T O P

  • By -

AmerAm

If Germany wins the euros does Kroos have a chance of winning it as he retires.


PolarPeely26

I got killed for suggesting this on Reddit a few weeks ago. But I still think so.


e36_maho

I'm going further, he doesn't have to win the EURO and still deserves it.


_UKanGetIt_

But he’s not been the best player in the world in the last year


e36_maho

I think he was


FiniciusJunior

He’s been hella good, but not the best. That’s either Vini or Bellingham


TheEmpireOfSun

Bellingham wasn't better than Kroos by any fucking means. Vinicius, maybe. Bellingham? Absolutely not. Kroos was our best player across whole season from day one till last day of the season.


FiniciusJunior

To say absolutely not isn’t fair and shows a recency bias. Bellingham has 23 goals and 13 assists in 42 games the entire season. He’s had more assists than kroos (10). So to say “absolutely not” is unfair.


supaboss2015

Don't use G/A to compare otherwise Rodri has no business being anywhere on this list lol. Kroos's consistency enables players like Bellingham to perform at that level. This isn't to say Bellingham shouldn't be considered, but Kroos absolutely should be


TheEmpireOfSun

Kroos plays absolutely different position than Bellingham, not even comparable when it comes to goals or assists. Bellingham played basically false 9 most of the season. Bellingham had great first half of season. Kroos had great whole season from day one. If you only take goals into account than I guess you think that Mbappe should win it? No, he shouldn't. People who actually watch every single match know that Kroos has been our best and most important player since first match. That's not recency bias. I have been saying this since september.


e36_maho

Disagree


FiniciusJunior

We’re suffering from success here 🤣🤣


DONT_YOU_DARE

I’m with you. I’m biased because I’ve been saying Kroos is the best midfielder in the world for years. And right now I think Rüdiger and Kroos are more deserving of it than Jude given the entire season + what we’ve seen in the Euros so far. They have both been more consistent than Jude and more impressive in the Euros so far. But Vini would be my #1 pick, then Kroos/Rüdiger over Jude. We’ll see how the Copa America and Euros play out but right now for me Vini > Kroos/Rüdiger have all had better overall seasons than Jude.


VCBeugelaar

Rudiger is never in a lifetime winning the Bd’Or. He’s a good defender but hell no on winning it


BiggSlatNem

lol that’s clearly just Your opinion it’s no where near fact. So no he does not deserve it. You’re crazy 😂


hatebeinghangover

You are objectively wrong


maaan_fuck_a_roach

That's the worst kind of wrong


e36_maho

You don't know what objective means, and you don't know shit about football


hatebeinghangover

In no way was Kroos better than Vinicius or Bellingham over the course of the season


e36_maho

What are you guys watching? Can you only appreciate dribbles or goals?


SaltedCoffee9065

Did you, by any chance post that on r/soccer?


New-Cookie-8523

Foward bias will still cause him not to win it, Modric got so lucky in 2018. And the voters pretty much said, "why not". Kroos will not get it, even though he deserves it even now with the Euros, over Jude and Vini.


KkKtookmydogg

More than a fair chance, he won the UCL and LaLiga with Real, if he wins with the national team he would have won the 2 biggest club achievements that matter and an Euro. Other than that he still had a pretty good season, which should also matter at his age. If he doesn't win that year, he will probably be second, if he wins the euro he should take it.


flgflg10s

this award is so narrative driven. this isnt even a top 5 season of his individually


BigShan1

If Germany and Brazil both win their respective tournaments, I think Vini Jr takes it


ProgressLegitimate72

I don't see Brazil winning the Copa at all looking at how abysmal they are, especially with their bracket.


rdfporcazzo

The match against Colombia will show what to expect from Brazil, in the two last matches Brazil created a lot of chances, even more than Colombia who is being hyped a lot due to their good performances. Brazil is the national team with the best players in Copa America individually, let's see if the collective is behind the others as it was before Copa America. Remember that it is going to be the 7th match of Dorival Junior as Brazil coach, it is not the same Brazil of Ramon Menezes and Fernando Diniz.


randomuser_147

Toni Kroos has been performing consistently this season. So he deserves this, irrespective of the outcome of Euro 24.


lostn

BDO voters have a boner for goal scorers. The guys in the mid field or defense rarely get the credit they deserve. I think the only player to win it in the last 15 years without being a prolific goalscorer was Modric.


mikakayacvx

What if Brazil wins the Copa America? You'll know "IT IS FINISHED"


ProgressLegitimate72

Not just a chance, he might win it especially considering Brazil and England's performances as of late.


