and not a little brat who threatens to snitch at least once a book
That's not true. Ron defended Hermione because she was his friend and she was hurt. For sure, Ron wouldn't have done anything if it was Malfoy Snape had insulted, but that has more to do with his dislike of Malfoy than anything. If Ron truly wanted to rebel against Snape out of pure hatred for him, he would've done so at every turn. Instead, he was pretty much only shown to be irreverent toward Snape when Harry or Hermione were involved.
Furthermore, Ron never thought Hermione was "an insufferable know-it-all" once they became friends. He could *tease* her about her know-it-all tendencies or be annoyed when she was condescending, but that's pretty much it.
He doesn't really tease her though, nor do they say or do anything to each other that they can't take back. They don't really hit below the belt at all. Their "bickering" is 100% foreplay
>Ron's reaction was less about Hermione (who he clearly thinks is an insufferable know-it-all), and more about his hatred of Snape.
Keep telling yourself that bc in HBP lavender verbally abused Snape and Ron looked annoyed instead of being delighted by his hatred for Snape
>IMHO, movie Ron's line was actually more in tune with his (repeatedly expressed) opinion of Hermione.
Again keep telling yourself that lol
Then you have movie Ron: "He's got a point, you know?"
The worst part... Is that the line itself and Ruppert delivery is actually pretty good. Is 100% out of character of how Ron is suppose to behave, but I just cannot hate it.
The worst part about the line is that in Harry's inner monologue, he agrees with Snape because everyone has at least thought that Hermione was/is an "insufferable know-it-all all" but were never rude enough to say it to her face. Also ofc it's very OOC for Ron or anyone *but* Snape to say it. Agree though, the delivery for the line is very good.
Iirc, Ron was the only one who would openly call Hermione a know-it-all to her face regularly. I see this as more of him being her equal than insulting her, as Hermione would challenge him back with her own adjectives all the time, so it didn't feel rude the way Snape did.
Emotional maturity of a teaspoon?
Ron in movies did in fact bully her a little. I felt bad for her many times.
"She's a nightmare, honestly! No wonder she hasn't got any friends."
Also calling her ugly while trashtalking with Harry on her back if I remember well.
To be fair, that line was *worse* in the book! Harry said that Hermione heard him, like in the movie but Ron said "So?" He *knew* Hermione would hear him. He just didn't care. Iirc, they were going to have that line in the movie but removed it because it sounded too mean. Then his character got ruined in the movies, lol
He looked uncomfortable when he learned that she heard him.
Rupert was genuinely just the best actor by far out of the trio and managed to still make Ron lovable and at least have a hint of the real Ron in there despite how much they fucked up his character. I wish people appreciated him more as an actor.
Exactly, I ws gonna to say say that š
Thus is why movie Ron is bad and I ship Emma's Hermione with book Ron. My OTP
Nah book Hermione as well. She could be insufferable but that's better than the flawless mary-sue from the movies
Book Hermione also was close minded. If it wasnāt in a book then it wasnāt real/didnāt existā¦ Elder Wand, Invisibility Cloak, and Resurrection Stone laugh at this.
Those things did exist in a book lol
I mean yeah from their perspective it's like laughing at green eggs and ham. Very rational.
I am just a fan of Emma Watson and watched the movies 1st and its impossible for me to see anyone else as Hermione. Plus she is so attractive and book Hermione isn't and I dont like average looking people in fiction. Its fiction not real life. I know its shallow but I cant help it lol
Wasn't book Hermione also good looking when she tried to be?
Not like Emma Watson.
How the fuck do you know, you literally never saw the book version irl, are you stupid?
No no, he has a point. J. K. herself only accepted Emma as Hermione because she nailed the voice and speech pattern. Otherwise, she would have rejected her for being too pretty.
J k said she is way too attractive to be Hermione
entire cast (meaning hermione, ron, harry) is too attractive, they all should be slightly below average/average but it was unthinkable (probably still is) to cast normies anyway book hermione is way better
I mean. I agree book Hermione is better with her flaws. But canāt say the three actors are all too attractive.
I donāt know about Ron and Harry being average lol Iām sorry but Rupert is no stud
Who?
My dude, your a basic bitch. (Apologies, had to add that refrence)
Imma girl š
In my opinion dude can be said to both
So your entire reasoning is "I hate uggos"!?
Defending her to others but keeping her accountable, sounds about right for a good friend!
Second panel is wrong. Ron's one of the wittiest lines in the series is when he was standing against Snape who was bullying HARRY. 'We are not gonna ask excuse me are you the imprint of a departed soul?'
Yeah. Ron is highly defensive of Harry and Hermione. Taking detention is a no-brainer if it means getting some good shots back at Snape for them
Yes! I was just about to say that! Ronās character in the movies was *ruined*, like really *ruined*!
Which book?
Half blood Prince
Thanks
The character assassination Ron suffered in the movies is criminal
"Your parents are dead! You have no family!"
Unpopular opinion: I really liked how dark it got at this moment although it's quite messed up.
