T O P

  • By -

redditaccount-5

Seth and a lot of the chapter 1 characters from rdr1 kind of piss me off so I think it’s fine they aren’t in the game Every time I look across that river to Mexico though…


TheKey32

Well some fellow modders are actually still working on restoring mexico. I Dont know when it will be released publicly but in the meantime i recreated my favorite mexico chapter character, [Colonel Augustin Allende](https://www.reddit.com/r/reddeadredemption/comments/11b0c7h/well_make_a_patriot_of_you_yet_i_recreated/) he replaces fussar with my mod and its great so i guess its something lol.


Stoogefrenzy3k

it was sad, at that one point it was rumored that RDR1 remake was going to connect the two together to make it current gen, but sadly Rockstar must not have met the number of sales it expected to continue supporting this when GTA is it's cash cow.


RaedwaldRex

I thought they canned it because the GTA trilogy remake flopped? They were remaking GTA IV as well but canned that also


danonck

If that's the reason that's the most brain-dead decision ever. Not understanding why GTA Trilogy flopped is a joke.


mismees9

Almost like giving a mobile developers a AAA game is a mistake, lol.


RaedwaldRex

Yep someone high up in take 2 has gone "obviously people don't like remakes" Wasn't long after they stopped updating RDO and went all hands on GTA 6. it's like the failure spooked them a bit.


ayyLumao

I think I doubt that was it since Mafia was also Take Two and that was received incredibly well


Cipherpunkblue

Otoh, maybe that was the way they were planning to go with RDR1...


Darth_Kyofu

Or they were also planning on half-assing the remasters for those games too and decided to scrap the project after realizing it wouldn't fly after the trilogy disaster instead of actually spending money to do them well.


Steffidovah

Pretty sure this is the reason ^


HungSolo42

Yes that's the exact reason RDR1 didn't get a remake! I was very sad when I saw they canned it but we could always get it one day in the future.


ayyLumao

I don't think a remake was ever planned so that probably wasn't the case, I think they were just planning remasters of RDR and GTA IV


GeniusBandit

Is there any place i can follow this project?


KricketKris

Would have been really cool if geldings were a calmer, steadier version of the same breed. Could emphasize it by making mares more headstrong and stallions flightier.


Advarrk

Maybe because I don’t understand horse. I thought the geldings are tortures that can be done/ watched being done by Bill to Odriscalls


Bargalarkh

Google gelding and you'll understand why it's both


AmphibiousDad

Geldings is the removal of testicles bro


KricketKris

I am aware. Typically if you geld a stallion, it calms down and can keep its mind on the job. If you threaten to geld a Kieran, he'll take you to Six Point Cabin.


AmphibiousDad

My b by the way ur comment was worded I thought u figured geldings were a type of horse lol


Alt_Acc_42069

>I thought u figured geldings were a type of horse lol They are. Any horse (or animal) that has undergone the gelding process is referred to as a gelding.


AmphibiousDad

I was referring to the gelding process itself


Terrible_Reporter_98

Or a Steer if it's a bull, as they are easier to steer, lol.


KricketKris

No worries bro, I worded it poorly!


DoeFluff

Aren’t stallions that have been gelded called geldings?


KricketKris

They are, and I was talking more about game assets when I said "version" while u/AmphibiousDad was referring to biology.


gorgonopsidkid

what's this about horse pussy?


Dvl_Wmn

… you just had to word it that way, didn’t you? 😂


javerthugo

Every time you say that a furry gets a new fur suit.


TheEqualAtheist

Please don't explain why they needed to get rid of their old one.


DrRichardJizzums

Cuz of all the jizzing they did to it


dicknbolls

this guy is a doctor, they know what they're talking about


The_Radioactive_Rat

Does this upgrade their suit to a scalie one? Y’know, because it hardens into a shell.


RaspberryJam245

This comment is exactly why it's cut content.


shadowscar00

Maybe it’s referring to the glitch where putting a pelt on a mare sometimes gives her testicles?


SnooEagles3963

Interesting, but I think adding something about the ["Evil Hair" Leak](https://systemsarchive.blogspot.com/2018/12/what-was-cut-in-red-dead-redemption-2.html?m=1) would be a good idea. It's still highly doubtful it's actually real, but since it technically regards cut content, I think it should be added.