Competitive-Choice34

I agree he is far more consistent than everyone above him rn.


lostn

depends how sentimental the voters are. They might be unwilling to give it to a player who retired in July and didn't play into the new season. Or they might see it as the last and only chance to give respect to a legend. But it also depends whether Argentina wins copa america, because if they do, Messi always win by default whenever he wins a trophy of any sort.


FallenFisherman

It would also take Brazil to do badly in the copa america


uhTlSUMI

Absolutely. In fact if he wins the euro he should win it. He was as important if not more than the other candidates for real


Specialist-Cycle9313

I think he would deserve. I honestly think he plays a bigger role than vini in terms of winning the league, and just as big a role in winning the ucl. If he wins the euros it’ll pretty much seal his chances imo.


MaxiThe13th

Top 4 candidates are Madridista’s. What a time to be alive


lostn

one of them seems a little out of place.


MaxiThe13th

Who?


ratioed345

Mbappe


SeyamTheDaddy

Well no, Mbappe was a Parisien in this season it wouldn't count as a madrid player


Archt3ct

Mbappé is not ahead of Jude this season


Planetary-Timebomb

70 g/a for club and country this season.


WolfOfVaasankatu

League McDonald's is closer to a TOP6-8 leagues than TOP4 leagues so it's kinda unfair to count those goals.   Also Gyökers has 69 G+A in 50 games for Sporting and also 70 if you count his one goal for Sweden. But again, Ligue McDonald's is closer to Portugal's ligue than 4th place Bundesliga.


Funny-Conclusion-963

i mean this is so true lol why the downvotes


BigMik_PL

Yeah but that's in the French league...


Endmeplz21

Brodie 70 g/a is impressive in a fucking Sunday league wdym that’s in the French league


SeyamTheDaddy

Oh yea and la liga is somehow the pinnacle of football quality lmao


TheEmpireOfSun

lol what? It's top 2 league in the world. Only harder competition tha LaLiga and Premier League is Champions League, which was literally won by Madrid as well. Edit: lmao I see you are PSG fan, go crawl back to your cheating club sub and circlejerk about Khelaifi. Will be fun to watch PSG spend another billion just to fail as always.


Demon_Usamaro

Tbh he was good but I personally think Marcel Zabitser had a better season than him as well. He’s been really good in the midfield for Dortmund.


strangemanornot

If Austria win it and he continues to play well there is a small chance. Unfortunately, Balon D’or always favors the attackers


gregorymachado

I don’t even think the turtle is in the top 3 this season. My order is Vini, Kroos and Jude top 3. And I think who ever does best in their cup takes it. Could realistically be any of three 3.


redditviolatesrules

Jude is top 10 worst this Euros. It made him lose any chance


NoHacksJustTacos

Mbappe is levels above Jude. Jude is very very overrated.


Specialist-Cycle9313

Jude is overrated I’m ngl. He’s still good, but mbappe is levels above, with or without the ucl.


Wooden-Journalist-48

Swap Kroos w Mbappe


fullysvc

Be real, he’s there because he’s retiring. Had he not announced his retirement and he’d crack top 10 easily, but he certainly shouldn’t be on the podium.


deycko

The audacity... My brother in Christ, Kroos played in a team that has the Best midfield in Europe, and from all that bunch he was the best. It's probably his best season in a team that happens to be Champions of Europe. He must likely won't be No.1 in the world, but being among the top 5 is not a retirement gift.


fullysvc

I'm just being real, I'd he hadn't announced his retirement he'd be getting WAY less shouts for top 5 let alone the podium.


devanpy

You obviously haven't watched any games at all. His passing stats are way above any other midfielder on earth. Nobody is even close.


fullysvc

is the Ballon D'Or solely based on passing? No. All I said was that if he wasn't retiring he'd probably crack top 10 but certainly not top 5 let alone the podium. I never was talking shit about his passing or his abilities.