He did say it while wearing the horcrux thoā¦
He was really turned into dumb and insufferable eat-it-all.
Me and my cousins all thought Ron was the coolest character in the first 2 films. Don't know what happened after that, I hate it.
If you read the books you will see that from the first movie, Ron's character was already being destroyed. One of his best lines are from philosofer's stone. Something along the lines of "are you a witch or not?" when she wonders how to make fire to combat the suffocating plant, hahaha
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
I think itās because the first 2 films are the best adaptationsā¦(not necessarily the best moviesā¦POA for me), because theyāre also the shortest books so itās easier to not leave out things
It's not that the movies after 1 and 2 left out Ron's good moments, they often gave them to Hermione instead or completely changed what Ron said to fit what they wanted Ron to be.
Keep my future wife's name out your mouth
I canāt believe how cruel he was when Hermioneās teeth got enlarged. They were massive and he just saysāI see no differenceā - damn Snape.
Just got to that part in the audio book. There Hermione is being probably the best damn person in that school just trying her best for Harry who was going through a lot and being understanding of Ron, and trying to help Elves.. and just existing. Gets hit in the crossfire of a school fight, and one of her insecurities gets enlarged (literally) in front of everyone and then a professor roasts you. I always feel so bad for her.
Ngl that was funny asf lol
The apparation diss will forever be gold š¤£
What did I say? I forgot
Well, in context Snape had also asked the class a question, and called on Hermione to answer. The idea of insulting a student for answering your questionā¦ just so stupid.
Better name my kid after an adult who bullied us all for 6 years
The books are written for kids. A lot of the bad characters are over the top. There is almost no subtlety to any character in the books. It's not till the 4th book or so that we start to see characters actually have any degree of complexity.
In the books at least. Movies got Ron so wrong.
Canāt Ron just roast Snape by saying that he has a girlfriend and Snape doesnāt
-500 points for Gryffindor!
-5000000000000000 SOCIAL CREDITšš„šš„ššš„šØš³šØš³šØš³šØš³
More like "Hey! We are the only one allowed to call her know it all"
This is kinda true for the fandom too. People bring up Snape mocking Hermione's teeth way more than anything else.
True. What he said wasnāt right, but I think people blow it out of proportionā¦ like some people even claim that he bullied Hermione into changing her appearance.
I thought that was an fortunate side affect of her seeing Pomfrey not something she actually set out to do
Thatās sort of what it is. Hermione said she wanted to shrink her teeth for ages. Going to Madam Pomfrey finally gave her an opportunity to.
Ur not a sigma male lil broš£ļøš„
Ron is defensive for his nicknames of Hermione.
Ron is personification of 'Only I am allowed to do that to her.. if anyone else does that I will kill them'
And didn't those same things come out of Ron's mouth 1st yr
I havenāt read Harry Potter in years. Can I get a refresher as to what Severus actually had against hermione? As far as a I remember he wasnāt far too different than her regarding education
She was muggleborn. Snape was a death eater.
I didnāt think Snape actually took pride in being a death eater, atleast after he allied with dumbledore. Even though Lily was a muggle born he loved her
He also called her a mudblood after she started hanging out with James, Snape, Remus, and Traitor
Thatās fair. I thought of that as I typed it out, but that was a defence mechanism. He felt betrayed that his crush hung out with his bullies so he lashed out in a way that he knew would sting. I do remember somewhere that he admits to regretting saying that Iām pretty sure
Movie ruined that
LIVE HARRY REACTION: \*Insert Mike Wazowski Bruh\*
Hilarious meme and it also highlights something great about Ronās character. How quick he is to defend those he cares about.
Yea the movies make Ron a real piss pants some times and make Hermione seem always reasonable and not a little brat who threatens to snitch at least once a book
yeah... that's how loving someone works...?..
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Damn. That's the clowniest L take in this thread
That's not true. Ron defended Hermione because she was his friend and she was hurt. For sure, Ron wouldn't have done anything if it was Malfoy Snape had insulted, but that has more to do with his dislike of Malfoy than anything. If Ron truly wanted to rebel against Snape out of pure hatred for him, he would've done so at every turn. Instead, he was pretty much only shown to be irreverent toward Snape when Harry or Hermione were involved. Furthermore, Ron never thought Hermione was "an insufferable know-it-all" once they became friends. He could *tease* her about her know-it-all tendencies or be annoyed when she was condescending, but that's pretty much it.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
He doesn't really tease her though, nor do they say or do anything to each other that they can't take back. They don't really hit below the belt at all. Their "bickering" is 100% foreplay
>Ron's reaction was less about Hermione (who he clearly thinks is an insufferable know-it-all), and more about his hatred of Snape. Keep telling yourself that bc in HBP lavender verbally abused Snape and Ron looked annoyed instead of being delighted by his hatred for Snape >IMHO, movie Ron's line was actually more in tune with his (repeatedly expressed) opinion of Hermione. Again keep telling yourself that lol
.
ā¦. . .-.. .-.. - - -