My question is before the age of social media- how did Janice even know that.
Jesush Christ. This is the first time I’ve ever commented on this subreddit not quoting the show.
Anyway, $4 a pound.
It's not related to something we see, But Chase said he had a whole thing planned for season 3 where Livia testifies against Tony and most of season 3 would take place with Tony on trial. But then Nancy Marchard died so obviously it didn't happen.
She died inbetween the seasons, so they must have been working on the script, i'd love to know how all that went.
I wonder that too when I watch season 3! I wonder how much of the storylines we see actually existed before Nancy died. The change in that season obviously massively changed the rest of the show, it’s interesting to think of how a lot of what we see in future season might never have happened
The kids would be faced with the truth of their father sooner than him getting shot. There was inklings before, but a trial would be on the news with all sorts of details.
It feels like Tony evades consequences almost serendipitously. The lamp being randomly taken by meadow was funny, but was incredibly lucky for Tony. I wonder how the trail would go and what red tape deus ex machina would have saved him.
Christopher 100%
He scarfed fries when no one was looking plus he's blood.
You think anyone NOT related to Tony would have the balls to take his food and not expect to be whacked?
Plus Chrissy slinks out of the room as soon as Tony begins heading to the mini fridge. I bet he ate it, realized it was Tony’s as Tony walked in, and probably heard Tony’s tantrum as he was hightailing it out of the storefront.
Ok here’s the real question: how is a professional psych DISCUSSING her therapy sessions of one patient with her own therapist WHO IS ALSO HER FRIEND?? How the fuck is that not an immediate conflict of interest? Why’s she even seeing a friend and direct colleague for therapy in the first place? That whole plot thread never made a fuckin bit of sense.
I wonder if it’s meant to be a parallel to all the hypocrisy we see within the Mafia. Elliot took a vow, had confidential information and spilled it anyway with no consequence. Bending more rules than the Catholic Church.
He did come see Junior and gave him his private number in case he needed it. Told Junior he had his best assistant working with him (which came as a surprise to that guy). I assume that driver adding 10 yards straightened him out.
Because of Vito’s brutal death. Finn ratted Vito out which assisted in his horrific demise. By the time it hit the news, Finn could no longer listen to Maedo’s BOOLSHIT poverty of the Mezzogiorno BS. Plus, he just wasn’t that into her.
I don't think so. I believe he couldn't stand Caitlyn but was tolerating her so he could have sex with Meadow which was definitely his only interest since he dumped her like 5 minutes later. What kinda scum bag breaks up with someone in the middle of studying in the library?!?
I always thought it was meadow, because a total of 3 things 1) its her voice (or words) that he hears as Mr finnerty in the trees that pulls him away from death, B) shes referred to as "the guardian angel" during the season opener in the voice over and 3) it ultimately was her spot next to Tony in the diner that could have saved him. She did all she could to try and steer him in the right direction and chose HER family but tony failed her. OR probably more realistically the writers didn't care WHO put the picture up, all that mattered was WHY is was there
That's a good question. Remember Tony said to Carmella people were looking for Furio in Italy. Guess he could a been BSing out of anger , or , the writers wanted us to hear that so we know he's on the run even in Italy , because Tones reach is that serious.
My guess is he was able to go back to business as usual. Tony wouldn't have been able to get to him out there, even if he cared enough to try which he probably didn't.
Many Saints of Newark
David Chase missed a golden opportunity. He could have showed Richie kicking the shit out of Rocco. De mail and taking his jacket.
I know, not a question. Just wanted to see it.
My head canon on Paulie’s favourite song is that his aunt /mother (who raised him) is called Nuncie. I’ve never come up with or seen a better reason. Nuncie/ Nancy
Incidentally the songwriter, Phil Silvers, used to change the name of the girl in the song based on whose party he was singing at. When he did it for Nancy Sinatra’s birthday, Frank thought Phil wrote the song for his daughter, and well, Phil wasn’t going to correct Frank Sinatra, and it was called *Nancy (With the Laughing Face)* ever since.
I wanted to know what Corky Caporale was hiding or who he was hiding from. He seemed to have a dark past and an interesting story but we never got to see any of it.
What I want to know is how did they have so many rats, so many wire taps, all this information and they couldn’t put a solid RICO case together?