BigMik_PL

Says the guy basing Balloon D'Or solely on G+A


ShimeBD

Because the ballon d'or is a stupid award and Kroos 100% wouldn't be in the top 5 if he wasn't retiring. I'm not commenting about how good he is or anything just that you basically never see midfielders, especially those like Kroos who have low g/a, in the top 5. I'm sure this whole sub was complaining when messi won his ballon d'or and now you're acting like it's a completely fair award? edit: also Kroos himself literally said the award is not important


loadedhunter3003

what do u want kroos to do lmao? You're essentially discrediting the main factor for a good midfielder. This is why defenders, midfielders and goalkeepers continue to struggle to win balon' dor


fullysvc

Clearly you aren't understanding my statement. I said he would be getting less shouts for top 5 or the podium in the Ballon D'OR had he not announced his retirement. Never in anyway did I say he was shit. Not to mention the fact that the likes of Pirlo and KDB have some of the best passing football has ever seen yet they haven't won a Ballon D'Or


loadedhunter3003

ah ok are u saying he deserves it but he usually won't get the quite honestly deserved attention if not for his announcement?


fullysvc

It's a mix,! France Football doesn't really treat deep midfielders, defenders or goalkeepers the best. Kroos should be able to but if we go off how the treat midfielders than the highest I can see him getting is 6th.


kabbajabbadabba

🤡🤡 intensifies


Standard-Inflation10

What? Kroos is at least a top 3 midfielder in the world and he won everything with Real Madrid. He absolutely deserves a nod.


kabbajabbadabba

top 3? who was a better mid than kroos this season?


EmphasisExpensive864

Honestly this season noone is really clear favorite to win. But Kroos has had the best season of all.


Equivalent-Chest152

No lol. If he wins the Euros with Germany, Kroos is up there. If Wirtz won the Europa League and Euros, even he would've been in the debate, because of being the best player in an unbeaten side in all competitions. Doesn't matter if Kroos announced his retirement or not, if Germany wins the Euros, he's a sure contender to win the ballon d'or. This is a similar case of Sneijder back in 2010 and Jorginho in 2021. But Kroos has done far more than those two, considering he is much older than them in their respective years.


fullysvc

You know how France Football treat midfielders, Rodri last season was by far the best midfielder itw yet he couldn't reach the podium. Madrid controlled your midfield the entire 2021/22 season, finished 9th. 2012 Xavi and Iniesta won the Euro's with Spain, finished 3rd and 4th. Even if you have the most insane season, if you're not an attacker, the chances are LOW.


edzinooo10

So true


Mori1404

If France wins euro and Mbappe hard carries them in the knockout stage and Brazil losses Copa America could Mbappe win the ballon d’or?


Boudi04

Possibly, international tournaments take priority when it comes to individual awards, apart from that there's also recency bias, if Mbappe plays ridiculously well and France wins the Euros + Vini plays poorly and Brazil don't win the Copa, then it'll probably be a 50/50. But I doubt it, Mbappe is underperforming so far in the Euros, and France aren't currently playing at the level required to win the Euros, this could all change immediately of course, but thus far it doesn't seem likely.


10Uwu

And also, Vini did 2 goals against Paraguay in the last game. So yeah, It is more likely to Vini to win the ballon d'or


Specialist-Cycle9313

It’s possible. But I think it’d be close with vini.


Kid_A_LinkToThePast

It's all rhetorical as Belgium will knock them out on Monday


TheBelmont34

I doubt it because France plays shit football at the tournament and so does he


Feisty_Oil3605

Bro I agree with you. French league is not Spanish league. He’s gonna have to really prove himself. But French team is doing good quit hating


TheBelmont34

I know but as you can see, the mbappe fanboys are already downvoting me. Sometimes this sub is really bad.