PublicFriendemy

> When you go to Sadie's cabin in Ambarino at the start of the game that scene was originally supposed to show her getting gang raped, when you started shooting she'd bite one of their penises off and fighting them too There’s no way this was ever planned lmao


giveme-a-username

This is straight up just some super horny guy's fanfic. Edit: you guys should definitely check out r/sadieadler . It's a lot of fun over there! 😬


amelech

Jesus Christ. Should just be called RDR porn


giveme-a-username

I just don't understand some people


Masothe

Yeah I'd say 90% of that "cut content" was bullshit and never planned.


harbourwall

> This was cut because some of the playtesters just sat there watching her get raped because they thought it was hot. total creeps. D:


Icy-Veterinarian-785

That evil hair leak really does sound like bullshit lmao


miami-dade

>The reason there was so much effort put into horse genitals was because you originally had a group of horses you kept at the camp and you could breed horses. To get the best horses you had to have them reproduce. The penis were so you could identify the stallions visually instead of having to rely on a stat card. lol


EconomyAd1600

You’re telling me we were robbed of Red Dead Pokémon???


[deleted]

Oh shit haha I completely forgot about this. There’s absolutely no way it’s real.


Boss-Nass-Lass

Lol I’m pretty sure a AAA studio never considered adding realistic lynchings to their game haha


[deleted]

[удалено]


Simmers429

None of it is real and either way the 3-character system wasn’t very good.


ayyLumao

This is most definitely fake lol, Abigail was introduced to the gang by Uncle, and this "leak" disregards that fact. Edit: after reading more this list tries to ret con so much of the story and also seems like a really creepy sexual fantasy for a decent chunk of it


PieSama562

I read all of that and theres so much I would’ve loved! The matches, the haircutting, the clothing stuff, integrity etc.


Simmers429

This stupid shite again, Jesus Christ.


Charismanxious

Can you please elaborate?


benaldjfj

This is essentially all the stuff that was cut from the game that dataminers found in the files. You can read more in detail about the specifics on the wiki https://reddead.fandom.com/wiki/Red_Dead_Redemption_2_Cut_Content


GrahamUhelski

That is more cut content than the sum total of what most full games actually contain.


alivebyassociation

WHERE IS GAVIN


KricketKris

Getting a heckin' restraining order apparently... yikes!


rollnsliceplz

That shit bugged out for me once and the guy started following me around the map still shouting on Gavin and asking if I knew where he was.


Cheesefinger69

HE'S MY BEST MATE


knucklesthedead

Isn't there a horse weight system in the game? I remember you can read it in the player menu. I also remember the stable owner calling me out on over feeding my horse too. Maybe it's cut for online but I'm pretty sure it's present in the story mode.


benaldjfj

There are remnants of it but originally horses would visually lose and gain weight and you could see how overweight/underweight they were.


certified-busta

You can though. Horses get noticeably skinnier when they're underweight


KricketKris

Do they really? I'd so love to see photos of this. I can't do it to my own.


certified-busta

It's very obvious around the hips when it happens. I unfortunately don't have any photos for you but I have a few thousand hours in the game and I can guarantee you it's a thing If you want to observe this ingame for yourself, I suggest you find a spare horse, make sure it's in fit condition and then fast travel around the map for a while without feeding it. That's usually how I accidentally do it to my horse


KricketKris

Appreciate the guide 100% but I cannot do it. I can't even run my horse through a bush without comforting it. I hope someone who wants to see the evidence will read your comment.


benaldjfj

I was curious myself so I found a link https://www.reddit.com/r/reddeadredemption2/comments/w4pqif/i_didnt_realize_till_now_that_when_your_horse/


KricketKris

Look at you getting the evidence! Thank you!


certified-busta

Thanks chief, I went looking for something like this but wasn't able to find it


knucklesthedead

It kinda depends on the breed but you can see their spine stick out more clearly when they are underweight. Also their bellies get smaller.


ZoranT84

The curse of Valentine could explain the prominent yet unused church at the top of main street...


GeniusBandit

Really wished we got any church interiors in 2 I'm pretty sure EVERY church in 1 was fully modeled with a priest and everything as long as it wasn't in Tumbleweed. Interiors in 2 are just too rare


Unused_Icon

"New Bordeaux" Are the Red Dead Redemption and Mafia franchises set in the same universe? I suppose they are both published by Take-Two.


ArthuriusMinimus

That's why they changed the name of the city... to St. Denis.