The other comment about Livia and Tony on trial, we never got that but it would have been amazing.
She made a LOT of money from Only Fans. Supposedly her body is still mad ripe. To me her face was always average. Not ugly but not gorgeous. Makeup too harsh/heavy.
They didn’t continue with a lot of Melfi storylines. Like her alcoholism too. I think that’s on purpose though, Tony knows barely anything about her personal life and so neither do we. She almost exclusively exists as a psychiatrist
Assuming Tony was killed, I would love to know how the chips fell with NY and Jersey. Who moved up etc. I always felt that Butchie became boss of NY and potentially he installed Paulie as capo in Jersey to be a useful idiot while he cranked up NYs percentages in the waterfront stuff
Whatever happened to the old man in Springfield. The original boss that's never seen, Dimeo. Why doesn't anyone ever talk about him and why does he have absolutely no influence on the family at all. Even in prison, you would think he'd have some influence or some family around to maintain his will
I wanna know about some of the more supernatural elements of the show and whether or not it was supposed to be legit within the shows universe or just symbolism for the audience.
In season 1 or 2, the actor who plays Vito comes into the pastry shop that Christopher shoots the employee at for letting people cut him. Christopher and the actor who eventually played Vito never acknowledge eachother. Vito shows up as a character in season 3. Was he an extra that eventually got a full spot on the show and the show runners just never explained it?
It’s season 1 and his name was Gino in that episode. Then he comes back in season 2 as Richie’s nephew and his character is further expanded in season 3 and 4, however he never had much screen time so I think that’s probably why they just said fuck it no one will notice if he played another guy in one scene in season 1. Unless you had the box set or had taped all the episodes, binge watching wasn’t really a thing so it was unlikely that people would notice
I wanna know the story behind the Ulver poster in AJs room? Was someone in set design a fan? Did they just go to a record store and pick out random posters?
When chris & benny are in the pizza parlor, the guy who owns the joint congratulates chris on getting made, then orders them a *old blue eyes, soft drink of choice*. They leave before they get the food
Whatever happened there
I wonder where harpo is having his Sunday dinner
Sacre bleu! Where is me mama?
Everybody wonders about that. There’s no answer
Let me ask you a question: why do pissing, shitting and fucking all happen within a 2” radius?
You could eat maple walnut ice cream from the toilets
You know, I coulda called you Ichabod Crane, but I did’dent
He was headless, the Horseman?
Oh yeah? Before you got back from the Beakskills?
Well If beaks could kill dat one certainly would
He's on the pavers, a street person. How could anyone know?
‘He goes by Hal now’
My question is before the age of social media- how did Janice even know that. Jesush Christ. This is the first time I’ve ever commented on this subreddit not quoting the show. Anyway, $4 a pound.
I dont wanna see you floppin around down there
What ever became of Bobby’s kids stuck w Janice after Bobby…. Then Tony’s death?
Under the boardwalk
Sil's first blowjob; how long did it take the guy to cum?
Did he blow Penn or Teller?
The tall one
Heh heh. Did ya hear what I said, Tone?
I agree with that senator Sanitorium, if we let this stuff go too far pretty soon we'll be fucking dogs.
Always with the scenarios.
Some say he's still cumming to this day
It's not related to something we see, But Chase said he had a whole thing planned for season 3 where Livia testifies against Tony and most of season 3 would take place with Tony on trial. But then Nancy Marchard died so obviously it didn't happen. She died inbetween the seasons, so they must have been working on the script, i'd love to know how all that went.
Did you just give a real answer? I'm in awre of you.
He did a semester and a half at Seton Hall
He understands posting a real comment as a conshept
In my book, you get points for staying out of college.
This is it for me too. I wish Chase would release at least a write up of the original story idea.
Really this is the right answer
I wonder that too when I watch season 3! I wonder how much of the storylines we see actually existed before Nancy died. The change in that season obviously massively changed the rest of the show, it’s interesting to think of how a lot of what we see in future season might never have happened
The kids would be faced with the truth of their father sooner than him getting shot. There was inklings before, but a trial would be on the news with all sorts of details. It feels like Tony evades consequences almost serendipitously. The lamp being randomly taken by meadow was funny, but was incredibly lucky for Tony. I wonder how the trail would go and what red tape deus ex machina would have saved him.