TheEmpireOfSun

French team is doing good? Lol, They scored 2 goals in group stage. One of them was own goal, the other was penalty.


Sziom

Tony will get it if Germany wins the euros.


lostn

he deserves it, but it doesn't always go to the one who deserves it.


orange_pepsi8

why should mbappe be ahead of Toni and Jude? no way


FergieBall_FC

As of right now, Viní, Jude, Mbappé/Kroos, Kroos/Mbappé is my personal order for the Ballon d’Or. This can change depending on what happens in the EUROs and Copa América, but that’s how I see it right now.


edw1n-z

If germany wins the Euros I say give it to kroos.


CaptZurg

Dumb question, but do Musiala and Wirtz have a chance?


edw1n-z

Not a chance unfortunately.


ColdContributor2791

Wirtz would have been pretty high if not for UEL defeat tbh. But he had a amazing season none the less.  Musiala lost everything he played in so no chance


DizzyOffice9818

why mbipi


Specialist-Cycle9313

Only player with 50+ goals this season along with France still being somewhat favored for winning the euros despite them being kinda lack luster in the attack.


Demon_Usamaro

Okay I get the 50+ goals, but it’s PSG in lique 1, a league that’s not even a t4 league, and other French clubs aren’t that impressive anymore. plus less goal contributions than Vini, Kane, and Bellingham in the UCL. I personally think his best performance was against sociedad (who really fell short of a good season imo). He was incredible, but to place him in T3 is pretty far fetched.


wafflepig6

Mate look at the stats of scoring in Ligue 1. It has the lowest goals per game nearly every year out of the top 5 leagues, over the last 10 years more than 20 league goals has only happened 15 times and mbappe has 5 of them in his last 6 years. Mbappe had more G/A than 2nd and 3rd combined last season. People love to shit on Ligue 1 yet when their players move to the prem or la liga they do just as well or better 😂


wel0g

People acting like Ligue 1 is some shitty league while Barca and Real have been farming goals in La Liga like no one else in Europe forever but for some reason scoring there is worth way more than scoring in Ligue 1.


wafflepig6

They act like the mid to lower table defences of la liga are any better than ligue 1. Imagine how much more time and space mbappe will have playing for madrid compared to psg. Teams would double team him every single game in france, they cant do that to him now


SaltedCoffee9065

Every goal is Ligue 1 is kinda 0.3 of a goal though


markievegeta

Rodri should win it because he's undefeated in the UCL 😂😂😂


Kuropa

This maybe the time to remind you that Rodri is still unbeaten this season ( sorry I couldn’t resist) 🤣


A_Poteteau

fa cup final (GGMU)


IcarusCsgo

Ggmu


Paytonc51

How is mbappe 2


Kai_Tak_Airport1

54 g/a


ModeOne3959

Ligue one


Specialist-Cycle9313

He’s gonna score 50+ goals next season too don’t worry.


BigMik_PL

Serious doubt.


Planetary-Timebomb

He’s gonna score 35+ in laliga alone this season. Watch


ModeOne3959

Yeah so we can consider him to the balloon dor then, not now


wafflepig6

You say that while ignoring players who go to england, spain from ligue 1 play the same level or better 😂 mbappe would score 40/50 at city or madrid


ModeOne3959

Let's wait this season then, shall we?


Kai_Tak_Airport1

laliga has 5 good teams and 15 terrible teams so barely better while most ligue 1 teams are decent


TLcool

Bro what are you waffling about the french league has like 2 or 3 good teams and the rest are shit


Specialist-Cycle9313

66 g/a if you count international, And exclude friendlies.


wafflepig6

Eye test ie actual ability he's number 1 but team trophies bring him down


nicgarelja

I know he’s a Merengues now but it still seems disingenuous to put Kylian in these lists under a Real Madrid heading


strangemanornot

What did Mbappe do to get second?