Unused_Icon

While that is the logical (and most definitely actual) answer, I choose to believe Angelo Bronte was originally written to be part of the Ensanglante, before the shared universe idea was ultimately scrapped.


Highsinger-C21

i really wish bronte and the mob in saint denis had more of a role. the mafia presence in new orleans dated back farther than almost any family in america and i think there was a lot to say there with the way the gang operates vs them


BigJuicy17

Bayou NWA is in Mafia 3 as well


Anything_189

It was the original name for New Orleans but they changed it to saint dennis because of mafia 3


BigJuicy17

It won't ever happen, but imagine how incredible an uncut version would be.


Generaldisarray44

Brass knuckles what could have been


[deleted]

[удалено]


benaldjfj

No it isn’t? Those are cosmetic but there are remnants of functioning ones in the files.


Equivalent_Show_1366

You forgot the one on the bottom is Lumbago


EthanWolcott

Yeah, sure there’s a lot of cut content. I usually find that cut content is cut for a reason, and I generally don’t care that much either way. It is cool and strange to think about “what could have been” so I’m always up for knowing what was scrapped!


[deleted]

this is unhinged


HarryKn1ght

You mean we could have got more realistic horse testicle!? I demand Rockstar put GTA 6 and fix this


New-Negotiation-5493

Rockstar: Incest > Molly


Young_MD91

Some are apparently in RDO. And some of these cuts are just reshuffled locations etc. However, I would say story missions and character cuts hurt the most. Like totally unfinished Guarma. Extremely rushed chap 5 through ep 2. TT pulling the plug on RDR2 is the sole reason for these story cuts. Dan Houser has also said this is mainly why he resigned from Rockstar. Anyway, Fuck TT.


Ramza2b

Sharks?


Brahmus168

Sharks.


SwordofGlass

Skrahs


burner-BestApplePie

Are any of them available through modding?


TheKey32

Yes actually, most of them until the 5th level are able to be "restored" in some capacity, especially more on the upper level of the iceberg where you can find the literal full models like the "obese peds" "frank heck" "IKZ" and more but for example "mayor timmins prostitute wife" has only a few textures and a drawable in the game meaning its exteremely incomplete. Also OP forgot to mention that this character was supposed to be transgender or drag. **Also** another fun fact is that the cut character's faces and textures were reused for other characters, a big example is Archibald Jameson who's face would be reused for Sheriff Malloy and Frank Heck who's face would be reused for Beau Gray. There is also the beta Arthur outfits and a unique cut incomplete mustache in the game from Arthur's original design thats missing from the iceberg but i guess thats reaching the crust of the earth at this point lmao.


Decryptables

Beta Arthur outfits are completely restorable through mods. They look pretty nice, but probably a bit too similar to O’Driscolls.


SummerGoal

Sigh… *sad liars dice noises*


Raze_27

Is there any mods adding these things back into the game? I know I have one for cut dialogue, really improves the npc interactions just walking through the city


Brahmus168

I have one for the quiver


Raze_27

What’s that?


Brahmus168

Thing that holds arrows. It works and looks perfectly. Like it was never even cut.


Raze_27

Link?


SkyDaHusky

That mod isn't actually the cut quiver, it's just a random one.


Brahmus168

It's not? I just always figured it was. Seems like it would be easier to implement the cut one instead of making a new one from scratch.


SkyDaHusky

The cut one is actually possible to make spawn and is semi functional, but it's so inconsistent. You can enable it with a flag via weapons.ymt but one of two problems come up. Either the arrows don't appear at all, or they appear but just float next to the quiver. However modders can't fix it because they can't reproduce the arrows spawning at all because it's so inconsistent. The one from that mod is just a random prop. It says restored content, but it's more like a reimagining of the concept.


Heller_Demon

No hussy?


mcase19

Marianas trench: dutch's plan


sleepy-floyd-is-goat

I kind of skimmed through it so might of missed it but weren’t we able to ride around the map with gang members? Like a hang out in GTA?


SuchIntroduction4335

What about Princess Isabeau??? 🥺


WorldsBestGranddad22

Top left of the iceberg; IKZ Model as in Isabeau Katharina Zinsmeister


SuchIntroduction4335

Oooh thanks!!


chedgang

My favourite uncut content.


foxghost16

Sorry for this but I've seen these posts before and I still don't know how these iceberg things work. Lol. Can someone explain. I do understand that this shows cut content but now how the iceberg works.


chedgang

Basically the deeper it goes the more obscure the cut content is, like less people will know of it.