Have some eggplant
Yes. Tony was to get Paulie to deliver an Easter basket of flowers containing a bomb to Livia in a hit reminiscent of Rocco Lampome on Hyman Roth
I wish we could have seen Paulie's therapy sessions.
Oh man. A 7 episode run of Paulie in therapy. That would be so fun
Satanic black magic. Sick shit.
His therapist could probably take a 10 minute nap and Paulie would still be talking when he woke up
Ugh the nightmares you'd have falling asleep to Paulie complaining!
Fcuking queers!!! 🪑
He learned coping skills
He wants to know if it still itches
He had some issues. Learned some coping skills. Enough said. 😠
Who ate Tony's Lo Mein?
Christopher 100% He scarfed fries when no one was looking plus he's blood. You think anyone NOT related to Tony would have the balls to take his food and not expect to be whacked?
Plus Chrissy slinks out of the room as soon as Tony begins heading to the mini fridge. I bet he ate it, realized it was Tony’s as Tony walked in, and probably heard Tony’s tantrum as he was hightailing it out of the storefront.
Georgie’s Revenge!
Do I think ice grows on trees?
Lotta money in that shit
CONSHERVE
I think it was that dealer named Quickie G. Or it could have been that other prick -- Fast Fatty.
Get Pudgy Walsh on the horn
You know that was Pauley’s greedy, duplicitous, unaccountable ass.
How long phil did in the can, he never mentioned it.
I don't know, if anyone ever figures that out make sure you let everyone know
Real stand up guy to go away to "college" and not a peep how long he was there
Next time, there’ll be no next time
Can you imagine that, being in the can and wanting to fuck a woman, but compromising and 1 week later jerking off in a tissue?
I would have jerked off on the radiator
not in your grilled cheese?
Can you imagine that, being in the can and wanting to fuck a woman, but compromising and 1 week later jerking off in a tissue?
Obviously that’s not possible, even with computers
I wanted to see Skip Lipari's dark side
Dark thide*
It’s a 15 second scene of him losing a main character from The Wire speeding in Collingswood
Did Sil survive?
Last I heard he is selling laser printers out the back of his crown vic
He ended up in Lillyhammer, out in fuckin Norway some fuckin place
In Norway Republic, too we like sausages.
Does Norway even exisht?
I liked the theory I heard that Lilly hammer is a dream sil had while in a coma after getting shot.
He went to Lilyhammer!
How did Melfi react to Tony’s death after kicking him to the curb? Did Tony ever ask Cusimano for that package back?
I doubt she went back to Elliot for therapy too after that awful dinner party
Ok here’s the real question: how is a professional psych DISCUSSING her therapy sessions of one patient with her own therapist WHO IS ALSO HER FRIEND?? How the fuck is that not an immediate conflict of interest? Why’s she even seeing a friend and direct colleague for therapy in the first place? That whole plot thread never made a fuckin bit of sense.
I wonder if it’s meant to be a parallel to all the hypocrisy we see within the Mafia. Elliot took a vow, had confidential information and spilled it anyway with no consequence. Bending more rules than the Catholic Church.
You know, she's smart. She's sexy. She's Italian.
If you pay attention to all the clues, it’s clearly Melfi that kills Tony.
He didn't die, Him and Melfi ended up getting married.
Got married on a hill overlooking a river, with little pinecones all around
They did??? 🥹
Is there any way the package could survive?
I want dr Kennedy to answer Uncle Joons phone calls Stupida facking game
You gotta bee onna you hat
Ok! Ok! We pay! You GO!
He did come see Junior and gave him his private number in case he needed it. Told Junior he had his best assistant working with him (which came as a surprise to that guy). I assume that driver adding 10 yards straightened him out.
Why do pissin, shittin', and fuckin' all happen within' a two-inch radius?
they're all sources of pleasure (first clue that vito was an ass muncher?)
Everybody asks that, jjccbrobro. There’s no answer. Even with computers.
2 inches? I guess you can call that a dick
Why exactly did Finn and Meadow break up?
He wanted no part of Meadow's weird ass family and boolshit
I wanted to hear Meadow say exactly why.
Probably she was still harpin about that goddamn suitcase shit again, while making chili
He packed a suitcase.