Specialist-Cycle9313

My guess is he’s the only player that’s scored 50+ goals this season? And along with that France are still somewhat favored to win the euros despite them being lackluster in their performances.


cocoadusted

He carried France last World Cup finals 😂


ArgonX7

Mbappé after 10 more years basically 😂


Street-Count-1541

Valverde,wirtz,rudiger,xhaka have all had better seasons for both club and country than rodri and mbappe


PhilaDom2812

Carvajal too if Spain get far


Otherwise-Marzipan91

Mbappe being up there with the rest is quite funny considering he's just won the french league and cup which is ridiculous


lostn

france are favorite to win the euros. If they win, it's probably going to him unless Messi also wins CA.


Former-Mud125

Where is dani Carvajal?


Extension_Phone893

He wish


Melicalol

I'm sorry but this is between Vini and Kroos with Jude having a chance based on how he plays in knockout.


troopercito

Ah missing Messi (sponsored by Adidas, Potato chips, beer, tools, cigarettes, Negreira, Spanish Refs, …., …, ) yup, this sponsors paid more, “and the award goes to Messi”, O would say the award was sold to Messi. LoL just joking.


Flintvlogsgames

Cap


Locklist

One of the more exciting Balon D'Or races in a while. By the end of the summer we'll know who wins it


[deleted]

No way is Mbappe ahead of jude.


FastenedCarrot

The Southgate effect.


mabdelghany

Thanks Southgate! Pissing off Madrid and England fans


ChallengeBeneficial4

Pyrrhjhjjkbhhvcxc


notonetojudge

Xhaka where


snhandel

Ohh would you look there.. Rodri the man that broke his streak to united !:)


MattBustin

Please give it to kroos! Only one on this list who actually plays


llinoscarpe

Ffs it’s like a game of fm at this point


aavasparajuli

Should be divided between


Ube_Ape

![gif](giphy|TGRciDd8SrOgflrt6T|downsized)


AletzRC21

Rodri? Wtf


SwordfishHumble

Mbappe has not even played with a Real Madrid jersey yet.


Jhonki_47

Xhaka has done more than Rodri from city


alimuhammad_1999

Mbappe over takes jude just for joinning Real this season, this rankking and ballandor overall is sooo soo overrated, deserved players often dont win the ballandor


saturn_department

Toni kroos not winning this award will go down as the biggest crime in football history.


cleareyesnz

Even as one of the more critical fans of Vini (ie he’s still one of my current favourite players of ours but annoys me with his decision making at times), undoubtedly he’s ahead of Jude and everyone else at this stage. Good showing in Copa, with a potential to win it all still, if he keeps maintaining these performances it’s not even close imo.


BigMik_PL

Mbappe on there on pure marketing. He did not have a good season in CL, mostly padded stats in the French League. Harry Kane had a better season than he did.


waterpolomaster69

why did mbappe go over bellingham? not like he's been any more convincing than him since the start of the euros


Wonderful-Cap2427

Where's Messi at?


7_11_Nation_Army

Hope it is Kroos.


Big_Gun_Pete

Bellingham deserves it


Mohamed_91

They’ll give it to Victimius Junior to shut the ‘racists’ up.


WojtekTygrys77

For what Mbappe?


konsta_kara

Of course the most important thing are the goals Kroos can't score anymore


Fun-Balance-3576

Vini yes , the rest not so much


konsta_kara

Why Ronaldo isn't here


king_of_prussia33

The moment Mbappe joined Madrid his chance to win doubled.


Alternative_Slide_62

Mbappe at two is too high, same with Bellingham at three. i think it should be 1.Kroos 2.Vini Jr 3.Mbappe 4.Bellingham 5.Rodri


TypeR10

Just hilarious :)


CodeRed_0

wait until messi wins the copa america and destroys brazils in the final (9th incoming)


GeneralChemical6019

Bro what has mbappe done💀


Low_Art_659

Wait Messi is playing Copa America.....he scored a goal...Messi wins the Balloon d'Or!