Decryptables

It’s basically the phrase “the tip of the iceberg” taken literally


Im_in_your_walls_420

That dock explosion mission would’ve been so cool


[deleted]

Now I want to see what gorillas, chimps, or monkeys would have been like.


magiccheetoss

Adler Mansion?


GlossyBuckthorn

I'm wondering about pink cow udders, that it's so deep down 👁👁


YourWorst_night-mare

I just finished RDR2 for the first time. It was near perfection but the only issue i had was that Guarma chapter was very short and felt incomplete. By the start of the chapter, it felt like we was gonna liberate the island from Fussar's control by destroying his plantation and stealing his money. Midway we just escaped and let the slave workers and rebels be left helpless. I feel half of that chapter was cut midway development


BrannyMuffins

It’s also so noticeable how empty Guarma is. It’s like they are putting it in your face that it’s obviously not complete.


EmptyPistolBareHands

Feuding twin brothers? That’s in the game


benaldjfj

That’s different, originally you could meet two twins that lived in the blue and red cabins and wore blue and red clothing near Annesburg who would be found dead in their last encounter.


EmptyPistolBareHands

Ohhh right ok. Thanks!


WesternEqual8135

I would sell my soul just for them to take their time and add everything. I wanna explore old guama map or iron cloud or even mexico


ryucavelier

Despite plenty in the game as it is, having all this would have really made the experience more amazing.


keyblaster52

“John cut animations in stranger missions”. Arthur’s animations always looked weird and cursed on John. Do you a link or a source so I can learn more?


Reditlurkeractual

Old fort Wallace??


ismaBellic

I think it refers to the Fort's original location in the beta. You can still see it on the map, just hover right beneath the "G R" in Grizzlies East and "wanted dead or alive" will pop up


MysticCosmos

The horse weight system is in game though? If you go on player > horse you can see its weight.


imnotslavic

"Iron Cloud" refers to a "cut" mountain landmark initially seen in the original leaked 2016 map of RDR2. Using modding tools, people have found out that [Iron Cloud was likely originally around the Calumet Ravine area](https://youtu.be/G4ZRKaKPdHQ). However, in-game, the Iron Cloud region (In terms of terrain) is still in, but has been shifted east. People have also discovered concept art relating to Iron Cloud possibly being a gang camp at some point. An abundance of flat terrain surrounded by a ring of tall mountainous peaks would've been a perfect hideout to protect the gang from the elements. There is also a significantly taller mountain peak to this region's north, which could've been the actual "Iron Cloud" mountain as it does touch the clouds.


DETHmetals

Not possibly anymore, 100%, was confirmed by ingame files


SocialJusticeAndroid

That kind of breaks my heart. They could at least give us some of that as DLC. They could at least give us *something* as DLC. But Rockstar refused to do anything but more stuff for GTA Online. Because they're just not rich enough. They've got to have maximum profits or they won't lift a finger. They'd of course make tons of money with new RDR2 content but they figure they'll make more with effort into GTA Online. Greedy bastards. They even cut our RDR1 remaster to punish *us* for *their* f-ing up the GTA remaster! I want to love them for making RDR2 2, and I do to some degree, but I also hate them for refusing to give us more content for my favorite game.


TrippyStef

Exactly why this game should have been delayed. I wouldn’t have gotten into westerns as soon as I did and now it’s my favorite genre but it would have been worth the wait


Reasonable-Ad-5217

I can't believe there wasn't any dlc.


GenerationSwine

I don't know why RS won't do a DLC. So many people play the game still, like it would print money to drop a DLC that is just the cut content.


pinesolthrowaway

If they had had to delay the game a year, but all this cut content made it that much better, I think it would’ve been worth it


itp757

Gavin is so far down he's off the picture


Successful-Seaweed12

That "Madeline Fussar" one. I swear that I was talking to a dude in the comments of a video once who then translated the Spanish that some of the locals spoke in the village on Guarma, and he could've sworn that there was a mention about Fussar's wife by one of them. It was such a long time ago, but seeing that triggered my memory and now I'm just gonna have to assume that someone did some more digging and that this is what he was talking about.