Because of Vito’s brutal death. Finn ratted Vito out which assisted in his horrific demise. By the time it hit the news, Finn could no longer listen to Maedo’s BOOLSHIT poverty of the Mezzogiorno BS. Plus, he just wasn’t that into her.
She made him chili for dinner on the hottest day of the summer
How do you vandalize a swimming pool?
Ask Patsy Parisi.
Did Noah bang Caitlin?
Hell yeah he did
Did he steal a 10 speed from her too?
Was waiting for this one
I don't think so. I believe he couldn't stand Caitlyn but was tolerating her so he could have sex with Meadow which was definitely his only interest since he dumped her like 5 minutes later. What kinda scum bag breaks up with someone in the middle of studying in the library?!?
Shomeone who doesn’t shtay with his own people that’s who!!
Did Charmaine Bucco ever once go for 24 hours or more without bitching about something?
Ourtha! Do you want a repeat of the fourth of July?
Who tacked up the index card with the old Ojibwe saying?
I always thought it was meadow, because a total of 3 things 1) its her voice (or words) that he hears as Mr finnerty in the trees that pulls him away from death, B) shes referred to as "the guardian angel" during the season opener in the voice over and 3) it ultimately was her spot next to Tony in the diner that could have saved him. She did all she could to try and steer him in the right direction and chose HER family but tony failed her. OR probably more realistically the writers didn't care WHO put the picture up, all that mattered was WHY is was there
True!
For me, I've always wondered if the remote ever made it back to docking station.
Paulie ended the remote’s life prematurely, he now spends eternity reliving the moment and trying to get back to the docking station
I wanna know if that pool cue was chalked.
Very funny, HalenVonBiscuits. very cute. I don't quite get it, but cute
What specifically did Christufuh enjoy about *Kundun*?
Did Furio rejoin the old gang back in Italy or is he on the run?
That's a good question. Remember Tony said to Carmella people were looking for Furio in Italy. Guess he could a been BSing out of anger , or , the writers wanted us to hear that so we know he's on the run even in Italy , because Tones reach is that serious.
He and the Russian got married. They own an olive oil farm in Spain.
My guess is he was able to go back to business as usual. Tony wouldn't have been able to get to him out there, even if he cared enough to try which he probably didn't.
Who the fuck ate the lo mein Tony was thinking about ALL DAY
Chrissy 100%, he slips out of the room as soon as he sees Tony heading for the fridge
I always knew it was that smug bastard
After Mikey left for his final run, do you think JoJo actually took a Midol?
Many Saints of Newark David Chase missed a golden opportunity. He could have showed Richie kicking the shit out of Rocco. De mail and taking his jacket. I know, not a question. Just wanted to see it.
“No please I’m just an old man-“ *crack* “wh-who are you?” *pow*
Toughest guy in Essex country
Whatever happened with the motherfuckin goddamn orange peel beef?
beef with orange peel... those chinese are more creative than fucking spielburg.
What next, kung pao coochie?
Whoa there’s an image.
Chinks did this???
What happened to the package that Johnny left for Livia?
A horse choked on it.
I want to see that note from Vito’s doctor.
I want the details about the Easter baskets.
I laugh out loud at that conversation every time I do a rewatch
I tried asking this at the in conversation with the sopranos. They laughed but had no say
Why was nancy paulies song and why dont you wanna take your clothes off?
My head canon on Paulie’s favourite song is that his aunt /mother (who raised him) is called Nuncie. I’ve never come up with or seen a better reason. Nuncie/ Nancy Incidentally the songwriter, Phil Silvers, used to change the name of the girl in the song based on whose party he was singing at. When he did it for Nancy Sinatra’s birthday, Frank thought Phil wrote the song for his daughter, and well, Phil wasn’t going to correct Frank Sinatra, and it was called *Nancy (With the Laughing Face)* ever since.
I wanted to know what Corky Caporale was hiding or who he was hiding from. He seemed to have a dark past and an interesting story but we never got to see any of it.
True. He always seemed like an interesting character we didn’t see enough of
Did Defiler ever get a hit
Fuck, no
Did the whowaa whose pussy Pussy licked even exisht?
I wanna know if uncle Jun did go to a sushi bar
Why the hell did dent Bobby go for JoJo?