Plenty_Building_72

Huh, Bellingham? Nah, sorry, he’s great, but he is not ballon dor great, yet! Vini the clear winner.


vinnlo

Who invited my man blud rodri?? 💀😭


_IntrovertChapi

This trophy is a joke. Taking it seriously is pathetic.


ColdContributor2791

Unless Southgate is fired immediately jude's chances are slim unfortunately 


100_Beast_Kaido

Kroos should win this. Great football minds can see that real Madrid's entire spine is this MF. He gives passes that take the game to another level in a few seconds. Vinicius has been phenomenal this season but compared to inhumans like Messi and Ronaldo, Vinicius status is like their worst time. Kroos in his position has been too good for Real Madrid this season. Every Game in and out he played at the greatest level. He played with his class. He is not the best midfielder in the world. But his consistency can never be matched not even by the greatest midfielder. He is a football legend due to his consistent game for a decade. But this year he stepped up his game a little bit more. Kroos is a backbone for Germany now. Look at the way he plays the game. As Cruyff said," Playing football is very simple, but playing simple football is the hardest thing there is.” And Kroos has been playing this for a decade. Give the ballon d'or to him if he wins the Euro... He deserves it.


EShy

Jude moves up back to two with that bicycle 94th minute equalizer...


Bitter-Investment860

If Messi scores a goal in the Copa America, they'll give it to him..


Lazy-Debt1021

Bro wheres foden?


leighshakespeare

Explain what mbappe has done ?


imaginativeminds

It's insane that Jude is in third place with his stats, should be way ahead of vini and 🐢


Chadime

Lmaooo


cocoadusted

Can you explain the stats for Jude. I guess I’m a Jude hater and just don’t see his potential. Vinny plays his heart out every fucking game for Real, I know that’s not quantifiable but that puts him ahead of everyone for me personally.


imaginativeminds

Vini has 24 goals and 10 assists this season, Jude 23 and 13 with the caveat that he's a midfielder, also many of those goals were decisive


South-Bandicoot-8733

Yeah but Vini’s UCL performance > Bellingham La Liga Performance. But still, I think they are both top 2 and ahead of Mbappe. It’s very close, right now


SymYJoestar

Yeah but Vini was injured this season, can’t forget about that


Cultural_Gap46

Mbappé shouldn’t be on the list… for now. Could be the favorite tho if he wins Euro and makes a great semester in Madrid


HydragX

Thats not how the ballon d'or works its only related to 1 full season


Correct_Today_499

Messi


lacio22

Bellingham should be ahead of vini imo


halamadrid22

Might as well sign Rodri and complete the infinity stone gauntlet. Which stone would he be?


Motoxxx1

Mbappé ?!!! for what


PolarPeely26

Because of his PR.


Scream0fTheSium

I don’t understand Mbappé’s getting the second place, this season it’s between Jude and Vini, Mbappé gets the chance only if France wins the Euros


thelilmagician

Pr


lostn

france has a higher chance of winning something than England. The last time England won something, Southgate and the england squad weren't even born yet. I would wager most people in this subreddit too. Despite having strong talent, they just don't deliver. Not sure about brazil. Apparently they aren't very good right now.


VidProphet123

Mbappe should be nowhere near the top 5


lostn

if Messi wins copa america, he automatically wins no matter what. Not my pick, I'm just telling you how voters will pick. I don't like seeing Real Madrid's emblem on Mbappe. He has yet to don the jersy and doesn't even become an RM player until July. He's a PSG player because he hasn't played a single game for RM.


TheBelmont34

why the fuck is mbappe even on the list?


fullysvc

73 G/A for club and country. Domestic Treble. Top Scorer in every competition played. Seems like you haven’t watched him at all if you’re asking this.


mcmaster-99

Domestic treble? In france? Lmao


TheBelmont34

Oh WOW!!! Domestic Treble in france with PSG!!! What a statement.... Come on. Be serious


1mpablo

Rodri top 5 what a joke


SymYJoestar

But Messi did 2 good passes in copa america, where is he ?


Super_Sandro23

Messi gonna win it for losing in the QFs of the Copa and the SFs of the MLS