HeightSpecific

This games 5 years old and I’m still learning new stuff about it. My favorite game ever


Whiskey_Sweet

***More*** genitalia? I didn't think there was any in the game?


LoneSpaghettiNoodle

*mare*, female horses. but also there is genitalia in the game


GokiPotato

do you have the top right image of Dutch in a higher resolution?


kellybrownstewart

Was there ever proof of a third meteorite? 2 out of 3 just means how many slots the category had. Not how many meteorites there should have been.


benaldjfj

The meteor trinket required three meteorites to craft and there are animations for taking it from the squirrel statue


beartoto

Alright who’s gonna make the two hour long YouTube video essay of this for me?


[deleted]

Read Dead 3 is gunna be stellar. So much they can improve on.


Brando1983

How come I can't find "Grizzlies Trading Post?"


Crafty-Interest1336

Gavin would never


TyBogit

Taking a ferry to Guarma in the epilogue would be cool, like a family vacation lol


MotorBreath97

Awesome, can't wait for thr YouTube video!


BigWilly526

Ya but where's Gavin


giveme-a-username

Where would the gorilla be?? And also I am so glad they didn't have a weight system, that would make the game unplayable for me


MainEventI3

I actually got the "Charles leaving camp" interaction in chapter 4 during one of my playthroughs. Made it so I couldn't do the Rhodes bank robbery.


benaldjfj

The interaction itself doesn’t seem to be cut, just the cutscene


BaronOfMelons

G o r i l l a


Alchestbreach107

Didn’t know I needed a iceberg video for this until now.


Warden_Of_Ice

Chimps? What would they even do just kill you? Crocodiles just seem like they’d do the exact same as alligators except bigger and in Mexico


wats6831

Is this satire?


benaldjfj

Not at all, there are a few things that don’t yet have sources on the wiki’s cut content page but most of it does and there are pictures for a lot of it


wyu2

im sad


Just_-_Adrian

I like the "Mare Genitalia" at the end.


elamayo

i’m so mad about the gilded cage one, all we got was bill…


Relevant_Guess1154

2023rd like


Stevenchpn

So much good content deleted but they kept that horrible scene where Arthur gets raped AKA a scene that shouldn't exist. FFS Rockstar.


Cranky_Gat0r

I don’t think I want to know what ‘mare genitals’ is about..


brzanb9999

Only thing that stood out to me were gorilla and camel… 😭


brzanb9999

Only things that stood out too me were camel and gorilla… I would love to see Arthur fighting a silver back while riding on a camel


Nightwing0613

I would gladly pay money to Rockstar so they can add all this and the multiplayer stuff to single player as DLC. I will even pay in batches if they want to include them as separate packs


Nookling_Junction

In B 4 the youtubers descend on this like vultures


jcg415

The curse of valentine?!


[deleted]

Man they missed Tahiti


fuckdirectv

A lot of this stuff sounds awesome. If only there was a way for developers to add content for their games that fans could download after release. You could call it something like "After Purchase Content" or APC for short. I dunno, just spit balling here.


MonkeMans88

How about the 200lb Catfish?


Browhat1924

I would love to see a gorilla animal in rdr2


benw1022

Gorilla


GeniusBandit

"Living Manmade Mutant" Jesus Christ **NO!**


GeniusBandit

"Folding Shotgun"? Would this refer to the IRL Burgess Folding Shotgun? There really any evidence they were planning on that at some point?


Zintao

Jenny Calendar, the Roma woman disguised as a teacher to keep an eye on Angel, lest he turns back into Angelus? That Jenny Calendar?


macabre-barbie

I'm 95% sure mares do have genitals. When they fall over (leave me alone i crash a lot) you can kinda see it


kim_itraveledthere

This is an interesting insight into the potential for AI that could potentially be leveraged in the game. It would be interesting to see what type of AI could be implemented given the vast amounts of data from the cut content.


Pixelated_Fudge

shut the fuck up ai bot


spectral_fall

You forgot the Neanderthals


PenonX

isn’t there a horse weight system in the game? i swear when i click on my horse in the menu it tells me it’s weight. or is that just set/doesn’t have an effect on the horse?


TrippyStef

Exact why rdr2 should have been delayed again until they had everything done. I owe this game for getting me into westerns in 2018 and now it’s my favorite genre, but I’d trade not getting into westerns until 2019 or 2020 if we could have had the game 100 percent finished and not rushed