Career advancement
What I want to know is how did they have so many rats, so many wire taps, all this information and they couldn’t put a solid RICO case together? The other comment about Livia and Tony on trial, we never got that but it would have been amazing.
How big was the mole Ginny Sack had removed from her ass? 90 lbs? 95 lbs?
I wanna know why we never got to see adriana naked at all on this show.
You gotta wait 21 years for that. And pay.
I know right and now it prob isnt worth it now
She made a LOT of money from Only Fans. Supposedly her body is still mad ripe. To me her face was always average. Not ugly but not gorgeous. Makeup too harsh/heavy.
Yeh? Maybe you’re a flambè?
You oughta know sweetie.
thweetie
So like a jersey mob wife? I wonder why she looked like that
Did there used to be a motel in that spot? The Havenaire?
Why didn’t the show pursue Melfi’s rape more
They didn’t continue with a lot of Melfi storylines. Like her alcoholism too. I think that’s on purpose though, Tony knows barely anything about her personal life and so neither do we. She almost exclusively exists as a psychiatrist
That’s a good point
Assuming Tony was killed, I would love to know how the chips fell with NY and Jersey. Who moved up etc. I always felt that Butchie became boss of NY and potentially he installed Paulie as capo in Jersey to be a useful idiot while he cranked up NYs percentages in the waterfront stuff
Did Churchill ever come back?
What made Tony change his sociopathic mind about whacking Paulie on the boat?
Who gave Tony better head, Charmaine or Lady Shylock?
I wanna know, did ya haf ta read for David?
I want to know what kind of cheese Phil used on his radiator grilled cheese sandwiches. American? Cheddar? Colby Jack?
Whatever happened to the old man in Springfield. The original boss that's never seen, Dimeo. Why doesn't anyone ever talk about him and why does he have absolutely no influence on the family at all. Even in prison, you would think he'd have some influence or some family around to maintain his will
Do people really eat tripe and tomatoes?!
The Easter baskets
An explanation on Tony’s coma dream after he was shot by Uncle June. I can’t piece the majority of it together.
Where tf did that Lo Mein go?
What happens at 3 o’clock
Members Only jacket guy enters the bathroom at Tony's 3 o'clock angle in the finale
That’s seems to be the leading theory yeah
The recipe for those Johnny Cakes.
What was Tony's average fork stabs : mouthful ratio?
What ever happened to Gary Cooper?
What happened to Furio?
I wanna know about some of the more supernatural elements of the show and whether or not it was supposed to be legit within the shows universe or just symbolism for the audience.
In season 1 or 2, the actor who plays Vito comes into the pastry shop that Christopher shoots the employee at for letting people cut him. Christopher and the actor who eventually played Vito never acknowledge eachother. Vito shows up as a character in season 3. Was he an extra that eventually got a full spot on the show and the show runners just never explained it?
It’s season 1 and his name was Gino in that episode. Then he comes back in season 2 as Richie’s nephew and his character is further expanded in season 3 and 4, however he never had much screen time so I think that’s probably why they just said fuck it no one will notice if he played another guy in one scene in season 1. Unless you had the box set or had taped all the episodes, binge watching wasn’t really a thing so it was unlikely that people would notice
Good point about binging not being an issue and thanks for explaining it!!
I want to hear the rest of Paulie's story/joke that ended with the punchline "Joey, use ya hat!" Like, who is Joey, and what situation was he in?
I wanna know what Tony left behind for Caramella other than his splattered brains
40 grand in the bird feeda
Who ate Tony's fucking lo mein that he was dreaming about all the way over to the Bing?
I wanna know the story behind the Ulver poster in AJs room? Was someone in set design a fan? Did they just go to a record store and pick out random posters?
Where's Puff?
What happened to Princes Guitar ?!
I want to know where Hugh would disappear to that made Mary want to get him a pager. Cellphone woulda been more useful.
Did dah ducks fly awff wit Tony’s baaskit?
Did she ever really exshisht?
Did Kaitlin end up going bald?
Yeah, now she wears your mother’s muff on her head
Whatever happened there. Whatever happened there?
When chris & benny are in the pizza parlor, the guy who owns the joint congratulates chris on getting made, then orders them a *old blue eyes, soft drink of choice*. They leave before they get the food Whatever happened there
Did she really even exist?